Tuesday, November 22, 2011

“Effective immediately, all of our efforts to privatize the schools will be known as ‘®eform,’ and any opposition to those efforts will be known as ‘anti-®eform’.”

you can’t say we weren't warned


Test Today, Privatize Tomorrow: Using Accountability to "Reform" Public Schools …to Death

By Alfie Kohn | PHI DELTA KAPPAN  | April 2004 | http://bit.ly/tbOlf6

I just about fell off my desk chair the other day when I came across my own name in an essay by a conservative economist who specializes in educational issues. The reason for my astonishment is that I was described as being “dead set against any fundamental changes in the nation’s schools.” Now having been accused with some regularity of arguing for too damn many fundamental changes in the nation’s schools, I found this new criticism more than a bit puzzling. But then I remembered that, during a TV interview a couple of years ago, another author from a different right-wing think tank had labeled me a "defender of the educational status quo."

 

Alfie Kohn 


Alfie Kohn writes and speaks widely on human behavior, education, and parenting. The latest of his twelve books are FEEL-BAD EDUCATION...and Other Contrarian Essays on Children and Schooling (2011), THE HOMEWORK MYTH: Why Our Kids Get Too Much of a Bad Thing (2006) and UNCONDITIONAL PARENTING: Moving from Rewards and Punishments to Love and Reason (2005). Of his earlier titles, the best known are PUNISHED BY REWARDS: The Trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, A's, Praise, and Other Bribes (1993), NO CONTEST: The Case Against Competition (1986), and THE SCHOOLS OUR CHILDREN DESERVE: Moving Beyond Traditional Classrooms and "Tougher Standards" (1999). Kohn lectures widely at universities and to school faculties, parent groups, and corporations. In addition to speaking at staff development seminars and keynoting national education conferences on a regular basis, he conducts workshops for teachers and administrators on various topics. Among them: "Motivation from the Inside Out: Rethinking Rewards, Assessment, and Learning" and "Beyond Bribes and Threats: Realistic Alternatives to Controlling Students' Behavior." The latter corresponds to his book BEYOND DISCIPLINE: From Compliance to Community (ASCD, 1996), which he describes as "a modest attempt to overthrow the entire field of classroom management." His many articles on education include a dozen widely reprinted essays in Phi Delta Kappan from 1991 to 2008. Among them: "Choices for Children: Why and How to Let Students Decide," "How Not to Teach Values: A Critical Look at Character Education," "Test Today, Privatize Tomorrow," and "Why Self-Discipline is Overrated."


In an earlier age, I might have suggested pistols at dawn as the only fitting response to these calumnies. But of course there’s a lot more going on here than the fact that one writer has had his radical credentials unjustly called into question. The point is that the mantle of school reform has been appropriated by those who oppose the whole idea of public schooling.  Their aim is to paint themselves as bold challengers to the current system and to claim that defenders of public education lack the vision or courage to endorse meaningful change. This rhetorical assault seemed to come out of nowhere, as though a memo had been circulated one day among those on the right: “Attention. Effective immediately, all of our efforts to privatize the schools will be known as ‘reform,’ and any opposition to those efforts will be known as ‘anti-reform.’ That is all.”

Silver-lining hunters may note that this strategy pays a backhanded compliment to the very idea of change. It implicitly acknowledges the inadequacy of conservatism, at least in the original sense of that word. These days everyone insists there’s a problem with the way things are. (On one level, this posture is familiar: Polemicists across the political spectrum frequently try to describe whatever position they’re about to criticize as “fashionable.” The implication is that only the bravest soul – that is, the writer – dares to support an unfashionable view.)  But the word reform is particularly slippery and tendentious. The Associated Press Guide to Newswriting urges journalists to exercise caution about using it, pointing out that “one group’s reform can be another group’s calamity.”(1) At the same time, conservative politicians are being exhorted (for example, by a like-minded New York Times columnist) to embrace the word. “For my money,” David Brooks wrote earlier this year, “the best organizing principle for Republicans centers on the word ‘reform’” – which can give the impression that they want to “promote change, while Democrats remain the churlish defenders of the status quo.”(2)

Of course, this begs the question of what kind of change is actually being promoted, but begging the question is really the whole point, isn’t it? The “reform” of environmental laws has often meant diluting them or simply washing them away. And just ask someone who depends on public assistance what “welfare reform” really implies. The privatizers and deregulators have gone after health care, prisons, banks, airlines, and electric utilities. Now they’re setting their sights on Social Security. I was recently reading about the added misery experienced by desperately poor families in various parts of the world as a result of the privatization of local water supplies. The clarity of language be damned: They come to bury a given institution rather than to improve it, but they describe their mission as “reform.” As Lily Tomlin once remarked, “No matter how cynical you become, it’s never enough to keep up.”(3)

THE NATURE OF “SCHOOL REFORM”

But back to education. People with an animus against public schooling typically set the stage for their demolition plans by proclaiming that there isn’t much there worth saving.  Meanwhile, those who object are portrayed as apologists for every policy in every school. It’s a very clever gambit, you have to admit. Either you’re in favor of privatization or else you are inexplicably satisfied with mediocrity.

Let’s state what should be obvious, then. First, a defense of public education is wholly consistent with a desire for excellence. Second, by most conventional criteria, public schools have done surprisingly well in managing with limited resources to educate an increasingly diverse student population.(4) Third, notwithstanding that assessment, there’s plenty of room for dissatisfaction with the current state of our schools. An awful lot is wrong with them: the way conformity is valued over curiosity and enforced with rewards and punishments, the way children are compelled to compete against one another, the way curriculum so often privileges skills over meaning, the way students are prevented from designing their own learning, the way instruction and assessment are increasingly standardized, the way different avenues of study are rarely integrated, the way educators are systematically deskilled . . .  And I’m just getting warmed up.

Notice, however, that these criticisms are quite different from – in fact, often the exact opposite of – the particulars cited by most proponents of vouchers and similar “reforms.” To that extent, even if privatization worked exactly the way it was supposed to, we shouldn’t expect any of the defects I’ve just listed to be corrected. If anything, the micro-level impact (on teaching and learning) of such a macro-level shift is likely to exacerbate such problems. Making schools resemble businesses often results in a kind of pedagogy that’s not merely conservative but reactionary, turning back the clock on the few changes that have managed to infiltrate and improve classrooms. Consider the stultifyingly scripted lessons and dictatorial discipline that pervade for-profit charter schools. Or have a look at some research from England showing that “when schools have to compete for students, they tend to adopt ‘safe,’ conventional and teacher-centered methods, to stay close to the prescribed curriculum, and to tailor teaching closely to test-taking.”(5) (One more example of the destructive effects of competition.)

This is a point worth emphasizing to the handful of progressive-minded individuals who have made common cause with those on the right by attacking public education. John Taylor Gatto is an example here. In a recent Harper’s magazine essay entitled “Against School,” he asserts that the goal of “mandatory public education in this country” is “a population deliberately dumbed down,” with children turned “into servants.”(6)

In support of this sweeping charge, Gatto names some important men who managed to become well-educated without setting foot in a classroom. (However, he fails to name any defenders of public education who have ever claimed that it’s impossible for people to learn outside of school or to prosper without a degree.) He also cites a few “school as factory” comments from long-dead policymakers, and observes that many of our educational practices originated in Prussia. Here he’s right. Our school system is indeed rooted in efforts to control. But the same indictment could be leveled, with equal justification, at other institutions. The history of newspapers, for example, and the intent of many powerful people associated with them, has much to do with manufacturing consent, marginalizing dissent, and distracting readers. But is that an argument for no newspapers or better newspapers?

Ideally, public schools can enrich lives, nourish curiosity, introduce students to new ways of formulating questions and finding answers. Their existence also has the power to strengthen a democratic society, in part by extending those benefits to vast numbers of people who didn’t fare nearly as well before the great experiment of free public education began.

Granted, “ideally” is a hell of a qualifier. But an attack on schooling as we know it is generally grounded in politics rather than pedagogy, and is most energetically advanced by those who despise not just public schools but all public institutions. The marketplace, which would likely inherit the task of educating our children if Gatto got his way, is (to put it gently) unlikely to honor the ideals that inform his critique. Some folks will benefit from that kind of “reform,” but they certainly won’t be kids.(7)

People who want to strike a blow for individual liberty understandably lash out against the government – and these days they don’t want for examples of undue interference from Washington and state capitals. But in education, as in other arenas of contemporary American life, there is an equal or greater danger from concentrating power in private hands, which is to say in enterprises that aren’t accountable to anyone (except their own stockholders) or for anything (except making a profit).

Worst of all is a situation where public entities remake themselves in the image of private entities, where politicians pass laws to codify corporate ideology and impose it on our schools.(8) Perhaps the two most destructive forces in education these days are the tendency to view children as “investments” (whose ultimate beneficiary is business) and a market-driven credentialism in which discrete individuals struggle for competitive distinctions. To attack the institution of public education is like hollering at the shadows on the wall. The source of the problem is behind you, and it grows larger as you train your rage on the flickering images in front.

“FREEDOM” FROM PUBLIC EDUCATION

I try to imagine myself as a privatizer. How would I proceed? If my objective were to dismantle public schools, I would begin by trying to discredit them. I would probably refer to them as “government” schools, hoping to tap into a vein of libertarian resentment. I would never miss an opportunity to sneer at researchers and teacher educators as out-of-touch “educationists.” Recognizing that it’s politically unwise to attack teachers, I would do so obliquely, bashing the unions to which most of them belong. Most important, if I had the power, I would ratchet up the number and difficulty of standardized tests that students had to take, in order that I could then point to the predictably pitiful results. I would then defy my opponents to defend the schools that had produced students who did so poorly.

How closely does my thought experiment match reality? One way to ascertain the actual motivation behind the widespread use of testing is to watch what happens in the real world when a lot of students manage to do well on a given test. Are schools credited and teachers congratulated? Hardly. The response, from New Jersey to New Mexico, is instead to make the test harder, with the result that many more students subsequently fail. [Addendum 2009: "Math scores are up on Long Island and statewide - enough so that state educational leaders could soon start raising the bar....Meryl Tisch of Manhattan, the new Chancellor of the state's Board of Regents, said...'What today's scores tell me is not that we should be celebrating but that New York State needs to raise its standards" (Newsday, June 1, 2009.]

Consider this item from the Boston Globe:

As the first senior class required to pass the MCAS exam prepares for graduation, state education officials are considering raising the passing grade for the exam. State Education Commissioner David Driscoll and Board of Education chairman James Peyser said the passing grade needs to be raised to keep the test challenging, given that a high proportion of students are passing it on the first try. . . . Peyser said as students continue to meet the standard, the state is challenged to make the exam meaningful.(9)

You have to admire the sheer Orwellian chutzpah represented by that last word. By definition, a test is “meaningful” only if large numbers of students (and, by implication, schools) fare poorly on it. What at first seems purely perverse – a mindless acceptance of the premise that harder is always better – reveals itself instead as a strategic move in the service of a very specific objective. Peyser, you see, served for eight years as executive director of the conservative Pioneer Institute, a Boston-based think tank devoted to “the application of free market principles to state and local policy” (in the words of its website).  The man charged with overseeing public education in Massachusetts is critical of the very idea of public education. And how does he choose to pursue his privatizing agenda? By raising the bar until alarming failure(10) is assured.

Of course, tougher standards are usually justified in the name of excellence – or, even more audaciously (given the demographics of most of the victims), equity.  One doesn’t expect to hear people like Peyser casually concede that the real point of this whole standards-and-testing business is to make the schools look bad, the better to justify a free-market alternative. Now and then, however, a revealing comment does slip out. For example, when the School Choice Advocate, the newsletter of the Milton and Rose Friedman Foundation, approvingly described Colorado’s policy of publishing schools’ test scores, a senior education advisor to Republican Governor Bill Owens remarked that the motive behind reporting these results was to “greatly enhance and build pressure for school choice.”(11)

An op-ed published in the Wall Street Journal just before Christmas by William Bennett and Chester Finn underscored the integral relationship between the push for high-stakes testing (which they call “standards”), and the effort to undermine public schooling (which they call “freedom”). The latter bit of spin is interesting in its own right: Vouchers, having been decisively rejected by voters on several occasions, were promptly reintroduced as “school choice” to make them sound more palatable.(12)  But apparently an even more blatant appeal to emotionally charged values is now called for.  In any case, the article notes (correctly, I fear) that “our two political parties . . . can find common ground on testing and accountability,” but then goes on to announce that “what Republicans have going for them in education is freedom.”  They understand this value “because of their business ties”; unlike Democrats, they are “not afraid of freedom.”

Even in an era distinguished by unpleasantly adversarial discourse, Bennett and Finn redefine its lower depths with the charge that freedom is a “domain that few Democrats dare to visit.”  (Their evidence for this charge is that most Democrats exclude private schools from choice plans.) But this nasty little essay, headlined “No Standards Without Freedom,” serves primarily to remind us that the most vocal proponents of accountability – defined, as it usually is these days, in terms of top-down standards and coercive pressure to raise scores on an endless series of standardized tests – have absolutely no interest in improving the schools that struggle to fulfill these requirements. Public education in their view is not something to be made better; it is something from which we need to be freed.

MANY CHILDREN LEFT BEHIND

None of this is exactly new. “Standards” have been used to promote “freedom” for some time. But if that picture has been slowly coming into focus as education policies are enacted at the state level, it now attains digital clarity as a result of federal involvement –in particular, the law that some have rechristened No Child Left Untested (or No Corporation Left Behind, or No Child’s Behind Left). Even those observers who missed, or dismissed, the causal relationship up until now are coming to realize that you don’t have to be a conspiracy nut to understand the real purpose of this new law. Indeed, you have to be vision-impaired not to see it.

Jamie McKenzie, a former superintendent, put it this way on his website, NoChildLeft.com: “Misrepresented as a reform effort, NCLB is actually a cynical effort to shift public school funding to a host of private schools, religious schools and free-market diploma mills or corporate experiments in education.” The same point has been made by Jerry Bracey, Stan Karp, and a number of others. Lately, even some prominent politicians are catching on. Senator James Jeffords, who chaired the Senate committee that oversees education from 1997 to 2001, has described the law as a back-door maneuver “that will let the private sector take over public education, something the Republicans have wanted for years.”(13)  Former senator Carol Moseley Braun recently made the same point.

Addendum 2008: We now have corroboration that these fears were entirely justified. Susan Neuman, an assistant secretary of education during the roll-out of NCLB, admitted that others in Bush's Department of Education "saw NCLB as a Trojan horse for the choice agenda - a way to expose the failure of public education and 'blow it up a bit'" (Claudia Wallis, "No Child Left Behind: Doomed to Fail?", Time, June 8, 2008).

So what is it about NCLB in particular that has led a growing number of people to view it as a stalking horse for privatization? While any test can be, and many tests have been, rigged to create the impression of public school failure, nothing has ever come close to NCLB in this regard. Put aside for a moment the rather important point that higher scores on standardized tests do not necessarily reflect meaningful improvement in teaching or learning -- and may even indicate the opposite.(14) Let’s assume for the sake of the argument that better performance on these tests was a good sign. This law’s criteria for being judged successful – how fast the scores must rise, and how high, and for how many subgroups of students -- are nothing short of ludicrous. NCLB requires every single student to score at or above the proficient level by 2014, something that has never been done before and that few unmedicated observers believe is possible.(15)

As Monty Neill of FairTest explained in these pages not long ago, even the criteria for making “adequate yearly progress” toward that goal are such that “virtually no schools serving large numbers of low-income children will clear these arbitrary hurdles.”  Consequently, he adds, “many successful schools will be declared ‘failing’ and may be forced to drop practices that work well. Already, highly regarded schools have been put on the ‘failing’ list.”(16)  Schools that do manage to jump through these hoops, which include a 95-percent participation rate in the testing, must then contend with comparable hurdles involving the qualifications of its teachers.

The party line, of course, is that all these requirements are meant to make public schools improve, and that forcing every state to test every student every year (from third through eighth grades and then again in high school) is intended to identify troubled schools in order to “determine who needs extra help,” as President Bush put it recently.(17) To anyone who makes this claim with a straight face, we might respond by asking three questions.

1. How many schools will NCLB-required testing reveal to be troubled that were not previously identified as such? For the last year or so, I have challenged defenders of the law to name a single school anywhere in the country whose inadequacy was a secret until yet another wave of standardized test results was released. So far I have had no takers.

2. Of the many schools and districts that are obviously struggling, how many have received the resources they need, at least without a court order? If conservatives are sincere in saying they want more testing in order to determine where help is needed, what has their track record been in providing that help? The answer is painfully obvious, of course: Many of the same people who justify more standardized tests for information-gathering purposes have also claimed that more money doesn’t produce improvement. The Bush administration’s proposed budgets have fallen far short of what states would need just to implement NCLB itself, and those who point this out are dismissed as malcontents. (Thus Bennett and Finn: “Democrats are now saying that Republicans are not spending enough. But that is what they always say – enough is never sufficient for them when it comes to education spending.”)

3. What have the results been of high-stakes testing to this point? To the best of my knowledge, no positive effects have ever been demonstrated, unless you count higher scores on these same tests. More low-income and minority students are dropping out, more teachers (often the best ones) are leaving the profession, and more mind-numbing test preparation is displacing genuine instruction. Why should anyone believe that annual do-or-die testing mandated by the federal government will lead to anything different? Moreover, the engine of this legislation is punishment. NCLB is designed to humiliate and hurt the schools that, according to its own warped standards, most need help. Families at those schools are given a green light to abandon them – and, specifically, to transfer to other schools that don’t want them and probably can’t handle them. This, it quickly becomes clear, is an excellent way to sandbag the “successful” schools, too.

So who will be left undisturbed and sitting pretty?  Private schools and companies hoping to take over public schools. In the meantime, various corporations are already benefiting. The day after Bennett and Finn’s rousing defense of freedom appeared on its op-ed page, the Wall Street Journal published a news story that began as follows: “Teachers, parents, and principals may have their doubts about No Child Left Behind. But business loves it.” Apart from the obvious bonanza for the giant companies that design and score standardized tests, “hundreds of ‘supplemental service providers’ have already lined up to offer tutoring, including Sylvan, Kaplan Inc. and Princeton Review Inc. … Kaplan says revenue for its elementary- and secondary-school division has doubled since No Child Left Behind passed.”(18)

THE ACCOUNTABILITY – PRIVATIZATION CONNECTION

Ultimately, any attempt to demonstrate the commitment to privatization lurking behind NCLB doesn’t require judgments about the probability that its requirements can be fulfilled, or speculation about the significance of which companies find it profitable. That commitment is a matter of public record. As originally proposed by the Bush Administration, the legislation would have used federal funds to provide private school vouchers to students in Title I schools with lagging test results. This provision was dropped only when it threatened to torpedo the whole bill; instead, the stick used to beat schools into raising their scores was limited to the threat that students could transfer to other public schools.

Since then, Bush’s Department of Education has taken other steps to pursue its agenda, such as allocating money hand over fist to private groups that share its agenda. A few months ago, People for the American Way reported that the administration has funneled more than $75 million in taxpayer funds to pro-voucher groups and miscellaneous for-profit entities. Among them is William Bennett’s latest gamble, known as K12 -- a company specializing in on-line education for homeschoolers. (Finn sits on the board of directors). “Standards” plus “freedom” may eventually add up to considerable revenue, then. In the meantime, the Department of Education is happy to ease the transition: A school choice pilot program in Arkansas received $11.5 million to buy a curriculum from Bennett’s outfit, and a virtual charter school in Pennsylvania affiliated with K12 got $2.5 million.(19)

At the center of the conservative network receiving public funds to pursue what is arguably an antipublic agenda is the Education Leaders Council, which was created in 1995 as a more conservative alternative to the Council of Chief State School Officers (which itself is not all that progressive). One of its founders was Eugene W. Hickok, formerly Pennsylvania’s Secretary of Education and now the second-ranking official in the U.S. Department of Education.   Hickok brushes off the charge that DOE is promoting and funding privatization.  If there‘s any favoritism reflected in these grants, he says, it’s only in that “we support those organizations that support No Child Left Behind.”(20)

But that’s exactly the point. A hefty proportion of those who support vouchers also support NCLB, in large part because the latter is a means to the former. Take Lisa Graham Keegan, who was Arizona’s school superintendent and is now ELC’s executive director. She was a bit more forthcoming about the grants than Hickok, telling a reporter that it’s only natural for the Bush administration to want to correct a “liberal bias” in American education by giving grants to groups that share its philosophy.  “It is necessary to be ideological in education these days if you want to promote academic standards, school choice, and new routes to certifying teachers.’”(21) Notice again the juxtaposition of “standards” and “choice,” this time joined by another element of the conservatives’ agenda: an initiative, undertaken jointly by the ELC and a group set up by Finn’s Thomas B. Fordham Foundation – and, again, publicly funded thanks to DOE -- to create a new quasi-private route to teacher credentialing.

For that matter, take Education Secretary Rod Paige, who appeared at an ELC conference to assure its members that they were “doing God’s work” and has been quoted as saying that “the worst thing that can happen to urban and minority kids is that they are not tested.”(22) Indeed, Paige spent his years as superintendent in Houston doing anything and everything to raise test scores (or, rather, as it turns out, to give the appearance of raising test scores). At the same time, his “tenure as superintendent was marked by efforts to privatize or contract out not only custodial, payroll, and food services, but also educational services like ‘alternative schools’ for students with ‘discipline problems.’”(23)

Just this past January, Paige made his way around the perimeter of the U.S. Capitol to speak at the conservative Heritage Foundation, whose headquarters stand about a dozen blocks from the Department of Education.  His purpose was twofold: to laud NCLB for injecting “competition into the public school system” and to point out that vouchers – which he called “opportunity scholarships” -- are the next logical step in offering “educational emancipation” from “the chains of bureaucracy.”

The arguments and rhetoric his speechwriters employed on that occasion are instructive. For example, he explained that the way we improve education is “one child at a time” -- a phrase both more substantive and more dangerous than it may seem at first hearing. And he demanded to know how anyone could oppose vouchers in light of the fact that the GI Bill was “the greatest voucher program in history.” Paige was particularly enthusiastic about the newly passed legislation that earmarks $14 million in public funds – federal funds, for the first time -- for religious and private schools in Washington, D.C., which he hoped would turn out to be “a model program for the nation.” (However, “this isn’t a covert plan to finance private, especially Catholic, schools,” he assured his audience. The proof? “Many of the students in Catholic schools are not Catholic.”)

Paige couldn’t restrain himself from gloating over how the passage of this law represented a triumph over “special interests” – that is, those who just “ask for more money” and want “to keep children in schools in need of improvement.” These critics are “the real enemies of public schools.”  In fact, they put him in mind of France’s determined opposition to the Bush Administration’s efforts to secure UN approval for an invasion of Iraq.(24) (At another gathering, a few weeks later, he compared opponents of the law to terrorists.)(25)

Notice that Paige chose to deliver these remarks at the Heritage Foundation, which publishes “No Excuses” apologias for high-stakes testing while simultaneously pushing vouchers and “a competitive market” for education. (Among its other reports: “Why More Money Will Not Solve America’s Education Crisis.”) Nina Shokraii Rees, a key education analyst at Heritage who helped draft the blueprint for NCLB and pressed for it to include annual high-stakes testing, is now working for Paige, implementing the plans that she and her group helped to formulate. So it goes for the Hoover Institution in California, the Manhattan Institute in New York, the Center for Education Reform in Washington, and other right-wing think tanks. All of them demand higher standards and more testing, and all of them look for ways to turn education over to the marketplace where it will be beyond the reach of democratic control. Over and over again, accountability and privatization appear as conjoined twins.

To point out this correlation is not to deny that there are exceptions to it. To be sure, some proponents of public schooling have, with varying degrees of enthusiasm, hitched a ride on the Accountability Express. In fact, I’ve even heard one or two people argue that testing requirements in general – and NCLB in particular – represent our last chance to save public education, to redeem schools in the public’s mind by insisting that they be held to high standards.

But the idea that we should scramble to feed the accountability beast is based on the rather desperate hope that we can satisfy its appetite by providing sufficient evidence of excellence. This is a fool’s errand. It overlooks the fact that the whole movement is rooted in a top-down, ideologically driven contempt for public institutions, not in a grassroots loss of faith in neighborhood schools. The demand for accountability didn’t start in living rooms; it started in places like the Heritage Foundation. After a time, it’s true, even parents who think their own children’s school is just fine may swallow the generalizations they’ve been fed about the inadequacy of public education in general. But do we really think that the people who have cultivated this distrust, who holler about the need for more testing, who brush off structural barriers like poverty and racism as mere “excuses” for failure, will be satisfied once we agree to let them turn our schools into test-prep factories?

COLLATERAL DAMAGE

In any event, if we did so we’d be destroying the village in order to save it. No, scratch the conditional tense there: The devastation is already underway.  Every few days there is fresh evidence of how teaching is being narrowed and dumbed down, standardized and scripted – with poor and minority students getting the worst of the deal as usual. I have an overstuffed file of evidence detailing what we’re sacrificing on the altar of accountability, from developmentally appropriate education for little children to rich, project-based learning for older ones, from music to field trips to class discussions.(26)

Lately, it has become clear that piling NCLB on top of the state testing that was already assuming nightmarish proportions is producing still other sorts of collateral damage. For example, there is now increasing pressure to:

* segregate schools by ethnicity. A new California study confirms what other scholars had predicted: NCLB contains a “diversity penalty” such that the more subgroups of students that attend a given school, the lower the chance that it will be able to satisfy all the federally imposed requirements for adequate progress.(27)

* segregate classes by ability. While there are no hard data yet, it appears that schools may be doing more grouping and tracking in order to maximize test-prep efficiency.(28) All children lose out from less heterogeneity, but none more than those at the bottom – yet another example of how vulnerable students suffer the most from the shrill demands for accountability.

