Friday, November 04, 2011

Media enquiry: LAUSD MAGNET APPLICATION PROCESS

e-mail to 4LAKids

Sent: Thu, Nov 3, 2011 12:05 pm
Subject: Magnet school applications

Scott, I’d like to do some in person interviews with parents navigating LA Unified’s magnet application process for the first time and/or who’ve done it before. I’m preparing a news story for public radio KPCC 89.3FM. Ideally I’d like to do the interviews on Monday or Tuesday. Do you know any parents who fit this description? Can you forward this?

Thanks!

Adolfo Guzman-Lopez

Reporter

aguzman@scpr.org

Thursday, November 03, 2011

CALIFORNIA STUDENTS RANK AT BOTTOM OF NATIONAL TEST

Corey G. Johnson | California Watch | http://bit.ly/tE5ZGw

koratmember/istockphoto.com

November 3, 2011 | While California's math and reading scores have improved slightly in recent years, they still rank near the bottom on a national test, according to a report released this week.

According to the 2011 National Assessment of Educational Progress, which tested fourth- and eighth-graders, state reading and math scores were higher than the state's 2007 results, but statistically unchanged from the last test in 2009.

In California, about 25 percent of fourth-graders and 24 percent of eighth-graders received proficient scores in reading this year, according to the study. Roughly 34 percent of fourth-graders and 25 percent of eighth-graders were proficient in math.

The total scores ranked California 46th out of 52 states and jurisdictions in student reading and math performance. Scoring lower were Tennessee, New Mexico, Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi and, in last place, the District of Columbia.

Nationally, 34 percent of students in both grades were proficient in reading. In mathematics, 40 percent of fourth-graders and 35 percent of eighth-graders scored proficient in 2011.

State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson this week praised the scores, while continuing his call for more financial support for schools.

“Our students are still making progress, even as they swim against a riptide of crowded classrooms and deep budget cuts to our schools,” Torlakson said. “Asked to do more with less, students, teachers, school employees and administrators have delivered. Imagine how much more they could accomplish – and how many more students would share in this progress – with the resources they deserve.”

The test results also show the state's Hispanic eighth-graders have narrowed the differences between them and their white peers. Out of 500 total points, this year's Hispanic eighth-graders scored 245 on the reading section. When compared with white students' 2011 score of 268, this represents a gap of 23 points, which is 7 points closer in performance than the two groups were in 1998.

Known as “The Nation’s Report Card," the test is conducted biennially. This year's scores were derived from tests of about 209,000 fourth-graders and 175,000 eighth-graders.

A "basic" score in the review suggests a partial mastery of the necessary knowledge and skills; a "proficient" score represents solid academic performance. The highest score, "advanced," equates to superior performance, according to the study.

For the math portion, students answered questions designed to measure their knowledge and abilities in the areas of number properties and operations; measurement; geometry; data analysis, statistics and probability; and algebra. The reading test was based on questions measuring a student's ability to interpret and understand a wide range of fiction, nonfiction, and persuasive and procedural writings.

Reading and mathematics results for certain large urban districts are expected to be released later this year. Results from the 2011 science assessment are expected to be released in spring 2012.

Dispatches from the frontlines: REFORM® WINS ONE IN DENVER

e-mail from save our schools colorado

        “A little patience, and we shall see the reign of witches pass over, their spells dissolve, and the people, recovering their true sight, restore their governmentto its true principles.”

To John Taylor Philadelphia, June 4, 1798

11/3/11

Dear SOS Supporters,

What a week it has been in Denver. On Tuesday night, many of us watched a devastating school boards election. As you all know, Emily Sirota ran a magnificent campaign: one of integrity, compassion, and sheer persistence. Personally, she knocked on more than 5,000 homes and talked incessantly with voters about how to rid DPS of special corporate interests, grow neighborhood schools, bring accountability and transparency to the district, and educate the whole child instead of test prepping the student. Emily stands for so many things that we hold in our belief system as educators and supporters of public schools. Well, her campaign was outspent, and it appears that school board races are potentially bought by the 1%.

It can be overwhelming to think about how entrenched the corporate reformers are at all levels of education in Denver. It is overwhelming to think about the job ahead of us, the job of educating parents, teachers, and community members of what is happening to our school districts throughout Colorado. However, we need to rise to the occasion. We need to band to together and strategize how best to fight for our students so that this generation is not lost due to rampant budget cuts, school privatization, dumbed down testing curriculum, and attacks on the unions and the teaching profession. We thank the Emily’s of the world who give up months of their lives to help us fight. We thank the Emily’s of the world who give up time with their own children to fight for all children. We thank the Emily’s of the world who understand the issues, fight a clean fight, and never give up for the cause is larger than all of us.

However, now it is our turn, to pick up the fight. We can pay our respect to the Emily’s of the world, by taking the time to educate our friends, colleagues, and neighbors about what is truly happening in education in our schools, districts, and throughout the nation. Please make sure you stay up to date on education issues around the nation and in Colorado. Do you have a subscription of Education Week and Rethinking Schools, for example? Share salient information with each other, and don’t forget to pass it along to me as well. Thank you.

Calendar:

Nov. 4th, 2011 “American Teacher”

6:30 p.m. at Starz Denver Film Center 2510 East Colfax

This movie is sold out, however there are rush tickets. Line up by 5:30 to get them. This movie talks about the struggles teachers face and the minimal pay we receive. Hopefully, we will be able to get a screening at a later date in Denver. I will keep you posted. Anyone interested in working on that?

http://www.denverfilm.org/festival/film/detail.aspx?id=24490&fid=61

Nov. 5th,

Occupy Wall Street

11:45 a.m. Meet at the Federal Reserve -16th St. Skyline Park-We will be meeting just outside or Starbucks.

Teachers join the movement. Have your voice heard. What are you biggest concerns regarding education today? How have corporate reformers changed the way we teach? Stan Karp writes a powerful article about “corporate” education reform and the movements around the country trying to fight it.

http://www.commondreams.org/view/2011/10/25-1

Nov. 1st- Nov. 8th- Save Our School Voting for a Steering Committee-

Remember to take time to vote for an excellent & diverse steering committee to move SOS forward. If you have not received the e-mail to vote, and if you have not received a newsletter, please go to the website to reregister. Saveourschoolsmarch.org

Below is an article about how mayor Hancock has hired a former Stand For Children activist to head up the mayor’s office on Education and Children.

http://blogs.denverpost.com/thespot/2011/10/28/head-of-pro-reform-education-group-appointed-to-childrens-affairs-office/45226/

Colorado SOS Facebook Page

Parents, teachers, and community members,

Please join us on our facebook page.  This is a great place to share ideas, and possible events that we can get going in Colorado to make more people aware of SOS and its mission!!  The page is private, which means that you can view but can’t post unless you are a member.  Please join!!

http://www.facebook.com/groups/285175064843594/

Have a great weekend. Thank you for your support.

Melody W.

(New) Information Coordinator for Save Our Schools

Saveourschoolsmarch.org

The Death and Life of the Great American School System: RAVITCH UPDATES BEST SELLING BOOK ON ED REFORM

By Valerie Strauss | Washington Post/Answer Sheet Blog | http://wapo.st/skbNrm

11/03/2011 6:30 AM ET - Critics of Diane Ravitch like to say that the education historian talks a lot about what is wrong with the modern school reform movement but doesn’t offer solutions about how to fix anything. Historians, of course, by definition spend their time looking to the past, not making policy pronouncements about what should be. That said, Ravitch, the leading voice in the country speaking out against standardized-test based school reform, does what her critics say she doesn’t in an important new chapter at the end of the new paperback edition of the best-selling “The Death and Life of the Great American School System.”

No doubt those critics still won’t like what she has to say.

The subtitle of Ravitch’s book — selected as the most important education book of the last decade by readers of Education Next, a magazine whose editors generally support reforms Ravitch opposes — aptly sums up the thrust of Ravitch’s narrative: “How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education.”

The book tells how Ravitch, who served as secretary of education in the administration of president George H.W. Bush* and was a prominent supporter of No Child Left Behind when it was implemented by Bush’s son, president George W. Bush, came to a profound rethinking of her views on education reform when she looked at data about how reform was affecting schools and realized that NCLB was a mistake.

* CORRECTION: Ravitch was Assistant Secretary for Educational Research and Improvement and Counselor to the Secretary, U.S. Department of Education in the George H.W. Bush Administration. – smf

(Ravitch, who is immensely popular with teachers and speaks to packed audiences across the country, gets attacked for having changed her views, which is, of course, a silly complaint, given that academics are, of all people, supposed to be led by evidence. She gets attacked, incidentally, by opponents for all manner of things, including the frequency of her tweeting; why they are monitoring her tweets is an open question.)

Ravitch clearly details the damage done to public schools when people insist on trying to run them as if they were businesses.

An obsession with standardized tests in reading and math led to narrowed curriculum, a fixation on “choice” led to an expansion of public charter schools without the same “accountability” measures that traditional public schools are being subjected to, and the American fascination with celebrity and wealth allowed people such as Bill Gates, Eli Broad and other billionaires to use their private money to drive ill-considered reform efforts that have had a major impact on public schools.

The new chapter carries the reform narrative forward, telling about the “no excuses” and “get tough” reform approach pushed by the Obama administration. There’s the episode in Central Falls, R.I., when all of the educators at a low-performing high school were fired — and both Education Secretary Arne Duncan and President Obama praised the move. It caused so much bad publicity that the decision was reversed (though what has happened since in Central Falls is no victory for reformers). There’s “Waiting for Superman,” and the damaging new trend to link teacher pay to student standardized test scores.

Perhaps the most important part is Ravitch’s discussion of the biggest problems in public education (which is not to say there aren’t some bad teachers, and some bad teachers education programs, and bad curriculum, etc): “resources matter and so does poverty.”

The mantra of many reformers is that poverty is an excuse (nearly 22 percent of America’s children now live in poverty), and Ravitch shows clearly that it is not, and that efforts to fix urban education without addressing the effects of poverty on students can’t possibly work.

The proof of this, she points out, is in Geoffrey Canada’s Harlem Children’s Zone, which is held up by pro-choice reformers because it operates a few charter schools, but which, Ravitch writes, “actually proves that poverty and resources matter a great deal.”

“Canada’s HCZ is an antipoverty program in Harlem that provides a broad array of medical and social services to children and families, such as health programs, preschool, after-school tutoring, and parenting clasess. Its three charter schools are far better funded than nearby regular public schools. Its small high school has classes of fewer than fifteen students with two licensed teachers in each classroom. Because it has a very wealthy board of trustees, HCZ has an endowment of $200 million. Even with the ample resources available to HCZ, its charters had many students in 2010 who did not meet state standards for proficiency in reading: 62 percent in one school, and 38 percent in the other. In the seventh grade, where students were in their third year, only 15 percent met state standards. When Geoffrey Canada first recruited students to his charter middle school, they entered with low scores; after three years, when their scores remained low, he kicked out the entire class. The neighborhood public schools can’t do this.”

This leads into what Ravitch says are necessary requirements for successful reform, the thing critics say she doesn’t do. What are those things?

“Although some school reformers of our own day believe that schools alone can create equality, Du Bois knew this was not possible. Schools can provide a route out of poverty for determined individuals, but schools by themselves — no matter how excellent — cannot cure the ills created by extreme social and economic inequality.... The achievement gap begins long before the first day of school.

“School reform therefore must occur in tandem with social reform.”

That doesn’t mean, she says, that schools don’t have to improve. They do. The teaching profession must get more professional. “The status quo today is intolerable,” she writes.

But billions of dollars spent on standardized test-based accountability measures haven’t done anything to help fix the problems, and have made things worse. Charter schools educate less than 4 percent of the nation’s children, and though all the hoopla about them makes it sound like that figure is higher, they never will be an acceptable replacement for neighborhood schools.

When I first wrote about Ravitch’s book last year, I included a passage that stayed with me. Here it is again, as instructive as ever, but, sadly, just as ignored by reformers:

“Reformers imagine that it is easy to create a successful school, but it is not. They imagine that the lessons of a successful school are obvious and can be easily transferred to other schools, just as one might take an industrial process or a new piece of machinery and install it in a new plant without error. But a school is successful for many reasons, including the personalities of its leader and teachers; the social interactions among them; the culture of the school; the students and their families; the way the school implements policies and programs dictated by the district, the state and the federal government; the quality of the school’s curriculum and instruction; the resources of the school and the community; and many other factors. When a school is successful, it is hard to know which factor was most important or if it was a combination of factors.”

LA UNIFIED HOLDS FIRST POSITIVE BEHAVIOR SYMPOSIUM

Adolfo Guzman-Lopez | KPCC | http://bit.ly/rJnqrY

Mercer 20360

Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Images - A student on his way to school walks past a Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) school bus.

Download Audio

Nov. 2, 2011 | Some 350 Los Angeles Unified educators attended a first-of-its-kind symposium Wednesday on how schools can improve student behavior.

Discipline problems are frustrating to teachers and contribute to students’ poor academic performance and drop out rates.

At the symposium, one education scholar told participants why harsh discipline doesn’t compel students to behave. Another speaker, this one a public interest lawyer, said more people need to advocate on students’ behalf.

L.A. County Juvenile Court Judge Donna Groman told the group that time in juvenile hall doesn’t help all students who break school rules — so that’s why she'd like to keep more in class.

"We don’t always know that you have a plan that you’re implementing; and that this youth is changing for the positive — and because we see a report that says missed 10 days of school, off they go to juvenile hall," she said. "And that defeats everything you’re trying to do."

The plan that’s generating a sea change across LAUSD campuses is called "School Wide Positive Behavior Supports."

Sharon Katz is a principal at a South L.A. elementary school, after the symposium, she said she’d return to her campus with ideas to reward good behavior with a little fun. "We can play a bingo game and when they fill out a bingo card for good behavior we can recognize them for that. She had some good ideas: A pie eating contest. "I think my kids would enjoy watching my teachers eat pie and getting all messed up. There was a principal here cut his head into a Mohawk and painted it pink for some time, I would go for something like that, too," she said.

L.A. Unified’s local district seven includes more than 80 schools. Each one sent representatives, and a few included parents. Elementary school teacher Baadia Daaood said the conference gave her some ideas for ramping up parent involvement. "Some of the parents are just not available for one reason or another to really devote the quality time that children need, and I just think that the children want more quality time and they want to feel like they’re cared for," Daaood said.

Toward the end of the symposium, school representatives wrote down what they’ll do to make the district’s positive behavior policy work. Administrators said they plan to visit schools from time to time and carry along copies of those pledges.

