Saturday, December 20, 2014


By Laurie Udesky | EdSource Today |

December 18, 2014 | As teacher David Ramirez strode around his 7th-grade classroom at Oakland’s Urban Promise Academy, he was taking on a central challenge of the new Common Core standards: how to ensure that students who lack proficiency in English are able to benefit from a more language-based approach to learning complex math concepts.

Most of the students in Ramirez’s class in this small Oakland public school are classified as English learners and most live in immigrant households. Their command of English ranges from minimal, to understanding parts of lessons, to speaking hesitantly. In almost all cases, their native language is Spanish, although the class also includes students whose first language is English. With 23 percent of California’s 6.2 million students classified as English learners, Ramirez’s challenge is one that faces thousands of other teachers across the state.

Seventh-grade boys writing on white board

<<  EdSource Today/Laurie Udesky  Seventh-grade math students at Oakland’s Urban Promise Academy work on solving a math problem.

Under the Common Core State Standards adopted by California, 42 other states and the District of Columbia, math teachers whose students have varying levels of English comprehension are using innovative ways to teach them math, including the vocabulary of math and ways for the students to discuss how they came up with their answers.

The issue of making sure English learners benefit from the Common Core has been the subject of considerable research and discussion. One key finding is that much of what students learn can come from their interactions with fellow students in small group discussions where they analyze a problem, critique each other’s reasoning and find the best way to talk about it. That practice is on full display in Ramirez’s class, where students work in small groups much of the time

In the past, Ramirez said, students may not have known how they reached an answer to a math problem. “With the Common Core,” he said, “teachers are pushed to a new level in order to have students clearly understand what they are doing and why their answer makes sense.”

To bridge the language gulf between the math terms he must use in his class and the limited English proficiency of some of his students, Ramirez spends the first 30 minutes of each class just on math vocabulary.

His lesson on a recent morning focused on “proportional relationships” between quantities, a key part of the 7th-grade Common Core standards.

Ramirez focused on the relationship between two squares of different sizes that he had drawn on the board. He threw out concepts using words like “enlarge,” “reduce” and “scale,” and then illustrated each of them and challenged students to interpret the words’ meanings in groups as he listened to their discussions.

Teachers use other strategies to help English learners understand terminology that may be out of their reach. For example, in a math problem that is written in a narrative form, teachers may tell English learners to circle words that are repeated often in the problem, said Crystal Hoffmann, a project specialist with the Kern Unified High School District who trains teachers to work effectively with English learners.

In groups, Hoffmann said, students focus on the importance of the circled words, talk about them and figure out their meaning. Those small group discussions – a major element of the Common Core’s commitment to collaborative learning – are key to helping push students.

Students who are newer to the English language are not always able to verbalize the reasoning behind their answers, said Jeffrey Grisham, a 5th-grade math teacher at Kennedy Elementary School in Santa Ana.

Small group discussions allow English learners to “express themselves freely,” said Martin Perez, a 4th-grade math teacher at Kennedy Elementary in Santa Ana. “It’s not just about math. It’s about kids that are so intimidated to say anything.”

Grisham makes sure that groups include a mix of students – English learners who sit alongside native and fluent English speakers and those who excel in math.

“The English language learners have learned how to express ideas by listening to the conversation of the other students,” Grisham said.

Martin Perez, a 4th-grade teacher at Kennedy Elementary, agreed, saying that the small groups may be the only way that a student struggling with English feels comfortable to speak up.

“It allows them to express themselves freely,” Perez said. “It’s not just about math. It’s about kids that are so intimidated to say anything,”

Perez recalled one student in a small group who talked about math concepts using a combination of English and Spanish. Perez, who understands Spanish, can listen and gauge whether her reasoning is faulty or on track.

“She struggles, but when I hear her explaining something, it shows she’s going through the cognitive steps to get through to the answer,” Perez said. Her test scores also show him that she’s picking up the math concepts he overhears her verbalize.