* segregate classes by age. Multiage education is reportedly becoming less common now – not because its benefits haven’t been supported by research and experience (they have), but because of “grade-by-grade academic standards and the consequences tied to not meeting those targets as measured by state tests.”(29)

* criminalize misbehavior. “In cities and suburbs around the country, schools are increasingly sending students into the juvenile justice systems for the sort of adolescent misbehavior that used to be handled by school administrators.”(30)  There are many explanations for this deeply disturbing trend, including the loss of school-based mental health services due to budget cuts. But Augustina Reyes of the University of Houston observes, “If teachers are told, ‘Your scores go down, you lose your job,’ all of a sudden your values shift very quickly. Teachers think, ‘With bad kids in my class, I’ll have lower achievement on my tests, so I’ll use discretion and remove that kid.’”(31) Moreover, attempts to deal with the kinds of problems for which children are now being hauled off by the police – programs to promote conflict resolution and to address bullying and other sorts of violence -- are being eliminated because educators and students are themselves being bullied into focusing on test scores to the exclusion of everything else.(32)

* retain students in grade. The same get-tough sensibility that has loosed an avalanche of testing has led to a self-congratulatory war on “social promotion” that consists of forcing students to repeat a grade. The preponderance of evidence indicates that this is just about the worst course of action to take with struggling children in terms of both its academic and social-psychological effects. And the evidence uniformly demonstrates that retention increases the chance that a student will leave school; in fact, it’s an even stronger predictor of dropping out than is socioeconomic status.(33) 

If flunking kids is a terrible idea, flunking them solely on the basis of their standardized test scores is even worse.  But that’s precisely what Chicago, Baltimore, and now the state of Florida are doing, harming tens of thousands of elementary-school children in each case. And even that isn’t the whole story.  Some students are being forced to repeat a grade not because this is believed (however inaccurately) to be in their best interest, but because pressure for schools to show improved test results induces administrators to hold back potentially low-scoring children the year before a key exam is administered. That way, students in, say, tenth grade will be a year older, with another year of test prep under their belts, before they sit down to start bubbling in ovals.

Across the U.S., according to calculations by Walt Haney and his colleagues at Boston College, there were 13 percent more students in ninth grade in 2000 than there were in eighth grade in 1999. Retention rates are particularly high in states like Texas and North Carolina, which helps to explain their apparently impressive NAEP scores.(34) The impact on the students involved, most of whom end up dropping out, is incalculable, but it makes schools and states look good in an age where accountability trumps all other considerations. Moreover, Haney predicts, “senseless provisions of NCLB likely will lead to a further increase of 5 percent or more in grade nine retention. And of those who are flunked,” he adds, “70 to 75 percent will not persist to high school graduation.”(35)

THE DANGERS OF COMPLYING WITH NCLB

Take a step back and consider these examples of what I’m calling collateral damage from high-stakes testing: a more traditional, back-to-basics curriculum; more homogeneity; a retreat from innovations like multiage classrooms; more tracking and retention and harsher discipline. What’s striking about these ostensibly accidental by-products of policies designed to ensure accountability is that, they, themselves, are on the wish list of many of the same people who push for more testing – and, often, for vouchers.

In fact, we can add one more gift to the right: By virtue of its definition of a qualified teacher, NCLB helps to cement the idea that education consists of pouring knowledge into empty receptacles. We don’t need people who know how to help students become proficient learners (a skill that they might be helped to acquire in a school of education); we just need people who know a lot of stuff (a distinction that might simply be certified by a quasi-private entity – using, naturally, a standardized test).  Or, as Bennett and Finn explain things to the readers of the Wall Street Journal, “A principal choosing teachers will make better informed decisions if she has access to comparable information about how much history or math or science each candidate knows.”  This nicely rounds out the “reform” agenda, by locking into place a model that not only deprofessionalizes teachers but confuses teaching with the transmission of facts.

The upshot of all this is that the right has constructed a single puzzle of interlocking parts.  They are hoping that some people outside their circle will be persuaded to endorse some of those parts (specific, uniform curriculum standards, for example, or annual testing) without understanding how they are integrally connected to the others (for example, the incremental dissolution of public schooling and the diminution of the very idea that education is a public good).

They are succeeding largely because decent educators are playing into their hands. That’s why we must quit confining our complaints about NCLB to peripheral problems of implementation or funding. Too many people give the impression that there would be nothing to object to if only their own school had been certified as making adequate progress, or if only Washington were more generous in paying for this assault on local autonomy. We have got to stop prefacing our objections by saying that, while the execution of this legislation is faulty, we agree with its laudable objectives. No. What we agree with is some of the rhetoric used to sell it, invocations of ideals like excellence and fairness.  NCLB is not a step in the right direction. It is a deeply damaging, mostly ill-intentioned law, and no one genuinely committed to improving public schools (or to advancing the interests of those who have suffered from decades of neglect and oppression) would want to have anything to do with it.

Ultimately, we must decide whether we will obediently play our assigned role in helping to punish children and teachers. Every in-service session, every article, every memo from the central office that offers what amounts to an instruction manual for capitulation slides us further in the wrong direction until finally we become a nation at risk of abandoning public education altogether. Rather than scrambling to comply with its provisions, our obligation is to figure out how best to resist.


The beginning of this article was adapted from the introduction to Kohn’s book, What Does It Mean to Be Well Educated?: And More Essays on Standards, Grading, and Other Follies, published by Beacon Press in 2004.

NOTES

1. The AP Guide is cited in Jan Freeman, “Reform School,” Boston Globe, January 11, 2004, p. L3.

2. David Brooks, “Running on Reform,” New York Times, January 3, 2004, p. 15.

3. To be precise, those who decry these semantic misrepresentations should be described as “skeptical” or “critical.” It’s those responsible for them who are more accurately described as cynical. (And while we’re being precise, the line I’ve quoted, like much of Tomlin’s material, was actually written by Jane Wagner.)

4. See David C. Berliner and Bruce J. Biddle, The Manufactured Crisis: Myths, Fraud, and the Attack on America’s Public Schools (Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1995); Richard Rothstein, The Way We Were?: The Myths and Realities of America’s Student Achievement (New York: Century Foundation Press, 1998); and the collected works of Gerald Bracey.

5. Kari Delhi, “Shopping for Schools,” Orbit [published by the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto], vol. 25, no. 1, 1998, p. 32. The author cites three studies from the UK in support of this conclusion.

6. John Taylor Gatto, “Against School,” Harper’s, September 2003, pp. 33-38.

7. After I made some of these points in a letter to the editor that appeared in Harper’s, Gatto wrote to tell me I had missed the point of his essay because he actually doesn’t support “the elimination of public education.” However, he does “hope to undermine centralized institutional schooling which uses the police power of the state to impose habits, attitudes, etc.” I can only assume that he is using the word public in a way I don’t understand. In any case, his furious attack on “mandatory” education – on universal schooling that is supported by the public treasury and administered by elected authorities – is one that has been warmly received by those on the right. Indeed, Gatto was one of the first endorsers of the Alliance for the Separation of School and State, which repudiates the idea of a “common school” and calls for “the end of federal, state, and local involvement with schooling.” (A conference sponsored by the Alliance “featured a wide variety of conservative speakers, including John Taylor Gatto,” according to a newsletter of Phyllis Schlafly’s Eagle Forum.) Elsewhere, Gatto has written that he is “deeply depressed by Jonathan Kozol’s contention that money would improve the schools of the poor.  It would not.”

8. For more, see my article "The 500-Pound Gorilla," Phi Delta Kappan, October 2002, pp. 113-19; and various chapters in the anthology that I edited with Patrick Shannon: Education, Inc.: Turning Learning into a Business, rev. ed. (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 2002).

9. C. Kalimah Redd, “Raising of MCAS Bar Is Weighed,” Boston Globe, April 30, 2003, p. B2.

10. Alarming failure, not universal failure. As education policy makers across the country have learned, there are political costs to having too many students flunk the tests, particularly if an unseemly number of them are white and relatively affluent. At that point, politically potent parents – and, eventually, even education reporters -- may begin to ask inconvenient questions about the test itself. Fortunately, by tinkering with the construction of items on the exam and adjusting the cut score, it is possible to ensure virtually any outcome long before the tests are scored or even administered. For the officials in charge, the enterprise of standardized testing is reminiscent of shooting an arrow into a wall and then drawing the target around it.

11. “In the Spotlight: Colorado,” The School Choice Advocate, December 2001, p. 7. Available at www.friedmanfoundation.org/downloadFile.do?id=222.

12. For an account of the carefully coordinated decision to stop using the V word, see Darcia Harris Bowman, “Republicans Prefer to Back Vouchers by Any Other Name,” Education Week, January 31, 2001.

13. The McKenzie quotation is from “The NCLB Wrecking Ball,” an essay first posted on www.nochildleft.com in November 2003. The Jeffords quotation is from Sally West Johnson, “Mathis Rips Feds Over School Act,” Rutland  [Vermont] Herald, February 5, 2003.

14. See, for example, my book The Case Against Standardized Testing: Raising the Scores, Ruining the Schools (Portsmouth, N.H.: Heinemann, 2000).

15. See, for example, the 2003 Presidential Address to the American Educational Research Association by Robert L. Linn, entitled “Accountability: Responsibility and Reasonable Expectations,” available at www.aera.net/uploadedFiles/Journals_and_Publications/Journals/Educational_Researcher/3207/3207_03PresAddress.pdf.

16. Monty Neill, “Leaving Children Behind,” Phi Delta Kappan, November 2003, pp. 225-26.

17. Bush is quoted in Eric W. Robelen, “Bush Marks School Law’s 2nd Anniversary,” Education Week, January 14, 2004, p. 20.

18. June Kronholz, “Education Companies See Dollars in Bush School-Boost Law,” Wall Street Journal, December 24, 2003, p. B-1.

19. The report by People for the American Way is entitled “Funding a Movement.”

20. Michael Dobbs, “Critics Say Education Dept. Is Favoring Political Right,” Washington Post, January 2, 2004, p. A-19.

21. Ibid.

22. The ELC quote is from Joetta L. Sack, “ELC Receives Grant to Craft Tests to Evaluate Teachers,” Education Week, October 10, 2001. The testing quote is from Robert C. Johnston, “Urban Leaders See Paige as ‘Our Own,’” Education Week, February 7, 2001.

23. Stan Karp, “Paige Leads Dubious Cast of Education Advisors,” Rethinking Schools, Spring 2001, p. 4.

24.  Paige’s January 28, 2004 speech, “A Time for Choice,” is available at www.ed.gov/news/speeches/2004/01/01282004.html.

25. Here Paige was referring to the National Educational Association, which he likened to "a terrorist organization" because it opposes some provisions of NCLB. He apologized, under pressure, for a poor choice of words but then immediately resumed his virulent criticisms of the union. See Robert Pear, "Education Chief Calls Union 'Terrorist,' Then Recants," New York Times, February 24, 2004, p. A20.

26. Among many other sources, see M. Gail Jones, Brett D. Jones, and Tracy Hargrove, The Unintended Consequences of High-Stakes Testing (Lanham, Md.: Rowman & Littlefield, 2003); and the examples cited at www.susanohanian.org.

27. See John R. Novak and Bruce Fuller, Penalizing Diverse Schools (University of California at Berkeley and Stanford University, Policy Analysis for California Education, December 2003). Available at: http://gse.berkeley.edu/research/pace/reports/PB.03-4.pdf.

28. “The federal No Child Left Behind Act demands that schools show proficient test scores for every student. One approach to achieve that, some argue, is to tailor instruction in groups of similarly skilled students.” See Laura Pappano, “Grouping Students Undergoes Revival,” Boston Globe, December 14, 2003.

29. Linda Jacobson, “Once-Popular ‘Multiage Grouping’ Loses Steam,” Education Week, September 10, 2003, pp. 1, 15.

30. Sara Rimer, “Unruly Students Facing Arrest, Not Detention,” New York Times, January 4, 2004, p. 1.

31. That explanation also makes sense to Mark Soler of the Youth Law Center, a public interest group that protects at-risk children: “Now zero tolerance is fed less by fear of crime and more by high-stakes testing. Principals want to get rid of kids they perceive as trouble.” Both Reyes and Soler are quoted in Annette Fuentes, “Discipline and Punish,” The Nation, December 15, 2003, pp. 17-20.

32. Scott Poland, a school psychologist and expert in crisis intervention, writes: “School principals have told me that they would like to devote curriculum time to topics such as managing anger, violence prevention and learning to get along with others regardless of race and ethnicity, but . . . [they are] under tremendous pressure to raise academic scores on the state accountability test.” (See “The Non-Hardware Side of School Safety,” NASP [National Association of School Psychologists] Communique, vol. 28, no. 6, March 2000.) Poland made the same point while testifying at a Congressional hearing on school violence in March 1999 – a month before the shootings at Columbine.

33. See, for example, the studies cited in Jay P. Heubert, “First, Do No Harm,” Educational Leadership, December 2002 / January 2003, p. 27.

34. That’s triple the rate for the disparity between ninth and eighth grade during the 1970s. See Walt Haney et al., The Education Pipeline in the United States, 1970-2000. Boston: National Board on Educational Testing and Public Policy, January 2004. Available at: www.bc.edu/research/nbetpp/statements/nbr3.pdf.

35. Walt Haney, personal communication, January 15, 2004. Haney’s study also found that there was a substantial drop in high school graduation rates, beginning, as a reporter noticed, “just as President Bill Clinton and Congress ushered in the school accountability measures [that were later] strengthened in the No Child Left Behind Act.” Haney is quoted in that same article as saying, “The benign explanation is that this whole standards and reform movement was implemented in an ill-conceived manner.” (See Diana Jean Schemo, “As Testing Rises, 9th Grade Becomes Pivotal,” New York Times, January 18, 2004, p. 23.) This, of course, invites us to consider explanations that are less benign.


Copyright © 2004 by Alfie Kohn. This article may be downloaded, reproduced, and distributed without permission as long as each copy includes this notice along with citation information (i.e., name of the periodical in which it originally appeared, date of publication, and author's name). Permission must be obtained in order to reprint this article in a published work or in order to offer it for sale in any form. Please write to the address indicated on the Contact page at www.alfiekohn.org.

www.alfiekohn.org -- © Alfie Kohn

PSC+LAUSD. What were they thinking?

PSC

http://publicschoolchoice.lausd.net/

Monday, November 21, 2011

PSC v.3.0: “AND THE THE APPLICANTS ARE….”

No outside groups apply to run South Bay and Harbor Area LAUSD schools up for bid

By Melissa Pamer, Daily Breeze Staff Writer | http://bit.ly/v1brnY

11/21/2011 06:07:18 PM PST  = Once again, no outside groups have applied to run Los Angeles Unified campuses in the South Bay and Harbor Area that are up for bid by nonprofit and charter management groups.

The school district on Monday released a list of applicants to run 25 new and academically troubled campuses that are a part of the third iteration of the district's controversial Public School Choice process.

Carson High School attracted applications from three groups - all internal. The Local District 8 office applied, as did two teacher groups that hope to run "pilot" schools within the larger high school.

The new Harry Bridges Span School, a K-8 campus set to open in August in Wilmington, attracted only the interest of Local District 8.

Central Region Elementary School No. 22, under construction in Playa Vista and also set to commence classes next year, was removed from the list of Public School Choice 3.0 campuses in May. That decision came at the direction of the Board of Education because the school will draw students from existing campuses that score above the state goal of 800 on the Academic Performance Index.

In previous rounds of Public School Choice, few local campuses drew applicants from charter organizations.

The district received 58 applications for the schools listed in this round. For more information, go to http://publicschoolchoice.lausd.net.

 

●●smf notes:

“The school district on Monday released a list of applicants…”

To whom?

As of this posting there is no “more information” on the PSC or LAUSD OFFICE OF (lack of) COMMUNICATIONS & MEDIA RELATIONS web sites

Student Journalism - VIEWPOINT: HOW SAFE IS OUR SCHOOL?

By Kauai Taylor News & Features  Editor | Westchester HS Comet / from MyHSJ | http://bit.ly/vfM0eW

Sunday, November 20, 2011  - How safe are our schools? Everyday you hear stories about young girls that are brutally stabbed by their jealous boyfriends, kids who bring guns to school because they have been bullied for years and they finally wanted it to stop, and teachers who have sexual relations with their students. Our parents send us to school every morning thinking that they are leaving their kids in a safe environment, but maybe these “safe havens” are the worst place of all.

On October 1, a girl at South East High School was brutally stabbed by her ex- boyfriend. The couple had been in an on-and-off relationship since the ninth grade, but during an argument at lunch, he got upset and choked her. The dean and another student stopped it, but in the end it wasn’t enough. If there had been school police around at the time, would Cindi Santana still be alive? What actions could have been taken to insure her life was never at risk?

How do we begin to make our schools a safer environment? In the beginning of the school year at WESM, there had been a series of pranks which involved kids setting things like trashcans and bushes on fire. During a particular bush fire, one of the history teachers ran to another classroom in the hopes that it had a fire extinguisher. Unfortunately, it did not. From there, the teachers resorted to filling up buckets in the boy’s bathroom and running back out to the flames. This is absolutely unnecessary! If this had been a more severe case -- say someone accidently fell into that burning bush -- what would have happened then? By the time the fire department came, it would have been too late.

There was a series of three school shootings in two days at Gardena late school year. In an interview, LAUSD Superintendent John Deasy said, “Since 1993, a Los Angeles Unified School District policy has required daily random searches for weapons at high schools. I have ordered that Gardena High School and all LAUSD high schools must comply with that policy.” I know several schools who have not implemented this policy, yet they act shocked and surprised when something bad happens on school grounds.

There are so many random things that can happen at school, and it will continue to happen no matter how much we wish otherwise. The fact of the matter is that schools are one of the most dangerous places for kids.

But, it is possible to make it a little bit safer; have parents call in and suggest to the principal to have random backpack checks. Create fun ways to incorporate school safety in class. And tell your friends that it is okay to speak up. Every voice does make a difference.

Let your child, best friend, student, or siblings know that the worst consequences come when you stay quiet; you don’t want to wake up one morning and find out that a student died because of something you could have prevented.

Tell us if you feel safe at school on our Twitter @TheCometNews. - Kyle Labaro

also in the comet

The Homecoming Dance: So, is it or isn’t it?

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By Kauai Taylor
News & Features Editor

Cancellation, then reschedule reveals bigger issues

full story

 

Teachers open their gradebooks online

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By Taylor McDaniel
Staff Writer

JupiterGrades lets students see grades online anytime

full story

 

Students give cafeteria food a chance

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By Nicole Turkson
Editor in Chief

The Comet samples WESM’s cafeteria food: “It’s edible.”

full story

 

Academic Recognition Night honors students

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By Nicole Turkson
Editor in Chief

Seniors who achieve academically, maintaining a cumulative GPA of 3.5 and above receive jackets in honor of their academic achievement

full story

 

Viewpoint: Is Westchester still Westchester?

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By Mecca Reed
Staff Writer

Two months into the school year, some things seem to stay the same

full story

 

The Homecoming Dance has been cancelled again

Sunday, November 20, 2011 By The Comet Editorial Staff

The Comet has learned that the Homecoming Dance has been canceled again due to low ticket sales. The announcement was made this afternoon in a WESM News & Events email with two words: "Homecoming can

full story

LAUSD > SAP > ERP > BTS RETURNS!: Phoenix Business Consulting Secures Contract With The Los Angeles Unified School District

 

The Acronym Scorecard + historical reminder:

SAP

SAP AG - Systeme, Anwendungen und Produkte in der Datenverarbeitung ("Systems, Applications and Products in Data Processing") is a German software corporation that makes enterprise software to manage business operations and customer relations.SAP is the market leader in enterprise application software.

ERP

SAP’s best known products are its Enterprise Resource Planning application (SAP ERP). Enormous cost overruns associated with botched SAP ERP implementations are the stuff of legend in IT circles.


BTS

Nine months after the Los Angeles Unified School District launched the SAP Human Resources and Payroll modules in 2007 — as part of a larger ERP rollout dubbed Business Tools for Schools, or BTS—tens of thousands of LAUSD employees at 700 schools were unpaid or overpaid or underpaid.

The situation for teachers—the vast majority of employees hit by the payroll snafu—got worse as the district unsuccessfully struggled to get the system errors corrected in time for tax season and other regulatory deadlines.

- from Wikipedia and e-week.com | more

LA Times: LAUSD Payroll Fiasco Comes to an End (Nov 2008)

The Google News Archive on the LAUSD Payroll Fiasco

 

from the LAUSD BTS page - What's New:

Budget reductions for fiscal year 2009-2010 will have a significant impact on services provided by the Information Technology Division, BTS (Business Tools for Schools) branch. Unfortunately, the reduction of positions has lead to a reduction of BTS-related services including the BTS Training Team.

press release from MARKETWIRE via COMTEX | http://bit.ly/sGgW33

LOS ANGELES, CA, Nov 21, 2011 -- On November 16, 2011, The Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) Board of Education selected Phoenix Business Consulting in a 6-0 vote as the implementers for a fixed bid contract for SAP financials and procurement. SAP is the world-wide leader in enterprise resource planning (ERP) software. The SAP software implementation at LAUSD will include the modules for general ledger, accounts payable, accounts receivable, fixed assets, funds management, grants management, materials management, warehouse management, Business Warehouse, SAS reporting and Supplier Relationship Management - Procurement for Public Sector (SRM PPS) 7.0. The project will take approximately 21 months to complete and will have 40 consultants working on the project during peak periods.

Phoenix Business Consulting was founded in 1997 and quickly became a leader in implementing SAP at state and local government agencies including cities, counties, higher education and school districts. The firm has a number of tools, reports, pre-configured systems and accelerators specifically designed for Public Sector customers. Phoenix Business Consulting hires only the highest skilled consulting resources and prides itself on never having failed in an SAP implementation project. Phoenix Business Consulting's particular area of expertise is taking over troubled SAP projects and seeing them through to completion.

Although a leader in Public Sector implementations, the firm also provides full-scale implementation, system reviews, training and support for diverse industries including: banking, consumer products, apparel, technology, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, automotive and manufacturing.

Phoenix Business Consulting has had over fourteen years of SAP implementation experience including a recent successful implementation of the financials and procurement modules of SAP at the Miami-Dade County Public Schools. Phoenix Business Consulting has had a 10 year relationship with the Los Angeles Community College District (LACCD) and a 5 year relationship with LAUSD. Phoenix Business Consulting received an overwhelming amount of support from the selection committee at LAUSD based on Phoenix Business Consulting's pricing, quality of resources and references.

Phoenix Business Consulting looks forward to continuing its successful working relationship with LAUSD on its implementation of the financials and procurement modules of SAP.

For more information, or to interview Phoenix Business Consulting, please contact Eileen Koch of Eileen Koch & Company Inc., a public relations firm, at 310-441-1000 or email eileen@eileenkoch.com.

LAUSD SET TO GO INTO AD BIZ + smf's 2¢

By Barbara Jones Daily News/Daily Breeze Staff Writer | http://bit.ly/uYHJ3A

Updated: 11/20/2011 11:11:43 PM PST - The next time you see a van on the freeway sporting an ad for a big-box store or a delivery truck promoting the latest box-office hit, the message may be brought to you courtesy of the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Los Angeles Unified School District trucks and vans will soon be touting merchandise, businesses and entertainment programing as part of the district's effort to tap new revenue sources. >>

With the state's yearslong financial crisis taking the district deeper and deeper into the red, the school board has decided - very reluctantly - to plug some of the holes in the budget by selling advertising space on dozens of LAUSD vans and delivery trucks.

"If public funding was funding public education, we wouldn't be out looking for ads," said school board member Steve Zimmer.

"It's a sign of the times - literally," Zimmer said. "It's basically a bake sale. And we have to decide: Should schools have to do bake sales to have a library? Should we have to turn to these kinds of methods for after-school and arts programs?"

With no resolution to the state's years long budget crisis, the school board felt it had no choice but to loosen the district's ban against using school property for advertising.

Members voted last Tuesday to contract with Texas-based Alpha Media, which will recruit advertisers and - after getting the board's OK - transform about 100 delivery trucks and 30 or 40 vans into mobile billboards.

Revenue from the ads - potentially $4 million annually - will be funneled into the general fund, with the goal of using it to pay for extra-curricular activities.

School buses are exempt Mark Hovatter, the district's procurement chief, said the ads are the first significant effort in the district's nearly yearlong campaign to generate revenue through commercial sponsorships.

While Alpha Media specializes in transforming school buses into mobile billboards, Los Angeles Unified officials insist that school buses will not be part of the deal.

Board members are equally adamant that they have control over the content to ensure the ads are consistent with the district's mission and message.

"We're essentially hiring a dating service to find the right matches for us," Zimmer said. "The actual advertising will still come back to the board for approval."

Michael Beauchamp, president and CEO of Alpha Media, said he understands LAUSD's concerns about content and will be judicious in setting up partnerships with the district.

Potential advertisers include colleges and universities, professional sports teams, auto brands or dealers, banks, big-box retailers, wireless phone carriers and local doctors and dentists, Beauchamp said. Restaurants - but not fast-food joints - and movies or TV shows that are appropriate for youngsters are also on the list.

A national trend

In the three years since he launched his company, Beauchamp said, the public has become increasingly tolerant of seeing commercial messages on public school property.

"Communities are fully aware that districts are facing tough times," he said. "Rather than raising taxes or laying off teachers, districts are looking at other ways they can bring in money."

In opening the door to advertising, Los Angeles Unified is joining other public entities and school districts that have resorted to commercial deals to bolter their sagging budgets.

In Los Angeles, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority shrouds its buses, light-rail and subway cars in ads, a campaign that last year generated nearly $28 million. City officials have given preliminary approval to a pilot program that would sell ad space on 500 of L.A.'s 774 trash trucks.

The Jefferson County School District in suburban Denver has brought in about $500,000 over the past four years from a local bank that advertises on its yellow school buses. The district expects to reap an additional $90,000 under a new three-year deal that will put ads for a nonprofit education savings plan on student report cards.

"The message has to match our mission - is it appropriate for kids?" said the school district's spokeswoman, Melissa Reeves.

Colorado's largest school district was especially sensitive to the issue, Reeves said, after learning of the controversy that erupted in 2008 in Seminole County, Fla., where McDonald's paid to print messages on report-card covers offering a free Happy Meal as a reward for good grades.

School bus ad anger

The Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, whose outrage contributed to McDonald's canceling that promotion, has launched a nationwide campaign seeking laws banning ads from school buses.

Franck Vigneron, a marketing professor at California State University, Northridge, called LAUSD's advertising effort an "acceptable but unorthodox" way to generate badly needed revenue.

"No one has a printing machine for money, so we have to use the resources available," he said.

Any criticism the district may face for allowing advertising on its property should be dampened since school buses are excluded from the plan.

"The key is the selection of the ads," he said. "The advertisement must be consistent with the district's goals and philosophy."

 

●● smf's 2¢: Full disclosure: I misspent large part of my youth – that part not misspent in the show biz - in the advertising business. My grandfather owned an advertising agency. I knew the actual characters fictionalized in Mad Men. 

Let me get this straight: The LAUSD Board of Education – who already complain that their meetings take up too much of their time – are going to routinely discuss and rule on the merits of ad campaigns?

WRIGHT MIIDDLE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL REMOVAL STIRS FURY

By Melissa Pamer,  Daily Breeze Staff Writer | http://bit.ly/vDGbDd

Updated: 11/20/2011 11:16:22 PM PST  - Still smarting from several recent battles with Los Angeles Unified, the Westchester education community is now reeling from the removal of a popular new principal at Orville Wright Middle School.

Kenneth Pride, a former assistant principal at Westchester High, was selected by a school hiring committee to lead the neighboring middle school in summer 2010. Earlier this month, he was dismissed and demoted to a teaching position - an action that he says is linked to his handling last May of an incident of a sexual nature that involved two students.

School district officials are saying little about either Pride's demotion or the spring incident, citing confidential personnel matters.

Pride has been awaiting an appointment to a teaching position while sitting in the Westside office of Local District 3, which oversees Westchester schools. He said he has never been written up for any incident in his 12-year LAUSD career.

Pride said district officials demoted him because he failed to follow district policy by not immediately calling authorities after learning of a sexual encounter between students. He said he did not call police because he did not know for several days the names of the students involved.

"I have been treated pretty funky, pretty bad. The district is taking the position that basically I'm an idiot," Pride said. "It's brutal, it's ugly. I'm left in the lurch. They came down with a sledgehammer on me."

His removal has prompted an outcry among parents and students. There have been multiple community meetings on the issue since Pride's Nov. 4 dismissal, said J.D. Webster, chairman of the education committee of the Westchester/Playa neighborhood council.

"People in the community, parents, teachers, are all saying this is wrong," Webster said. "People were outraged, upset. ... There have been student protests. ... This was their principal. This was a man they believed in."

Local District 3 Superintendent Brenda Manuel answered Daily Breeze questions about the situation by email, offering only generalities.

"The decision to reassign Mr. Pride from his position is a confidential personnel matter and, therefore, specific details cannot be discussed or revealed. The district considers allegations of a sexual nature to be a very serious matter and the protocol includes investigating these matters," Manuel wrote.

Pride said a male student involved in the incident on the school bus was expelled, and his mother had threatened to appeal the expulsion to the Los Angeles County Office of Education. Pride could not provide details of the incident because of a need to protect student privacy, he said.

Official can't speak

LAUSD board member Steve Zimmer, whose district includes Westchester, said he was "bound by confidentiality" not to speak about the matter.

Zimmer said he was "very distraught and worried" about the school, which some say was showing signs of improvement under Pride.

His dismissal is especially sensitive in Westchester because it's a community that has fought to have increased autonomy from LAUSD for its "Family of Schools." The removal in 2010 of a community-selected principal at Westchester High - and the conversion of that school to a magnet campus this fall - raised hackles.

Some cynically see Pride's removal as an effort by district officials to regain control of the sometimes troubled middle school. Emails to that effect have been circulated in the community.

Kelly Kane, a parent who has rallied others to return their children to neighborhood schools while also being publicly very critical of the district, is furious. She views the demotion as yet another blow to the community's effort to assert independence from LAUSD.

"The only vestige of that autonomy was to be able to hire our own principal. But yet again the beast that is LAUSD has cut us down and said, `No, you don't get to make that choice either,"' Kane said.

Regarding the school-bus incident, Pride said he reported it to school police as soon as he had the names of the students involved. He learned of the incident after it occurred from a student journal entry that provided no names, he said. It was reported several days later once the involved students' identities were confirmed, he said.

He said he followed district instructions in pursuing the student's expulsion.

"Now the district is saying there's something I did not do when I was following directions every step of the way," Pride said.

District investigation

In September, Pride said, a team of district officials descended on the school to investigate.

After questioning his handling of the May incident, Pride was notified Nov. 4 in a meeting at the district's downtown headquarters that he was being removed from his post. Assistant Principal Susan Allen was appointed interim leader of the school.

The same day, a letter was sent from Manuel to Orville Wright parents explaining Pride's reassignment. It provided no details.

"This difficult decision was reached after much discussion and deliberation," Manuel wrote.

Pride was returned to a teaching position, he said, because he had not spent enough years as an administrator to have rights under the district's administrator's contract to return to an assistant principal position.

A community hiring committee will select a candidate to replace Pride, Manuel said in an email.

Sunday, November 20, 2011

TRYING TO FIND THE ANSWERS TO AN ‘INEXPLICABLE’ ACT – a follow on to ‘Vigilance Is Powerful for Parents of Teenagers’

An email from a mother whose teenage son committed suicide is a reminder that blaming 'parenting' only compounds survivors' pain.

by Sandy Banks/LA Times columnist | http://lat.ms/uHC3D1

November 19, 2011- It has been not quite a year since her teenage son jumped from a building and killed himself. And her grief is still so raw, she couldn't help lashing out after she read my Tuesday column about a forum on suicide at Agoura High.

The advice offered that night to parents, stung by a string of recent deaths, seemed inadequate to her: Talk to your kids. Keep tabs on them. Don't let them use alcohol and drugs.

"I pity the parents who think that by being on top of their kids 24/7, that by drug testing them every time they come home from a friend's house, that by hounding their children, they can protect them, can stop them from suicide," she wrote.

Her son was "a brilliant student, a good athlete with a loving family" who "inexplicably" ended his life at 14. The details she shared are heart-wrenching. I pledged not to breach her family's privacy by disclosing them.

Her email forced me to consider the damage that suicide inflicts on a family. And it made me realize that blaming "parenting" only compounds survivors' pain.

::

It took Ester Ybarra Bryant three months to muster the courage to call the coroner's office and ask what killed her 13-year-old: Death by carbon monoxide. Suicide.

"I asked how did they rule it a suicide. They told me the evidence was overwhelming," she said. Her son had used a strip of rubber from his bicycle tire to bind his mouth to the tailpipe of an idling car in their West Covina garage.

She struggled to believe it. "I told the police somebody must have come into the house and made it look like a suicide."

Nathan had no drugs or alcohol in his system, just remnants of his favorite snack, a Rice Krispie treat. He was in the seventh grade, a Boy Scout and an altar boy. His father had died three years before, and the family had gone through counseling then.

"I was blindsided by this," Ybarra Bryant said. "We talked about everything: drugs, alcohol, sex. But never about suicide. "

In hindsight, there were signs. His grades had fallen from Bs to Cs. He'd stopped joking around at home. He'd given away his beloved pet mice and collection of Transformers toys.

"I thought it was just growing up, coming of age," his mother said. "Now I know I failed my son. That's the guilt that I live with; that I was not a good enough mom."

For survivors, guilt is a companion to sorrow, anger and pain.

"We all feel there is something we could have said or done that would have saved that person," said Richard Mogil, program director for Suicide Prevention and Bereavement Services at Didi Hirsch Community Mental Health Center.

"Ninety percent of the time, there is some form of mental illness involved — depression, bipolar, other personality disorders. It's not the person, it's the illness," Mogil said. "Some people will go to any lengths to end their mental pain."

Didi Hirsch offers support groups for people who have lost a loved one — and for those who have attempted or are contemplating suicide.

Teenagers are particularly high-risk. Suicide is considered the third most common cause of death among adolescents. Some are trapped by youthful immaturity and self-centered tunnel vision. Some compound their struggle by self-medicating, abusing drugs and alcohol. Some are swept up by what a rabbi at the funeral of a 14-year-old called "a sudden emotional tsunami."

They all leave behind families wondering what they should have seen or done.

The reality is, Mogil said, "You can do something about what's happening with your loved one. But it may not be enough."

::

For all the progress we've made in understanding addiction and mental illness, suicide is still considered by many a shameful exit — a failure of will or character or parenting.

"Survivors feel the stigma," said Mogil, whose younger brother shot himself to death at 48.

Some don't feel welcome at conventional bereavement groups. "People are looking at them and saying, 'My loved one died of cancer or an accident. Yours chose to die.' That's cruel and blind and devastating," Mogil said. "It's the disease that made that choice."

Parents feel ambushed and isolated. "It's a sudden death, and yes, it does catch us totally by surprise," said a mother named Marilyn, whose 14-year-old daughter killed herself nine years ago.

"She had good grades, she was involved in school, she was active at our church. … She was moody, but we thought it was just a normal teenage phase.

"Looking back, there was depression that none of us recognized," she said. "We don't look for the warning signs until after something happens."

Now Marilyn volunteers on the Didi Hirsch Crisis Line, talking to people considering suicide. "They reach out because they're ambivalent. You try and sort of open their eyes. They don't necessarily want to die, they want the psychological pain to stop."

She has dealt with her own psychological pain — the burden of parental guilt — by learning to forgive herself.

"You listen to every mother's story: 'If I had done this, maybe it would have been different.' And you realize there is no guarantee," Marilyn said. "Even if we take them to every therapist and listen to every problem, there is no guarantee.

"All of us do the best we can, given what we know, in the circumstances we're in. This has been a very humbling experience."

From Marilyn's perspective, being a "hyper-vigilant parent" is better than the alternative. "Better than to have to say 'If I had only listened to that little voice' after your child is gone," she said.

But for the mother who wrote to me, newly bereft, there was no "little voice." Her anguished email said it still stings to hear rumors "that my son was — fill in the blank — taking drugs, being bullied, on antidepressants."

She recognizes that outsiders need a logical explanation for what is a frighteningly irrational act. It's a way of putting distance between my child and the suicide victim; a way of keeping our families outside the bounds of tragedy.

She offers, from the trenches, a wake-up call:

"The only thing that lets these parents sleep at night is this fantasy that they have the power in this situation to protect their child. If they knew the reality, if they knew OUR reality, they would never be able to sleep at all."

Information on the warning signs of suicide can be found on the website of the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, http://www.afsp.org

COMMUNITY CELEBRATES RIBBON-CUTTING AT SONIA SOTOMAYOR LEARNING ACADEMY

Politicians and educators were on hand to dedicated the recently opened high school.

By David Fonseca Echo Park Patch | http://bit.ly/rCYlsE

 

Goldberg and Kayser, center, cut the ribbon on Friday at Sotomayor Credit David Fonseca 

November 18, 2011 - Flanked by community members, students and politicians, local Board of Education member Bennett Kayser and former State Assembly, School Board and City Council Member Jackie Goldberg officially dedicated the recently opened Sonia Sotomayor Learning Academy in Cypress Park on Friday afternoon by cutting a big red ribbon.

Friday's ribbon-cutting ceremony was an affair worthy of the long battle fought by community members and politicians to build the state of the art campus on the former Taylor Yard grounds, complete with performances by the school's performance band and orchestra and the reading of a personal letter from the school's namesake to its students.

Parent Georgina Clink read the letter from Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, which urged students to make the most of the opportunities available to them at the new campus.

"My accomplishments are a direct product of the extraordinary education I received," read the letter from the Bronx,NY, native, born to the Puerto Rican immigrants. "Reading opens the universe to you and learning expands your horizons beyond your imagination. For these reasons, having your campus named after me is deeply touching and moving."

State Senator Kevin de Leon (D-Los Angeles) told the students it was a great opportunity to go to a school named after the justice.

"You shouldn't take that lightly," he said. "This is a great facility, unlike any I've ever attended. But that's not what matters. What matters is what you can make happen in the classroom with the help of your extraordinary teachers."

Los Angeles City Council Member Ed Reyes also urged the students to thrive. He told the students that though they had the fortune to attend a brand new, state of the art high school, they would also face challenges.

"Teachers are not being paid what they deserve, schools' budgets are being cut back, all that's left is you--your heart, your soul and your commitment to what's right," Reyes told the students.

Many of the speakers on Friday told the students that the community effort it took to build the school should serve as a model of dedication to students.

"This area was a brownfield, and the community had few places to go to build new schools," Reyes said. "The state wanted to make this area into a Caltrans facility, but the community stood up and said 'no.'"

Reyes also called for a round of applause for Goldberg, who in her various elected roles urged the city to listen to the community's calls for a new school on the property.

Sotomayor--which comprises three pilot schools and two charter schools--will draw students from Benjamin Franklin High School, Eagle Rock High School and John Marshall High School, helping to alleviate overcrowding at all three schools.

Among the students to speak on Friday was junior Kimberly Campos, who transferred to Sotomayor from John Marshall.

A former captain of the Marshall swim team, Campos said making the switch to Sotomayor was difficult, at first. She feared she would miss her friends and the confidence she received from competing in athletics. However, when an opportunity to transfer back to Marshall arose, she declined.

"I wanted to stay and be among the students who would set standard at Sotomayor," she said.

 

text of smf’s remarks at the ribbon cutting:

The work we've done together on the Bond Oversight Committee has always been about protecting the voters and taxpayers – making sure what you voted for – what we voted for – and what we are paying for and will pay for for a long time to come - comes to pass.

The voters voted for neighborhood schools. They voted to end involuntary busing. They voted to end the year 'round calendar. They voted for full day kindergarten in elementary schools. These things have almost totally come to pass.

We voted for these things for our children, for our neighborhoods, for our community.

Never has a community been more involved and more engaged in the process than here at this campus. We were there when folks drew a large circle on a map and said we needed a new school here In the Northeast – to relieve overcrowding at Eagle Rock, Franklin and Marshall. Franklin and Marshall were Year 'Round; Eagle Rock was busing their young people away.

This community identified that the school should probably be here in Taylor Yard. And some of us met in the Denny's down the street with the owners of this property to begin the discussion. Did we overreach? Did we go too far? Were we being pushy?

Yes, Yes, and Yes.

"Never underestimate the power of a dedicated few to change the world," Margaret Mead said. "They are the only ones who ever do."

We took our discussion to the District and we began to make it happen. Did we get everything we wanted?

No.

Was it hard? Were there obstacles? Did we face opposition and intransigence and greed and resistance? Yes, Yes, Yes, and Yes.

Some of the delay and opposition and angst was honest and well reasoned – some were not.

Did we win?

No. But we dared.

You won. Everybody won. The young people at this school today and generations to follow will win. They will connect with each other and with their potentials and they will overreach and go too far and push the edges of the envelope as far as it will stretch …and then a little father. They will dream the unimaginable and dare to make it happen.

When I started this journey I wanted my daughter at Mount Washington Elementary to attend this school. This June she graduates from college – because she wouldn't wait.

Don't be afraid to go too far and meet with those who stand in your way and bring them together with you to today. Dare to draw your designs on the placemat. You'll make friends along the way. You'll make a difference. And you'll change the world.

Change is not a spectator sport. It's a team sport, played with different levels of skill and involvement by all of us here – and by our friends and neighbors who aren’t here.

Change is not an outcome, it's a process.

Like life, it's an adventure.

We wanted a high school here. And we wanted a community college. One down and one to go.

So Ladies and Gentlemen, Boys and Girls: Dare to dream.

And thank you.

TEACHERS WHO JUST DON’T CARE

by Karin Klein of the LA Times Editorial Board in the Opinion LA blog | http://bit.ly/urFmAx

Teacher-Illustration

Illustration by Peter Bennett / For The Times

November 18, 2011 |  9:53 am - We can talk all day about test scores and what they tell, do, or don't tell us about the worth of a teacher, but most parents know the good and bad teachers on campus from a mile away. I was reminded of that at Thursday night's meeting of the school board at the Santa Monica-Malibu School District, which was mostly about whether the donations of parents at the rich schools in Malibu should be put in a central pot for use by students at all the district schools -- more coming on that next week.

But one mother spoke on a very different topic. It seems her Santa Monica school had instituted a new system that informed parents about their children's ongoing grades as well as their homework and other assignments, but that some teachers weren't posting the assignments. This mom wanted to make sure her sons were doing their schoolwork.

When she contacted the teachers, most were great about adding the assignments, but about one-fifth  told her that the union contract didn't require them to do that and so they weren't going to extend to her what they considered to be a "courtesy," not a necessity.

Of course, I don't know what the teacher contract says, and maybe these teachers didn't either. But there's no reason to doubt this frustrated woman's word.

Often, teachers write to The Times about reform by complaining that they are being held accountable for the failures of uninvolved parents. To some extent, that's true. But it's too easy for union supporters to avoid talking about truly awful teachers -- including the teachers who just don't care. Here's a woman who wants to be involved in a very direct way, helping the teachers by making sure her children do their part in the educational process.

The superintendent promised to look into it, and I'll be interested in hearing the results. If this mother's story is true, though, it's a perfect illustration of why the public is so fed up with teachers' unions and with uncaring teachers who go through the motions. For many parents, it's not all that important how much teachers improve their students' scores on a standardized test that the kids take once a year. What's most important is whether teachers care, whether they interpret information in ways that helped children learn and think, and in this case, whether they bother to do their jobs. From my perspective, any teacher who isn't willing to follow a school's policy by giving parents the information they need to do their job should be fired.  

Briefly: EVERYONE AT THE TIMES JUMPS IN TO DECONSTRUCT EDUCATION POLL

the poll results + smf’s 2c: http://t.co/cz9mOTpl

Californians willing to pay higher taxes for better schools

By Teresa Watanabe, Los Angeles Times

Even in tough economic times, 64% in a USC Dornsife/L.A. Times Poll say they would shell out more for taxes to boost public-school funding.

Survey finds ethnic divide among voters on DREAM Act

By Larry Gordon, Los Angeles Times

Among Latinos, 79% support government financial aid for illegal immigrants who attend state universities, compared with 30% of whites. And 49% of all respondents say UC and Cal State campuses are not very affordable or are unaffordable.

Charter schools impress half of California voters

By Howard Blume, Los Angeles Times

In the USC Dornsife/Los Angeles Times poll, 52% of respondents had a favorable opinion of charter schools. But voters overall opposed supporting charters at the expense of resources for traditional schools.