Board Presentation SWPBS

THE STULL ACT & THE ED VOICE v. LAUSD LAWSUIT: Less than meets the eye, more than you wanted to know

●● s m f    n o t e s:

The lawsuit it not really called Ed Voice v. LAUSD – that would make too much sense. It is JANE DOE, et al, v. JOHN DEASY, et al. (The filing follows)

The Doe plaintiffs  are “a half-dozen unnamed parents backed by Sacramento-based EdVoice”, “The parents say they filed as Does for fear of ‘intimidation and retaliation against themselves and their children’." The Deasy et al, defendants  are Superintendent Deasy, the Board of Education, UTLA, AALA (the administrators' union), The California Public Employee Relations Board and ten Does to be named later. Hopefully Bambi’s mother is not among them.

This is a bizarre dance card. Or fight card.

Ed Voice is a stalking horse for Eli Broad, Bill Gates and the Billionaire Boys Club Forces of Reform® (including Deasy and the Bd of Ed majority ). Defendant Deasy is an miscast  stand-in (or perhaps bellwether) for UTLA and CTA; with he, Mayor Tony and a 4 to 3 majority of the Board of Ed firmly aligned with the plaintiffs. With the District sympathetic to the Plaintiffs it remains to be seen how vigorously this suit will be defended. We have all heard of uncooperative and/or hostile witnesses – welcome to Hostile Defendants!  Plus, The Bown Act

And,  if as I suspect based on previous practice, the unnamed Plaintiff Does are actually charter school parents, their very standing as litigants is open to challenge -  as most charters are outside the day-to-day purview and authority of the school district or the two unions.

 Parents Say L.A. Schools Defy State Law

By MATT REYNOLDS | Courthouse News Service | http://bit.ly/v3dB7Y

LOS ANGELES (CN) - Five parents sued the Los Angeles Unified School District in Superior Court, claiming that for four decades it has refused to comply with a state law that it regularly evaluate teachers, "with data that reasonably measures, among other criteria, whether or not the students under an employee's charge are actually learning."

     The plaintiffs - five mothers, a father and nine children, all filing as Does - claim that the district, "which annually fails hundreds of children," has violated the children's "fundamental right to basic educational equality and opportunity" by failing to comply with a section of the California Education Code known as the Stull Act.

     "The children and their parents ask the court to enforce a reasonable and four decade old statutory state law that requires the district to evaluate certificated employees' on-the-job performance with data that reasonably measures, among other criteria, whether or not the students under an employee's charge are actually learning," the complaint states.

     Named as defendants are Superintendent John Deasy, the seven members of the Board of Education, the Associated Administrators of Los Angeles (AALA), the United Teachers of Los Angeles (UTLA) and the California Public Employment Relations Board.

     Scott Witlin, with Barnes & Thornburg, filed suit for the advocates. He told Courthouse News he was "concerned" because the district is "ignoring the group that's supposed to be the beneficiary of the school system, the children. They have a constitutional right to education. The school district doesn't exist for the adults."

     The parents and kids say the district "never obeyed" the Stull Act's mandate to establish standards of pupil achievement and evaluate teachers according to their students' progress.

     They claim that "groups of politically powerful adults," have obstructed the law since it was enacted in 1971.

     According to the plaintiffs, the AALA and UTLA have "historically fought" teacher evaluations based on student progress and collectively bargained to prevent implementation of the law.

     "Both the AALA and the UTLA have historically fought against certificated personnel evaluations being tied in any way to student learning," the complaint states. "The result is decades during which prior LAUSD superintendents and school boards have entered into unlawful collective bargaining contracts with these associations of adults that prevented compliance with the statutory mandate of evaluating certificated staff based even in part on available evidence of whether or not the children are learning.

     "Indeed, the 2009-2011 collective bargaining agreement (CBA) and, on information and belief, the current one-year extension of the CBA between the AALA and the LAUSD does not allow for administrators to be evaluated as mandated by the Stull Act regarding the progress of pupils toward the standards established pursuant to Section 44662(a) and, if applicable, the state adopted academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion-referenced assessments."

     The parents say the superintendent has publicly revealed his hostility to performance reviews: "For example, the superintendent recently stated that, 'I would argue that nobody has told me that the current system of evaluation, which is performance review, helps anybody. It is fundamentally useless. It does not actually help you get better at [your] work and it doesn't tell you how well you're doing.'

     "The superintendent went on to state, 'One would have to argue: "So ... there are schools where 3 percent of the students are proficient at math and 100 percent of the teachers are at the top rating performance." That doesn't make sense to me whatsoever. And it doesn't make sense because the rating performance does not actually help teachers get better.'" (Brackets and ellipsis in complaint.)

     The parents say that poor teachers are disciplined under the current system only if "they fail to meet an illegal standard of satisfactory performance or are convicted of the commission of serious crimes leading to mandatory credential suspension or revocation."

     The complaint continues: "As a result, the adults' collective employment and political interests are turning the children's opportunity to learn and their fundamental right to basic educational equality in the public schools on its head and instead the system is protecting the working conditions of the certificated personnel, as well as preserving the political power of the board and the superintendent. ... And worse for the disenfranchised and socio-economically disadvantaged children, these adults have created systematic harm to students by allowing contracts to produce a concentration of under-qualified and ineffective certificated staff in chronically failing schools.

     "There can be no dispute that the nation's second largest school district is a broken school system that has failed millions of children over the past 40 years and limited the future potential of the children and community of Los Angeles in large part due to the failure of the adults who are responsible for governing, managing and evaluating the district's certificated personnel, by failing to establish a lawful standard for satisfactory performance of certificated adults, which necessarily must be based, at least in part, upon student progress. The very purpose of the district has been turned on its head by adults focused on employment conditions and political power instead of individual performance assessment and accountability measured at least in part on whether or not children are actually progressing toward standards of expected achievement. It is simply unacceptable under California Constitutional and statutory law to ignore the plight of students any longer.

     "This petition seeks a writ of judicial mandate to compel the LAUSD immediately to comply with the clear mandate of the Stull Act and its strengthened statutory revisions, and further seeks a preliminary injunction to enjoin the district, its superintendent, members of the Board of Education, and the representatives of certificated personnel from using collective bargaining force to compel the district to continue to violate the Stull Act and from continuing to injure the children, their parents and guardians, the community of Los Angeles and the state of California. Forty years of deliberate and calculated noncompliance with such a key state requirement is enough."

     The parents say they filed as Does for fear of "intimidation and retaliation against themselves and their children."

     The Los Angeles Unified School District did not respond to a request for comment.

 

New life for old law on evaluations:  L.A. Unified suit says problem is will to enforce

By John Fensterwald - Educated Guess | http://bit.ly/uL03Tn

11/02/11 • The Stull Act, the 40-year-old teacher evaluation law that school reformers had dismissed as useless, may have a second wind.

In a suit with statewide implications (filing follows), parents backed by an advocacy group are suing Los Angeles Unified and its teachers union, claiming that state law requires that statewide standardized tests must be used in the evaluation of teachers. That law is the Stull Act.

The suit, filed Tuesday in Los Angeles County Superior Court by a half-dozen unnamed parents backed by Sacramento-based EdVoice, seeks an order requiring the district to immediately start using measures of student performance in evaluating teachers and administrators. “Forty years of deliberate and calculated non-compliance with such a key State requirement is enough,” it says.

Plaintiffs want an injunction preventing the district from negotiating a contract that delays applying the law universally. That would include a three-year pilot program for a new evaluation system that Superintendent John Deasy has been prodding United Teachers Los Angeles to accept. An initial hearing on the lawsuit is scheduled for Nov. 21.

Dozens of states have revised teacher evaluation laws over the past two years, and a similar effort is shaping up to be one of the more contentious and involved efforts of the Legislature in 2012. The primary bill in play is AB 5, authored by Assemblymember Felipe Fuentes, D-San Fernando, whose current draft scraps the Stull Act and starts from scratch.

The LAUSD suit implies that may not be necessary. The problem is not with the law, but the collective failure, by the state’s 1,000 plus districts, facing union opposition to using test scores in evaluations, to enforce it over four decades. A victory by the plaintiffs might embolden districts to be more assertive in negotiating new contracts.

Although the lawsuit names Deasy, the LAUSD school board, the district’s teachers and administrators unions, and the state Public Employment Relations Board as defendants, the suit could provide leverage for Deasy in his dealings with UTLA, which has challenged the district’s authority to make any changes in evaluations that aren’t negotiated.

Deasy’s pilot evaluation system, involving volunteer teachers, includes using valued-added standardized test scores as one component. They are supposed to measure a teacher’s impact on student learning; Deasy wants valued-added scores to count as much as 30 percent of an evaluation.

Matter of local control

Bill Lucia, CEO of EdVoice, says the intent of the lawsuit is not to prescribe any particular methodology for using test scores or weight in applying them. State test scores could complement other local assessments or be one component, along with with observations.  That, consistent with the Stull Act, would be left for local districts to determine, he said.

The suit details the history of the Stull Act – and circumvention of it. As passed in 1971, the Stull Act required every school board to create standards of student achievement for each subject in every grade and also to evaluate teachers’ performances relative to students’ progress toward meeting locally determined standards. The State Board of Education fleshed it out with guidelines authorizing school boards to identify teachers who have weaknesses in performance, with ways to help them improve, and those who should be fired. In 1995, the suit says, the Legislature amended the law to explicitly permit dismissal for unsatisfactory performance. In 1999, the Legislature added the key component:  including in evaluations student progress toward meeting state academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion-referenced assessments, the California Standardized Tests.

But the suit says that unions stonewalled the new law, and, over decades, “in collusion” with superintendents and school trustees, “have made it impossible” to effectively evaluate teachers and to take corrective action based on evidence of a lack of student learning.

“As a result, the adults’ collective employment and political interests are turning the children’s opportunity to learn and their fundamental right to basic educational equality in the public schools on its head,” the suit said.

The suit says that the Commission on State Mandates Commission has allowed reimbursements for the Stull Act; more than 700 districts that at least report including student test scores in evaluations have filed $20 million in annual claims. Based on that, it would seem that districts could also seek repayment for more extensive evaluation costs, including mentoring, additional training and other actions that were recommended to teachers needing improvement.

The mandate of what districts must do is clear, the suit says; it’s just that they have ignored it.

Parents Sue LAUSD For Lack Of Teacher Evaluations

Kathleen Miles - The Huffington Post  | http://huff.to/uw4sjA

Parents Sue Lausd

11/1/11 08:19 PM ET Updated: 11/2/11 01:07 PM ET - An upcoming lawsuit by a coalition of Los Angeles parents and education groups alleges that the Los Angeles Unified School District has been breaking state laws for forty years.

As Dropout Nation reports, seven families, represented by Barnes & Thornburg LLP, are preparing to sue the Los Angeles Unifed School District (LAUSD) for not following the 1971 Stull Act, which mandates that California schools evaluate teachers and principals based on student performance. Today, the families asked California's superior court to bar any LAUSD-United Teacher Los Angeles (UTLA) contract that doesn't include data-based teacher evaluations.

In an October 26 letter, the families involved in the lawsuit gave LAUSD until the close of yesterday to demonstrate that it plans to implement data-based teacher evaluations. Their demands are based on a recent study that found that just 40 percent of veteran teachers and 70 percent of new teachers within the LAUSD were evaluated during the 2009-2010 school year.

As the Los Angeles Times reports, EdVoice, a Sacramento-based group with philanthropist Eli Broad, former ambassador Frank Baxter and healthcare company executive Richard Merkin as board members, is serving as a consultant for the families suing.

The announcement comes on the same day that LAUSD and UTLA set as a deadline for key contract agreements. However, the leaders of the two entities remain at a stalemate.

The pending lawsuit comes after a recent full-page ad in the LA Times, Daily News and La Opinion by a similar but separate coalition of civic and community groups with a clear message to UTLA: "Don't hold us back." The coalition, itself called Don’t Hold Us Back, asks for teacher evaluations in addition to protection of LAUSD's Public School Choice program, which allows teacher collaboratives and charter schools to request to run a school that is failing to meet benchmarks.

It remains to be seen if this louder parent frustration, now targeted especially towards UTLA, will hasten or further delay contract negotiations between LAUSD and UTLA.

STULL ACT: Demand that LAUSD immediately comply

B&T: LAUSD Stull Demand Letter[1]

THE STULL ACT: The Law

CALIFORNIA CODES
EDUCATION CODE
SECTION 44660-44665

44660. It is the intent of the Legislature that governing boards
establish a uniform system of evaluation and assessment of the
performance of all certificated personnel within each school district
of the state, including schools conducted or maintained by county
superintendents of education. The system shall involve the
development and adoption by each school district of objective
evaluation and assessment guidelines which may, at the discretion of
the governing board, be uniform throughout the district or, for
compelling reasons, be individually developed for territories or
schools within the district, provided that all certificated personnel
of the district shall be subject to a system of evaluation and
assessment adopted pursuant to this article.
This article does not apply to certificated personnel who are
employed on an hourly basis in adult education classes.
44661. In the development and adoption of guidelines and procedures
pursuant to this article, the governing board shall avail itself of
the advice of the certificated instructional personnel in the
district's organization of certificated personnel; provided, however,
that the development and adoption of guidelines pursuant to this
article shall also be subject to the provisions of Article 1
(commencing with Section 7100) of Chapter 2 of Part 5 of Division 1
of Title 1.
44661.5. When developing and adopting objective evaluation and
assessment guidelines pursuant to Section 44660, a school district
may, by mutual agreement between the exclusive representative of the
certificated employees of the school district and the governing board
of the school district, include any objective standards from the
National Board for Professional Teaching Standards or any objective
standards from the California Standards for the Teaching Profession
if the standards to be included are consistent with this article. If
the certificated employees of the school district do not have an
exclusive representative, the school district may adopt objective
evaluation and assessment guidelines consistent with this section.
44662. (a) The governing board of each school district shall
establish standards of expected pupil achievement at each grade level
in each area of study.
(b) The governing board of each school district shall evaluate and
assess certificated employee performance as it reasonably relates
to:
(1) The progress of pupils toward the standards established
pursuant to subdivision (a) and, if applicable, the state adopted
academic content standards as measured by state adopted criterion
referenced assessments.
(2) The instructional techniques and strategies used by the
employee.
(3) The employee's adherence to curricular objectives.
(4) The establishment and maintenance of a suitable learning
environment, within the scope of the employee's responsibilities.
(c) The governing board of each school district shall establish
and define job responsibilities for certificated noninstructional
personnel, including, but not limited to, supervisory and
administrative personnel, whose responsibilities cannot be evaluated
appropriately under the provisions of subdivision (b) and shall
evaluate and assess the performance of those noninstructional
certificated employees as it reasonably relates to the fulfillment of
those responsibilities.
(d) Results of an employee's participation in the Peer Assistance
and Review Program for Teachers established by Article 4.5
(commencing with Section 44500) shall be made available as part of
the evaluation conducted pursuant to this section.
(e) The evaluation and assessment of certificated employee
performance pursuant to this section shall not include the use of
publishers' norms established by standardized tests.
(f) Nothing in this section shall be construed as in any way
limiting the authority of school district governing boards to develop
and adopt additional evaluation and assessment guidelines or
criteria.
44663. (a) Evaluation and assessment made pursuant to this article
shall be reduced to writing and a copy thereof shall be transmitted
to the certificated employee not later than 30 days before the last
schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the governing
board for the school year in which the evaluation takes place. The
certificated employee shall have the right to initiate a written
reaction or response to the evaluation. This response shall become a
permanent attachment to the employee's personnel file. Before the
last schoolday scheduled on the school calendar adopted by the
governing board for the school year, a meeting shall be held between
the certificated employee and the evaluator to discuss the
evaluation.
(b) In the case of a certificated noninstructional employee, who
is employed on a 12-month basis, the evaluation and assessment made
pursuant to this article shall be reduced to writing and a copy
thereof shall be transmitted to the certificated employee no later
than June 30 of the year in which the evaluation and assessment is
made. A certificated noninstructional employee, who is employed on a
12-month basis shall have the right to initiate a written reaction or
response to the evaluation. This response shall become a permanent
attachment to the employee's personnel file. Before July 30 of the
year in which the evaluation and assessment takes place, a meeting
shall be held between the certificated employee and the evaluator to
discuss the evaluation and assessment.
44664. (a) Evaluation and assessment of the performance of each
certificated employee shall be made on a continuing basis as follows:
(1) At least once each school year for probationary personnel.
(2) At least every other year for personnel with permanent status.
(3) At least every five years for personnel with permanent status
who have been employed at least 10 years with the school district,
are highly qualified, if those personnel occupy positions that are
required to be filled by a highly qualified professional by the
federal No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 6301, et
seq.), as defined in 20 U.S.C. Sec. 7801, and whose previous
evaluation rated the employee as meeting or exceeding standards, if
the evaluator and certificated employee being evaluated agree. The
certificated employee or the evaluator may withdraw consent at any
time.
(b) The evaluation shall include recommendations, if necessary, as
to areas of improvement in the performance of the employee. If an
employee is not performing his or her duties in a satisfactory manner
according to the standards prescribed by the governing board, the
employing authority shall notify the employee in writing of that fact
and describe the unsatisfactory performance. The employing authority
shall thereafter confer with the employee making specific
recommendations as to areas of improvement in the employee's
performance and endeavor to assist the employee in his or her
performance. If any permanent certificated employee has received an
unsatisfactory evaluation, the employing authority shall annually
evaluate the employee until the employee achieves a positive
evaluation or is separated from the district.
(c) Any evaluation performed pursuant to this article which
contains an unsatisfactory rating of an employee's performance in the
area of teaching methods or instruction may include the requirement
that the certificated employee shall, as determined necessary by the
employing authority, participate in a program designed to improve
appropriate areas of the employee's performance and to further pupil
achievement and the instructional objectives of the employing
authority. If a district participates in the Peer Assistance and
Review Program for Teachers established pursuant to Article 4.5
(commencing with Section 44500), any certificated employee who
receives an unsatisfactory rating on an evaluation performed pursuant
to this section shall participate in the Peer Assistance and Review
Program for Teachers.
(d) Hourly and temporary hourly certificated employees, other than
those employed in adult education classes who are excluded by the
provisions of Section 44660, and substitute teachers may be excluded
from the provisions of this section at the discretion of the
governing board.
44665. For purposes of this article, "employing authority" means
the superintendent of the school district in which the employee is
employed, or his designee, or in the case of a district which has no
superintendent, a school principal or other person designated by the
governing board.

 

THE STULL ACT: The Legal Interpretation

Stull Act: Parameters & Guidelines

DOE v. DEASY: The Lawsuit

Doe v. Deasy - StullAct LAUSD suit110211[1]

FOSTER YOUTH GET A VOICE: New policies focus on lasting connections

By Kathryn Baron | Thoughts on Public Education/ToPED | http://bit.ly/vraj22

11/03/11 •It’s not often anymore that California is regarded as a bellwether for how to make good policy for children, but that’s what’s happening with the foster care system.  This week, in Oakland, representatives of eight counties presented their final reports on a six-year effort to transform foster care, known as the California Connected by 25 Initiative, or CC25I.

“In terms of planning, you’d be hard pressed to find a planning process anywhere in human services at the state level that has involved as many people over as long a period of time as this has,” said Mark Courtney, a professor at the University of Chicago’s School of Social Service Administration.

CC25I released two reports highlighting the model programs and successful strategies developed by the pilot counties to improve life for foster youth who are aging out of the system.  Promising Strategies from the California Connected by 25 Initiative contains tips on developing community partnerships, collecting data and getting current and former foster youth involved in policy discussions.

The Premise and Promise of the California Connected by 25 Initiative describes how well the strategies worked.  Nearly all the counties created collaborative programs with community organizations, schools and businesses. Santa Clara County, for example, received an award for partnering with the county’s human resources office to create a process that allows foster youth to apply for multiple job openings with a single application.

In everything from education to housing, things improved for foster youth in a relatively short time.  Between the 2008-09 academic year and 2010-11, the number of

In just three years of CC25I, foster youth showed significant academic gains. (Source: Stuart and Johnson Foundations). Click to enlarge.

<< In just three years of CC25I, foster youth showed significant academic gains. (Source: Stuart and Johnson Foundations). Click to enlarge.

students passing the high school exit exam increased by 25%, and the percentage completing some or all of the A-G courses required for admission to UC or CSU jumped from 31% to 45%.

The six-year, $6 million effort was funded primarily by the Stuart and Walter S. Johnson foundations* to correct what they saw as a huge gap in foster care, namely creating lasting relationships. But what made the project truly unusual, and so successful so quickly, was including former and current foster youth as equal participants.

Respecting youth voices

Lyssa Trujillo was 17 when she and her younger sister and brother were placed in foster care.  She and her sister were split from her brother and sent live with an aunt an uncle they barely knew, who forbid them from having any contact with her father.  Trujillo did anyway, emailing him on they sly.

She said child welfare didn’t intervene and she felt insignificant. “My voice as a young person wasn’t respected and honored because it was more about maintaining the placement so that I stayed there until I was 18,” said Trujillo.

Now 26, the soft-spoken, poised young woman has a baccalaureate degree from UC Santa Cruz and a job as a youth engagement technical assistant with CC25I and said she feels like she’s witnessing a culture shift within child welfare, that now there’s a team making the decisions and all voices are heard.

Lyssa Trujillo is a youth engagement technical assistant for the California Connected by 25 Initiative.  She is a former foster youth.  (photo, K. Baron) Click to enlarge.

Lyssa Trujillo is a youth engagement technical assistant for the California Connected by 25 Initiative. She is a former foster youth. (photo, K. Baron) Click to enlarge.>>

“I would say there have been times of awe for me that I’ve had people come to me and say, ‘You know when you said this one thing it has resonated with me since then, and I work with youth differently, and I really think about my preparation with them,’”  said Trujillo.

Kareena Blackmon’s experience in foster care went far beyond frustrating rules.  During 14 years in foster care, she said she was moved nearly every year, often placed with adults who meted out harsh punishments like holding her head under water and beating her with a weight belt.

Like Trujillo, the 23-year-old Blackmon is drawing on her experiences to help reshape policy as a youth advocate for child welfare services in Solano County.  But there’s still a  lingering anger at state officials for permitting the abuse to continue.

“The state decided that my parents were unfit, so you became my parents,”  Blackmon said she told state and county child

Kareena Blackmon spent 14 years in the foster care system.  She is a youth advocate for child welfare services in Solano County.  (photo, K. Baron) Click to enlarge.

<<Kareena Blackmon spent 14 years in the foster care system. She is a youth advocate for child welfare services in Solano County. (photo, K. Baron) Click to enlarge.

welfare officials at their meetings.  All she wanted, she explained to them, was for someone to find her father’s relatives so she could be with family, but it never happened. “Imagine just not even having that.  That’s the least you can do, I tell them.”

Through CC25I that’s changing.  The current philosophy is finding a permanent place for foster youth, either with relatives or other families who will create similar bonds.

What would a good parent do?

Having basic needs met -  food, shelter, clothing – is critical, but doesn’t provide the close human connections that most of us take for granted.  Even after kids graduate from high school and go off to college, they have a lifeline.  That’s not the case for foster youth when they turn 18 and age out of state care.

Half of 18-24  year olds in the United States live with one or both parents, said the University of Chicago’s Courtney.  At age 24, a quarter of them are still at home.  But for foster youth, until recently the policy was just the opposite.  When they turned 18, they could live with anyone except their foster family.

Courtney is preparing to publish the first longitudinal study of foster youth, which had some unexpected findings.  “I would say one of the things I was surprised by is how many of the young people in Illinois, when given the option to remain in state care, did,” said Courtney, “because there was a sort of narrative out there that young people hate foster care, they can’t wait to get out,”

The report, known as the Midwest Study followed more than 700 teens in foster care in Illinois, Iowa and Wisconsin from age 17 to 26.  Of the three states, Illinois allows foster youth to remain in the system until they’re 21.

On January 1, 2012, California foster youth will have that option when AB 12, the California Fostering Connections to Success Act, takes effect.

“We need to make it so if you’re the place they want to come back to, we maximize the likelihood they can do that.  But at the policy level, the policy must be that they can come back,” said Courtney, thumping his hand on the table for emphasis.  “That’s how to think about it, what would a good parent do?  That’s how our policy and practice should be carried out.”

*Stuart and Johnson are funders of TOP-Ed

Wednesday, November 02, 2011

U P D A T E D: CSEA RATIFIES AGREEMENT WITH LAUSD + smf’s 2¢ questions

originally posted 1 Nov 2011 9:57 PM

UPDATED 2 Nov WITH NEW QUESTIONS

U P D A T E:

Agreement restores some non-teaching jobs at L.A. schools

by Howard Blume | LA Times/LA NOW  | http://lat.ms/rLPyeM

Photo: Library aide Mary Bates reads "The Giving Tree" to kindergarten and first grade students in the library at Burton Elementary School in Panorama City. She works six hours a week and LAUSD wanted to cut her to three hours a week. Credit: Anne Cusack / Los Angeles TimesNovember 1, 2011 |  6:19 pm - Non-teaching employees have ratified an agreement that restores well over 200 jobs at Los Angeles-area schools, but hundreds of others will remain without a job or will continue to work at reduced pay.

The agreement, announced Tuesday, settles for this year a contract dispute between the Los Angeles Unified School District and the California School Employees Assn., which represents such workers as office clerks, financial managers and library aides.

The deal means that every middle school will have at least one six-hour library aide. Middle schools also will have a full-time financial manager. More than 120 office clerks will return to work, about half of them in four-hour positions and the rest full time.

The restoration will be paid for with the $2 million that the district saved when each worker took four unpaid days off. The district also is kicking in $6 million that was part of a year-end surplus.

The Los Angeles Board of Education ratified the agreement in October. Employees should be back on the job by mid-November, said district spokesman Thomas Waldman.

Non-teaching employees have suffered thousands of layoffs over the last three years, most recently on Sept. 23 when 748 employees lost positions. In addition, 1,428 workers had their hours reduced or were reassigned to a different job or location, frequently with a reduction in pay.

In some cases, the remaining employees dealt with both challenges, such as library aides who suddenly were offered only three-hour-a-day jobs with no health benefits and often with lengthy commutes.

“Too many people, especially library aides, couldn’t afford to return to work … that caused them to use more in gasoline to get there,” said union field representative Connie Moreno.

Some but not all elementary schools are likely to have a library aide restored. Some schools had already elected to use discretionary funds to keep their library open at least part time.

Job losses and pay reductions haven’t been the only issue. The union also has challenged the legality of the district supplanting professionals -- who frequently must manage confidential documents -- with parent volunteers or part-time, low-wage teacher aides.

Still, both sides seemed relieved to get an agreement on partial restorations.

“I am very pleased that our members overwhelmingly approved” the pact, said union local President Espie Medellin in a joint statement.

“This agreement returns vital staff to many of our campuses,” said L.A. schools Supt. John Deasy. “I applaud CSEA and its members for taking this step. At a time of crippling budget cuts, restoring these positions is especially welcome news for principals, teachers, and parents.”

 the 64¢ question:  WHO’S FOOLING WHOM?

●● The numbers don’t add up. Maybe they’re intended to divide+conquer?

● “How do you “Restore” a job that wasn’t there? Many of the Financial Manager jobs didn’t exist before the RIFs.

● To say Elementary Librarian/Teacher Aides are ‘non-teaching’ jobs strains incredulity – this is bait-and-switch and/or Orwellian logic at it’s most tortured – or “spin” at its most dizzying. The District last year went through the charade of ‘not-for’ show trials challenging whether teacher-librarians teach …and lost.  Do we really want to go there again?

Make no mistake: Library Aide/Elementary Librarians - under the supervision of credentialed ‘Field Librarians” - teach. They teach children to use the library, to use computers, to use the internet, to do research, to think independently – to think outside the classroom.

● …except that all the Field Librarian jobs have been eliminated.

● Previously Middle School Libraries were staffed by credentialed Library Media Specialists (aka: Teacher-Librarians) , credentialed teachers with a specialty in library science. Now the District the superintendent proposes to replace them with Library Aides.  This is in violation of federal mandate, state law and the union contract.

….and good educational policy – which trumps the other three.

end update/original story follows

LAUSD Press Release

image

 the (original) 2¢ questions:

●● Who decides which schools get their elementary librarians/library aides back – and on what basis?

●● Do the schools who made the commitment to their kids and literacy and used their own funds – either from discretionary budget funds or fundraising/bake sale money - get their money back?

●● Approximately 250 elementary librarians/library aides were RIFed – and 98 come back – yet more financial managers are being hired than were RIFed  …and that’s good news? 

  “At a time of crippling budget cuts, restoring these positions is especially welcome news for principals, teachers, and parents.”

Is that the trifecta of priorities? What about the kids?

Tuesday, November 01, 2011

HOLLYWOOD HIGH SCHOOL HOSTS “FRENCH OPEN MARKET PLACE”

HHS Alumni Association/Councilman LaBonge Press Release

(November 5, 2011: Los Angeles) – Councilman Tom LaBonge encourages people to check-out a new French-inspired outdoor market in Hollywood. It’s called “Open Market Place”, and will be held on the first Saturday of every month to generate funds to support various programs at Hollywood High School. Organizers of the market pay rent to the school for use of the grounds and 25% of the proceeds of admission tickets will go directly to school coffers. “I support community partnerships,” said Councilman LaBonge. “And this market’s support of programs at Hollywood High School is a creative approach to helping our schools, which are so financially challenged right now.”

Open Market Place is the brain-child of its founder David Pilcer, who started working in the markets of France selling perfume at the age of 18. Pilcer says he wanted to bring a little flavor of Paris to Los Angeles with this new French-Inspired artist, designer and vintage marketplace. He sees it as a premiere venue for emerging artists, indie designers, vintage collectors and hand-made crafters to set up shop, meet colleagues and get in touch directly with their customers. Add live music and trendy food trucks, and you have a fun and eclectic shopping experience for the whole family.

WHAT: Debut of “French Open Market Place”. Grand Opening and Ribbon Cutting Ceremony
WHEN: Saturday, November 5th, 2011 – 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM (then the first Saturday of every month)
WHERE: Hollywood High School, 1521 North Highland Avenue, Hollywood, Ca. 90028
WHO: French Consul General for Los Angeles David Martinon, various city officials, 75 vendors, customers and others.

Also contact: David Pilcer, Open Market Place
david.openmarketplace@gmail.com 310-213-6595

YOU TUBE VIDEO

###

Todd D. Leitz
Communications Deputy
Los Angeles City Councilmember TOM LABONGE
213.473.2344 - direct office line
323.706.2396 - mobile Blackberry
todd.leitz@lacity.org
www.tomlabonge.com

Visit Hollywood High School Alumni at: http://www.hhsalum.org/



 

CSEA RATIFIES AGREEMENT WITH LAUSD + smf’s 2¢ questions

THIS STORY HAS BEEN UPDATED HERE

AT-RISK QEIA SCHOOLS CONTINUE TO EXCEL

california teachers association press release | http://bit.ly/uMGfP7

Contact: Mike Myslinski, 650-552-5324 or 408-921-5769 (cell) | http://bit.ly/uMGfP7

T H E    S P I N

UTLA

UTLAnow UTLA

TWEET: Dramatic positive results from QEIA funded schools show that resources, not reconstitution, is the answer. bit.ly/s37Hjw

 

N O T E:  SB 1133 — THE Quality Education Investment Act (QEIA) — akA: "The Governor's Broken Promise”

QEIA funding comes from a settlement of a lawsuit brought by CTA against the Schwarzenegger Administration for failing to meet the minimum funding guarantees to education under Proposition 98 when Arnold was playing fast-and-loose with the budget numbers – taking property tax revenue from schools to give to cities and counties.  Education stakeholders sued when the governor broke a promise of repayment. The plaintiffs won the lawsuit and legislators passed  a bill that apportioned all of the money (which was withheld from every school in the state) to the lowest decile schools .

The  list QEIA schools in LAUSD are posted at the end of this webpost.

 

BURLINGAME – In positive news for a landmark, CTA-backed school reform program, the overwhelming majority of the 500 at-risk California public schools getting extra resources from the Quality Education Investment Act are exceeding academic growth targets set by the 2006 QEIA law, preliminary new state data show.

Teachers at these schools are sharing best practices that work. Research has shown that QEIA has been a catalyst for increasing teacher collaboration, improving instruction, and strengthening the quality of professional development in several schools.

To continue to receive their share of nearly $3 billion in resources over eight years for smaller class sizes, more counselors, better teacher training and other proven reforms, these mostly high-poverty QEIA schools have to meet various targets. They had to exceed three-year average growth targets defined by the state’s Academic Performance Index (API), which is based primarily on standardized test scores. The good news is that approximately 85 percent of the QEIA schools exceeded those three-year API targets – and a remarkable 95 percent or so had positive API score growth during that period, preliminary state data indicate. More than half of the QEIA schools that exceeded their three-year targets exceeded them by three times or more the required average API score.

“More than three full years of targeting these at-risk schools with the proven reforms that matter most is clearly paying off with significant academic achievement,” said Dean E. Vogel, president of the 325,000-member California Teachers Association. “This program’s emphasis on the value of teacher collaboration and parental involvement is working. An overwhelming number of QEIA schools are exceeding the academic benchmarks set for them by the law – and that’s great news, considering that the advances come despite unprecedented education cuts statewide.”

The California Department of Education is nearly finished with certifying the API growth target data for all QEIA schools. The trend is overwhelmingly positive, especially considering that many of these schools are in districts that were hit hard by cuts.

In the past four years, K-12 schools and community colleges suffered at least $18 billion in cuts and deferrals. The QEIA funding was not interrupted, however, since it was part of a CTA school funding lawsuit settlement, which led to Senate Bill 1133 and the creation of the QEIA program. It serves nearly 500,000 mostly lower-income, ethnic minority students. Targeted schools must also reduce class sizes and meet other requirements to stay in the program.

The QEIA program is the largest school turn-around program of its kind in the nation.

The carefully targeted QEIA reforms are working. The law’s funding is intended to reduce class sizes, improve teacher and principal training, and ensure instruction by qualified teachers. The program also provides more school counselors, increased parental involvement through school site councils, and gives schools the flexibility they need to support programs that best fit the local needs of their students.

Independent research also shows the value of QEIA in ways that go beyond API test scores. For example, a November 2010 report by an independent research firm tracking QEIA made these conclusions:

• Smaller class sizes matter at QEIA schools and allow teachers to focus more on classroom instruction. School implementation plans are largely focused on class size reduction, professional development, collaboration time and the adoption of curricular interventions.

• Professional development decisions in higher growth schools are made in collaborative teams with teacher input, leading to greater satisfaction among all stakeholders.

• Higher API growth QEIA schools used student data to guide and focus professional development decisions.

• Higher API growth schools also engaged in more teacher collaboration to develop lesson plans, create common assessments and analyze student data. 

To read the 40-page report titled “Lessons From The Classroom: Initial Success for At-Risk Students” and to follow more updates on the QEIA program, go to www.cta.org.

###

The 325,000-member California Teachers Association is affiliated with the 3.2 million-member National Education Association.

L A U S D     Q E I A     S C H O O L S

• Abraham Lincoln Senior High
• Academic Performance
• Alain Leroy Locke Senior High*
• Andrew Carnegie Middle
• Audubon Middle
• Bell Senior High
• Belmont Senior High
• Belvedere Middle
• Berendo Middle
• Bret Harte Preparatory Intermediate
• Bridge Street Elementary
• Charles Drew Middle
• Charles Maclay Middle
• Chester W. Nimitz Middle
• CIVITAS School of Leadersp
• Crenshaw Senior High
• Daniel Webster Middle
• David Starr Jordan Senior High
• David Wark Griffith Middle
• Edward R. Roybal HS
• Edwin Markham Middle
• El Sereno Middle
• Elizabeth Learning Center
• Evelyn Thurman Gratts Elementary
• Evergreen Avenue Elementary
• Farmdale Elementary
• Fernangeles Elementary
• Florence Nightingale Middle
• Francisco Sepulveda Middle
• George Washington Carver Middle
• George Washington Preparatory High
• Glenn Hammond Curtiss Middle
• Gulf Avenue Elementary
• Helen Bernstein

• Henry Clay Middle
• Hillcrest Drive Elementary
• Hollenbeck Middle
• Hollywood Senior High
• Horace Mann Junior High
• Huntington Park Senior High
• Hyde Park Blvd. Elementary
• James A. Garfield Senior High
• John Adams Middle
• John C. Fremont Senior High
• John Muir Middle
• Johnnie Cochran, Jr., Middle
• Joseph Le Conte Middle
• Langdon Avenue Elementary
• Leichty MS
• Los Angeles Academy Middle
• Los Angeles High School of the Arts
• Los Angeles Senior High
• Los Angeles Teacher Preparatory Academy
• Magnolia Avenue Elementary
• Main Street Elementary
• Malabar Street Elementary
• Manchester Avenue Elementary
• Manual Arts Senior High
• Mark Twain Middle
• Mary McLeod Bethune Middle
• Miramonte Elementary
• Napa Street Elementary
• Nevin Avenue Elementary
• Northridge Middle
• Olive Vista Middle
• One Hundred Fifty-Third Street
• One Hundred Seventh Street Elementary

• One Hundred Twelfth Street Elementary
• Pacoima Middle
• Park Avenue Elementary
• Phineas Banning Senior High
• Ritter Elementary
• Robert E. Peary Middle
• Robert Louis Stevenson Middle
• Samuel Gompers Middle
• San Fernando Middle
• School for the Visual Arts & Humanities
• Seventy-Fifth Street Elementary
• Sun Valley Middle
• Susan Miller Dorsey Senior High
• Sylmar Senior High
• Tenth Street Elementary
• Theodore Roosevelt Senior High
• Thomas A. Edison Middle
• Thomas Jefferson Senior High
• Trinity Street Elementary
• Van Nuys Middle
• Vermont Avenue Elementary
• Virgil Middle
• Vista Middle
• Weigand Avenue Elementary
• West Adams Preparatory HS
• West Vernon Avenue Elementary
• Western Avenue Elementary
• Wilmington Middle
• Woodcrest Elementary
• Woodrow Wilson Senior High

LAUSD FACES SUIT LINKING TEACHER RATINGS TO STUDENT PERFORMANCE + smf’s 2¢

The suit would demand that LAUSD comply with a 1971 California law requiring that student performance be part of the evaluations of teachers and principals.

By Howard Blume, Los Angeles Times | http://lat.ms/rHlk0E

&nbsp;

L.A. schools Supt. John Deasy is locked in a stalemate with the teachers union over performance reviews.

October 31, 2011, 8:24 p.m. - A group of parents and education advocates is preparing to sue the Los Angeles school district, demanding that it follow an arcane 40-year-old law that requires all California school systems to link teacher and principal evaluations to student performance.

The law, known as the Stull Act, was passed in 1971 with bipartisan support although neither school district officials nor teachers unions ever pushed to enforce all of its provisions, with their potential for conflict.

Now, with L.A. schools Supt. John Deasy locked in a stalemate with the teachers union over performance reviews, a prominent group of advocates believes it can force the issue with a lawsuit, which is expected to be filed Tuesday.

FOR THE RECORD:

An earlier version of this article named Netflix founder Reed Hastings and former L.A. Mayor Richard Riordan as members of the EdVoice board. They are no longer on the board.

Although the lawsuit would be technically filed against L.A. Unified, its underlying target is the teachers union, which has fought efforts to make student test scores any part of evaluations. United Teachers Los Angeles leaders say tests scores are too unreliable and narrowly focused to use for high-stakes personnel decisions.

The issue is bigger than L.A. Unified, said Arun Ramanathan, executive director of Education Trust-West, a nonprofit advocacy group not involved in the pending litigation.

"This has implications for every school district in California," he said. "This has the potential to put districts on notice that they should be fundamentally rethinking their evaluation systems."

The lawsuit was drafted in consultation with EdVoice, a Sacramento-based group. Its board includes arts and education philanthropist Eli Broad, former ambassador Frank Baxter and healthcare company executive Richard Merkin.

Tracking student progress "is a required element of evaluations, and the union and district cannot bargain it away," said attorney Scott Witlin, whose firm, Barnes & Thornburg, is preparing the suit. "If the adults in the system can't get their acts together to comply with the law, then people have to intervene and force them to comply."

The Stull Act demand surfaced in an Oct. 26 letter giving L.A. Unified until the close of business Monday to demonstrate that it will follow state law regarding teacher evaluations.

The district "refuses to implement the Stull Act in complete abdication of its responsibility to its students, their parents and the taxpayers of the district," states the letter, signed by attorney R. DeWitt Kirwan. "We demand that this change."

The timing is no accident. District officials had set Tuesday as the deadline for settling key contract provisions, including some involving evaluations.

Nationwide, a growing number of school systems and states have begun to include student data in teacher evaluations. The approach is strongly backed by the Obama administration, although California has not followed the trend.

Forty years ago, however, California was on the vanguard of evaluating teachers. Former Republican Assemblyman John Stull of San Diego sought to ensure that teachers and principals would be accountable for the academic performance of students. He also wanted teachers to receive the help they needed to be effective.

Stull's bill received mixed support from unions: The California Teachers Assn. backed it; the California Federation of Teachers opposed it. Among other provisions, the law set up a three-person panel that would review teacher dismissals. Previously, a district went to Superior Court to fire a tenured teacher, said education consultant John Mockler, who developed the original legislation with Stull.

As a conservative who believed in local control, Stull trusted school districts to develop their own evaluation systems that included student performance, Mockler said. But that didn't happen.

"The Stull Act has become a very cursory process, and it hasn't provided support to teachers," said UTLA President Warren Fletcher, echoing the view of district officials and advocates.

School districts and unions ultimately agreed to evaluation systems that declared virtually every educator satisfactory and set aside more contentious questions of whether students were learning.

Only now, with the school district and the union unable to agree on teacher evaluations, has the Stull Act been resurrected.

The Stull Act is imprecise on the type of evaluation measure to use. Some teachers, for example, might prefer using a portfolio of student work to demonstrate academic progress rather than a standardized test score.

But under the law, Deasy said, the district can decide how teachers will be evaluated.

The union's Fletcher said state law requires any teacher evaluation system to be negotiated with teachers.

"If the district is interested in putting together a reasonable, intellectually honest — and legal — evaluation system, you have to have teachers involved," Fletcher said.

Deasy responded by saying that the union's right to negotiations is far more limited. It applies, for example, to whether teachers would receive more pay for extra work in a new system but not to determining the evaluation method itself.

Witlin, the attorney, said his group would sue to stop any contract between the district and teachers that did not include all the requirements of the Stull Act. Deasy also said he would not ink such a deal.

The litigation would mark the second time that outside parties have turned to the courts to exert pressure for a school-improvement policy opposed at the negotiating table by the teachers union.

The tactic was used last year in a suit supported by L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and public interest attorneys. It resulted in a settlement that protected schools from being affected disproportionately by layoffs that were formerly based only on seniority.

This lawsuit "could build on the success of our court victory … providing a legal framework to allow teachers, parents and students to improve learning in schools," Villaraigosa said.

2cents ●●smf’s 2¢:

● – While I don’t doubt that Mayor Tony ‘supported’  last years suit – I did too – as I recall he (or his Partnership for LA Schools) was actually a named defendant in the action.

● – Now "parents and education advocates" (AKA Eli Broad + Co.) are suing LAUSD to force teacher and principal evaluations based on a 1971 California law that can be interpreted to mandate evaluating and dismissing teachers + principals  based on test scores.

Never mind that that wasn't the legislature's intent.

That explains what this was all about.


4LAKids suspects  the school district, led by Broad+Tony's chosen superintendent and a bare majority of Broad'+Tony’s school board members won't put up much of a fight. The deal will be done behind behind closed doors because the settlement of lawsuits is outside the Brown Act - California's Open Meetings Law.

The teachers+administrators have been/will be/are being had.  And kids and parents too. 

Though “had” was not my first verb-of-choice.