More-proficient English speakers may help those with less English understand math concepts. But Hoffmann, who coaches high school teachers working with English learners, said learning the language of math or any other subject is a challenge for many students – not only those who are learning English.

Many high school students struggle with academic language, Hoffmann said. Because of that, she added, “We try to teach teachers to bolster language across the board.”

The Common Core standards require that math teachers spend substantially more time helping students than in the past, Perez said.

“It’s a huge paradigm shift in the way math has been taught in this country,” Perez added, “and it’s so much better, because it requires a really active mind at work, not just one following rote steps. Basically, it boils down to students teaching students.”

“The English language learners have learned how to express ideas by listening to the conversation of the other students,” said Jeffrey Grisham, a 5th-grade math teacher at Kennedy Elementary in Santa Ana.

Ramirez, the Urban Promise Academy teacher, said the new standards allow him to apply math problems to the realities of everyday life experienced by his students – something he yearned for when he studied math in school.

For example, in a lesson on how to calculate the rate at which something occurs, he asked his students to look at school dropout rates by race, which hit home for several of them. Others mentioned that members of their families do not have high school diplomas.

“I always wanted math to tie into my everyday life,” Ramirez said. Now, he said, he is giving his students reasons “for why we need to know math.”

 Following is the proportional relationships standard, one of the Common Core standards for 7th-grade math:

    Analyze proportional relationships and use them to solve real-world and mathematical problems.
  • Compute unit rates associated with ratios of fractions, including ratios of lengths, areas and other quantities measured in like or different units. For example, if a person walks 1/2 mile in each 1/4 hour, compute the unit rate as the complex fraction 1/2/1/4 miles per hour, equivalently 2 miles per hour.
  • Recognize and represent proportional relationships between quantities.
  • Decide whether two quantities are in a proportional relationship, e.g., by testing for equivalent ratios in a table or graphing on a coordinate plane and observing whether the graph is a straight line through the origin.
  • Identify the constant of proportionality (unit rate) in tables, graphs, equations, diagrams, and verbal descriptions of proportional relationships.
  • Represent proportional relationships by equations. For example, if total cost t is proportional to the number n of items purchased at a constant price p, the relationship between the total cost and the number of items can be expressed as t = pn.
  • Explain what a point (x, y) on the graph of a proportional relationship means in terms of the situation, with special attention to the points (0, 0) and (1, r) where r is the unit rate.
  • Use proportional relationships to solve multistep ratio and percent problems. Examples: simple interest, tax, markups and markdowns, gratuities and commissions, fees, percent increase and decrease, percent error.

Going Deeper



Laurie Udesky covers the implementation of Common Core.



2cents small My daughter attended the Individualized Honors Program at Reed Middle School; the Reed IHP predates the LAUSD magnet program and presents an extremely rigorous curriculum to the identified highly gifted and high achievers. Reed itself is a regular middle school; the student population ranges from honors kids to underachieving skateboard punks and from the upper-middle class privileged students to recent immigrants - documented and not. The demographics ran the gamut.

Reed’s program+success  thrived by providing opportunity. It had a orchestral, jazz and choral music program second to none – and open to any student  interested enough to do the work – whether from the IHP, general  or ESL population. The Reed Drill Team regularly competed (and even more regularly won) against high school competition.

[I write in the past tense from past experience; I hope+pray it is still so!]

In theory the advanced IHP course work – including its Advanced Placement Physics courses – was open to all students ready to do the work – because there is no reason whatsoever why a student can’t get a 5 in AP Physics just because they don’t speak English!   Sadly there were no takers – even though the Parent Center Director was a great teacher, a powerful advocate, and a degreed mathematician from South America.

It is never about the test scores and the bureaucracy; it will never be about the implementation of the Common Core. It is, was and always will be  about the intersection of People and Opportunity and the recognition of the Moment..   They don’t run the PSA’s any more …but A Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste / Una Mente es una Cosa Terrible a Perder.


No comments: