By Valerie Strauss, Washington Post/The Answer Sheet | http://wapo.st/vvJvRw
1:01 PM ET, 10/24/2011 - In these troubled economic times, it would take a lot for a school district to turn down a gift of $2.5 million. But that’s just what the Oregon City School District has done.
The 8,100-student district was part of a group of school systems and a non-profit organization that applied to the federal government for a federal grant through the “Teacher Incentive Fund.” That fund awards money to districts that agree to implement performance-based compensation systems in high-needs schools for teachers and principals that include the use of standardized test scores and merit pay.
Officials in Oregon City’s district and teachers union thought, according to the Oregonian, that they could take the money — which the coalition won in 2010 — without implementing performance pay.
But the district, which has spent $55,000 of the $2.54 million grant, has been unable to come up with a merit pay plan, so it is leaving the program and therefore won’t use the rest of its allotted money, the newspaper reported. The U.S. Department of Education refused a request from the district to allow it to implement a plan that did not use test scores to hand out performance bonuses.
District Superintendent Larry Didway was quoted by the Oregonian as saying: “We certainly, as a team, do not believe that providing an incentive to teachers based on increased test scores of any individuals is going to make a difference in student achievement."
Right he is, and it’s past time that the Education Department acknowledged that there is no real evidence that using test scores for evaluation is a valid and reliable assessment tool.
The National Research Council issued a report earlier this year concluding that incentive programs for schools, teachers and students aimed at raising standardized test scores are largely unproductive in generating increased student achievement. The council is the research arm of the National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering and the Institute of Medicine.
Other studies too, have found fault with the validity of “value added” methods that are used to evaluate teachers and principals based on student standardized test scores, yet the Obama administration continues to push reforms that use this approach.
Some of the best performing school districts in the country right here in the Washington D.C. area — such as Fairfax County and Montgomery County, manage to have fine evaluation systems without using test scores. When will the federal government get the message?
Full coverage from Google News
NPR - Rob Manning - - Oct 25, 2011
Education Secretary Arne Duncan visited Oregon earlier this month, and he heard from an Oregon City teacher who complained about the rules of a performance-based pay bonus grant. Education Secretary Arne Duncan visited Oregon earlier ...
Oregon City School District Walks Away From $2.54 Million Grant For ...
Huffington Post - Nick Lahanas - Oct 24, 2011
The Oregon City School District has decided to reject a $2.54 million federal grant meant to reward top educators, partly because of philosophical concerns over performance-based pay. When the district won the money in September 2010 through a group ...
OregonLive.com - - Oct 25, 2011
By The Oregonian Editorial Board Frank Caro, the Tigard High School social studies teacher honored Monday as one of the nation's best teachers, is lucky he doesn't labor in the Oregon City School District. Teachers and administrators there are so sure ...
KATU - Patrick Preston - Oct 24, 2011
OREGON CITY, Ore. - Oregon City educators rejected a multimillion-dollar grant meant to reward teachers, because the money would have been tied to student test scores. The superintendent says staff members couldn't agree on a plan to take advantage of ...
The Republic - Oct 24, 2011
AP OREGON CITY, Ore. — The Oregon City School District is rejecting a $2.5 million federal grant intended to reward top teachers. Superintendent Larry Didway says the district team evaluating the system couldn't agree on using test scores to give merit ...
OPB News - Rob Manning - Oct 24, 2011
A Portland-area school district has lost federal funding for an initiative to give teachers money when they do extra work to help students. The Chalkboard Project won a $24 million federal grant last year to test new reward schemes for teachers at ...
Corvallis Gazette Times - Oct 24, 2011
AP | Posted: Monday, October 24, 2011 6:56 am | Loading… The Oregon City School District is rejecting a $2.5 million federal grant intended to reward top teachers. Superintendent Larry Didway says the district team evaluating the system couldn't agree ...