Tuesday, July 16, 2013


2cents smf:  In case you just woke up from a two-week nap, LAUSD teacher Rafe Esquith (“Teach Like Your Hair’s on Fire”) has a new book out; he is on all the chat shows, from NPR to the BBC.  Last weekend I caught him on LAUSD’s own KLCS @ an ungodly hour on a Tavis Smiley re-broadcast  -- gently sticking it to the LAUSD ®eformers, unProfessional Development, Common Core, etc.. I haven't read the book yet so I was only going to reblog one review –- and I went with Valerie Strauss’ from the WaPo HERE.    But Jay Mathews (also on WaPo) has been catching a lot of flack in the Blogosphere/Twitterverse from the ©orporate ®eformers for his complementary review – mainly because of Mathews fame as being The Guy Who Discovered Jaime Escalante.  It was Mathews who declared Escalante The Best Teacher in America back in 1988. Strauss in her review transferred the crown to Esquith – that's why I went with her. [Plus Mathews writes favorably about KIPP charters – and I have never been so frightened for kids as when I visited a KIPP school.]  But I am now reblogging Mathews so I can attach the dark energy.

By Jay Mathews | Washington Post Class Struggle | http://wapo.st/1dDod34

Posted at 02:03 PM ET, 07/14/2013  ::  Rafe Esquith, the most imaginative and productive classroom teacher I know, freely admits he overdoes it.

He works long hours, including Saturdays. He leads his fifth graders in mounting several performances of a Shakespeare play each year. He helps former students prepare for college. This summer he gave speeches in China, took former students to the Oregon Shakespeare Festival, drove their luggage 700 miles, showed students several John Steinbeck haunts, did an 11 day tour for this new book and took students on a Mississippi steamboat ride.

As hyper as he is, after 29 years teaching mostly low-income Hispanic and Korean kids in a small, rundown classroom in Los Angeles he knows what drains teacher energy and ambition. In his new book, “Real Talk for Real Teachers,” he describes this in ways I think nearly every teacher in the country would endorse:

The system, “rather than encourage and support you, . . . actively works to discourage you,” he writes. “Every few years a new ‘game changer’ is announced as the newest set of standards are introduced, but the system never really changes. Veteran teachers know that these standards are no different from the old ones. Taking a page from the politburo, leaders stand in the front of the room at professional development meetings making demands and predictions for their ‘New World Order.’ Good teachers don’t know whether to laugh, cry or quit.

“The most recent sermon on the mount has come to us in the form of Common Core Standards. I am not making this up: the presenter at our first training explained that our job as teachers was ‘to prepare the children to be a part of the international workforce.’ We were also told that the emphasis on imaginative literature was going to be scaled back because children need more nonfiction.”

Let’s give the Cluelessness of the Year award to the presenter who said that to Esquith. He has proven that a close reading of Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird,” Steinbeck’s “Of Mice and Men,” Mark Twain’s “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,” and even Shakespeare can have a magical effect on 10 year olds from homes where English is not the first language, even though he is told such texts are inappropriate for that age group.

Standardized tests have their place. Esquith’s kids do much better on them than other students with similar backgrounds. But the best way to determine a teacher’s worth is to spend time with his students. Ian McKellen, the great English actor, became an Esquith devotee after giving a performance in Los Angeles in which a group of children in the audience way too young for Shakespeare seemed enraptured. In fact, he realized, they were mouthing the dialogue as if they already knew it.

As Esquith says in the book, “real teachers know that real teaching is not based on the Common Core, or blended learning, or the newest notebook of rules and regulations handed out at the Tuesday staff meeting.” His view of the new world order is nicely illustrated by the D.C. Public Schools announcement last year that the city’s 40 lowest performing schools would have to raise their average proficiency rates from 23 percent to a completely ridiculous 63 percent by 2017.

Esquith’s book is full of good advice for teachers, including himself, who want to raise their kids to a new level without killing themselves. He schedules more rest and relaxation into his day. His formula for great teaching is following his best instincts about what works and ignoring expert advice when it contradicts what he knows to be true.

Some schools encourage their teachers to act that way. I wish there were more schools like them.

And now, the reviews of the reviews:


  1. e-learn.net@elearnnet 6h

    #edu #education Praise the exception, but remember the rule - My friend Jay Mathews, the Washington Post

  2.  http://ht.ly/2yowVU

    View summary

  3. Fordham Institute@educationgadfly 8h

    Chester Finn responds to @washingtonpost’s Jay Mathews http://bit.ly/12SQ0rk




    Praise the exception, but remember the rule

    Chester E. Finn, Jr. / July 16, 2013

    My friend Jay Mathews, the Washington Post’s longtime education reporter and columnist, has a spectacular history of identifying and profiling great teachers, including but not limited to Jaime Escalante, David Levin, Mike Feinberg, and Rafe Esquith. He is right to find and laud them. His latest tribute to Esquith and Esquith’s newest book, however, turns into another Common Core slam—and another example of idiotic professional development (inflicted, apparently, by some “presenter” on teachers during a “training” at Esquith’s school in Los Angeles). Ugh. Yuck. Sorry about that.


    But there’s an enormous underlying problem that Mathews understands full well, though he doesn’t mention it in this particular column: If American K–12 education contained three million Esquiths and Escalantes, we wouldn’t need Common Core or NCLB or KIPP or choice or value-added teacher evaluations or anything else. But it doesn’t. And it isn’t going to anytime soon. (For starters, as the NCTQ recently documented….. smf: Uh, oh - You can see where this is going….


LA’s Most Famous Teacher Critiques Common Core

Posted on July 15, 2013 by Alexander Russo | LA School Report | http://bit.ly/15LKYB8

Hobart Elementary Teacher Rafe Esquith, via the Clarion Ledger

Hobart Elementary Teacher Rafe Esquith, via the Clarion Ledger

Rafe Esquith may or may not be LAUSD’s best classroom teacher, but he’s certainly one of the most well-known — at least outside of LA.

His familiarity comes largely thanks to his own writing (including a new book coming out this year) and others like Washington Post education columnist Jay Mathews writing about him as he does again for the second time in a week.

According to Mathews, Esquith is “the most imaginative and productive classroom teacher I know,” tireless and dedicated to current and former teachers alike.  But he’s also critical of the coming Common Core push towards nonfiction, imagination-killing directives from administrators in the central office, and after 29 years in the classroom he’s increasingly aware of the dangers of burnout.

You can read the full Washington Post column here: Why top teacher ignores latest reform directives.

Rafe Esquith and The Hobart Shakespeareans Official Website


No comments: