Thursday, November 10, 2011

FOCUS ON STANDARDIZED TESTS MAY BE PUSHING SOME TEACHERS TO CHEAT + Letters

The number of California teachers who have been accused of cheating, lesser misconduct or mistakes on standardized achievement tests has raised alarms about the pressure to improve scores.

By Howard Blume, Los Angeles Times | http://lat.ms/sM2rol

Tests

Documents and interviews suggest that an increasing focus on test scores has created an atmosphere of such intimidation that the idea teachers would cheat has become plausible. (Mark Boster / Los Angeles Times)

November 7, 2011 - The stress was overwhelming.

For years, this veteran teacher had received exemplary evaluations but now was feeling pressured to raise her students' test scores. Her principal criticized her teaching and would show up to take notes on her class. She knew the material would be used against her one day.

"My principal told me right to my face that she — she was feeling sorry for me because I don't know how to teach," the instructor said.

The Los Angeles educator, who did not want to be identified, is one of about three dozen in the state accused this year of cheating, lesser misconduct or mistakes on standardized achievement tests.

The teachers came from 23 schools and 21 districts — an unprecedented number that has raised alarms about the pressure California educators are under to improve test scores. In the worst alleged cases, teachers are accused of changing incorrect responses or filling in missing ones after students returned answer booklets.

Many accused teachers have denied doing anything wrong. But documents and interviews suggest that an increasing focus on test scores has created an atmosphere of such intimidation that the idea teachers would cheat has become plausible.

"One teacher has personally confided in me that if her job was on the line, she indeed would cheat to get the higher test scores," one Los Angeles-area instructor said. "The testing procedures haven't been secure over the past 10-plus years. Some of the 'most effective' teachers could be simply the 'most cunning.' "

None of the accused teachers contacted by The Times were willing to be identified. For the most part, even their colleagues declined to be interviewed, saying that any comments about their schools would only continue the ignominy.

But in off-the-record comments or reports filed with school districts, the accused have spoken of their motivations, their errors or their innocence. Many talked about the devastation that the cheating cases have wrought on their lives and their schools.

"I am losing my sleep over it," the Los Angeles teacher said in an interview. The teacher, who taught at Virgil Middle School in Wilshire Center, denied cheating but retired under pressure. "I got so scared. I am crying now. It really broke my heart."

Cheating has been uncovered across the country as more states and school districts have made test results the key factor in teacher evaluations.

Investigations have found serious cases of cheating in Atlanta, New York City, Philadelphia and Washington, D.C. Atlanta's experience has become a parable for a system gone awry. Investigators there found cheating at 44 of the 56 schools they examined and identified 178 people thought to be involved.

This year's spate of misconduct in California ran the gamut:

A teacher in Chula Vista last spring gave students portions of the test to help them prepare. A teacher in San Francisco gave students hints during the exams. In La Quinta, a teacher violated rules by reading test questions and passages aloud.

The teacher at Virgil Middle School was accused of scanning the test and using actual exam questions to prepare students.

The number of alleged cheaters is minuscule compared with the 300,000 teachers in California. For the vast majority, cheating remains unthinkable.

"I can't for the life of me understand why a teacher would risk their job over this stuff," said Tina Andres, a middle school math teacher in Orange County.

But, she added: "Of course, many of them probably feel that they could lose their job if they don't."

It's a bind that teachers struggle with in the face of declining resources and students who often lack support and resources from home.

"The current system sets it up so students and teachers must succeed on a multiple-choice test, but it does not provide the resources to do so effectively," said one administrator who did not want to be identified.

"Both the system and the cheaters are wrong."

Such a combination can lead in rare cases to a dangerous logic, said Palo Alto High School English teacher David B. Cohen. Some teachers "might even feel that since they and their students have been treated unethically by 'the system' … that they might as well try to game the system in order to lessen its impact."

"With my own students," he added, "if I give meaningless assignments that have significant impact on grades and are easy to cheat on, I would never condone cheating but I can't claim to be surprised if it happens."

Some teachers insisted that their misconduct was about helping their students in reports to the state obtained by The Times through the Public Records Act.

At Franklin Elementary in La Quinta, for example, the teacher admitted she had violated rules by reading test questions and passages to students.

The teacher "said she had good students" and "wanted them to do well," according to a report sent by the school district to the state Department of Education.

The teacher at Chavez Elementary in San Francisco offered a similar explanation for why she gave students hints.

"The teacher reported that the students were very needy and had many questions" that made the teacher "uncomfortable," the report stated without further explanation. District officials declined to discuss the matter.

Underlying the rationales is a persistent anxiousness that many teachers said they feel over performance evaluations. These reviews are increasingly linked to tenure and dismissal decisions.

A lawsuit filed last week seeks to force the Los Angeles Unified School District to begin evaluating teachers with test data to demonstrate student progress. Those types of measures have been opposed by teachers unions and some experts, who see them as an unreliable, one-dimensional assessment of a teacher's skill.

Last year, The Times published "value-added" ratings of teacher performance, based on test scores, for thousands of L.A. Unified teachers in grades three through five. The school system subsequently produced its own similar yardstick, which has been released only to teachers, called academic growth over time. Administrators will be able to see that data in the coming weeks.

The school district also has launched a pilot program — without job consequences for participants — that tests a new evaluation system including a student-growth measure. The teachers union has gone to court to block it.

A focus on test scores can be found statewide. The partner of one teacher in a rural California county said there is an unhealthy preoccupation with test scores at his spouse's school — an obsession, even.

"You have no idea," the spouse said.

The veteran teacher, who'd been a recent honoree as the school's teacher of the year, was accused of inappropriately helping students during the tests. The teacher has contested the allegation.

There are tangible rewards and punishments for schools, dependent on test scores. High scores can earn prestige and boost neighborhood property values; low scores or none at all — the state can invalidate a school's ranking if cheating has occurred — can lead to loss of funds, the removal of faculty or administrators, and even the closing of a campus.

On any campus, a cheating allegation unleashes turmoil that is not easily calmed.

Parents at Short Avenue Elementary in Los Angeles rallied behind three teachers accused of cheating or lesser misconduct, questioning the evidence against them and asserting that one episode should not negate exemplary careers. All three instructors have decades of experience, and no one has challenged their ability to teach.

Parents also expressed concern about the undermining of their efforts to support the school and build its reputation as the best place for local parents to send their children.

"There is a risk right now that we are going to lose everything," parent James Zucker said at a meeting of school district officials and parents.

LETTERS TO THE TIMES: 10 Nov 2011 | http://lat.ms/sQFsCk

Teachers under siege
Re "Pushing teachers to the edge?," Nov. 7


At my first teaching job in 1970, I was supported by mostly engaged parents, involved administrators and great students. Even less academically inclined students had some degree of respect for teachers and fellow students.
Over the last 15 years, teaching has become very stressful. Administrators are under pressure to produce great standardized test scores. When I visit the high school I taught at, I feel the tension among my former colleagues.
Schools should not focus so much on standardized tests. Do we have to place more stress on our teachers?
John Pawson
Huntington Beach


As a teacher, I can understand the pressure we all feel today as educators.
I work in a low-income area where I often have to pick up my students to get them to school, give up a lunch or two to work with them and stay after school to help them with their homework.
If teachers make sacrifices to help their students, test scores go up.
It's easier to complain rather than putting the time and effort into the students we were hired to help.
Rick Howard
Claremont

Wednesday, November 09, 2011

Administrators Host Long Island Iced Tea Party?: PRINCIPALS REBEL AGAINST VALUE-ADDED EVALUATION

By Valerie Strauss. Washington Post | http://wapo.st/twfkoP

11/3/2011| updated 11/9/2011 - Scores of public school principals in New York are fighting the state’s new educator evaluation system, which ties the evaluations and pay of teachers and principals to how well students do on standardized tests.

New York has a new law requiring that 20 percent to 40 percent of the evaluations be linked to test scores, despite warnings by assessment experts (in this letter sent to the state Board of Regents in May) that there are too many problems with “value-added” methods of determining a teacher’s quality.

The state is one of more than 25 that are now either using or developing value-added models for assessment, encouraged by the Obama administration. Critics say that aside from the many issues with the actual formulas used — which can produce unreliable results — standardized test scores should never be a basis for high-stakes decisions.

Now more than half of the public school principals in Long Island have come together to oppose the evaluation system. Here’s the text of the letter that they signed, (minus the footnotes):

update 11/9: HERE IS THE ENTIRE DOCUMENT WITH THE FOOTNOTES AND THE SIGNATURES | FOLLOW THE LINKS TO SIGN YOURSELF!

APPR Position Paper 6Nov11a

THIS “CHOICE” WAS NOT A GOOD CHOICE

by School Boardmember Tamar Galatzan in the Galatzan Gazette | http://bit.ly/uyHS8v

Monday, November 7, 2011 at 5:02PM - On November 1, LAUSD launched a new program to fill out 2012-2013 magnet applications on-line. To my great frustration, just days into the application process, major glitches plague the system.

Traditionally the application, known as the Choices brochure, is mailed out to the family of every student enrolled in the district. Hard copies are also available in school offices and libraries. This year, for the first time, families received a post-card in the mail directing them to the LAUSD website, where they can fill out an on-line application. A few copies will still be available at schools and libraries, for those who do not have internet access, or who do not have children currently enrolled in LAUSD.

While I applaud the cost-saving initiative that was behind the move, if the program doesn’t work, it’s not worth anything.  Whether it be student handbooks, applications, or school lunch menus, moving on-line saves the district hundreds of thousands of dollars in copy, paper and mailing costs. In this case, district officials estimate the shift on-line will save the district close to a million dollars.

But, in the rush to get the new program up fast, it appears no one tried it. When I logged on myself to fill out applications for my two sons, who are enrolled in LAUSD, I received an error message. When friends logged on, the same thing happened. It turns out that if clerks at the school site didn’t enter all of the correct data, the application process sends an error message, with no advice on how to correct it. Deep cuts in clerical and office staff at school sites left many offices behind schedule in uploading the necessary student data. If that process has not been completed, families cannot log on. In addition, even a tiny error-missing a digit or mistyping, for example-will cause the system to send an error message.

I am troubled by the disconnect between well-intentioned district policies hatched in downtown offices, and life on the ground at our schools. Why wasn’t this system tested before it launched? Why didn’t anyone talk to school-based staff to see if all the necessary data had been entered? And why, now, when schools are short on staff, on paper, and often stuck with old, malfunctioning copy machines, are we leaving overworked school staff, once again, to explain, make copies, and fill in the gaps?

On Tuesday, after trying to log into the system with every combination of email address and phone number that I know, I expressed my concerns and frustrations to the Superintendent's office. They promised to make a ConnectEd phone call to the home of every LAUSD student guiding them to the internet portal that works. (eChoices). From there, families can print out the application, or file on-line. Those who have trouble on-line are encouraged to call 213-241-4177 to get assistance. Those without printers can go to their schools and ask for the Choices brochure, and if those are gone, ask the school to print them out a hard copy.

I, more than anyone, am impatient for change. But when the district launches a new way of doing things, we have an obligation to do it right.

-Tamar

 

●●smf's 2¢:

Tamar:

You are a bright woman, an attorney – which means you have a high school and college and post grad education. You have a state-of-the-art laptop computer that the district gave you – with a T-1 connection at Beaudry and a high speed connection – either cable or DSL - at home. You have a Wi-Fi Blackberry or an i-phone. You have IT support. You are, in two words: well connected.

Now imagine you are a recent immigrant with an eighth grade education who has more than one job - not because you choose to but because you need to. English is not your first language. You have a five -year-old PC with  dialup connection – or maybe you have a twenty minute block of time reserved at the library.

This part you don’t have to imagine: You want the best for your kids – and that opportunity is at one of LAUSD’s excellent magnet schools. The magnet application process is difficult and arcane, you need to accumulate points and bank the points so your child has a chance.

And now this.

Because someone was impatient for change and driven by urgency. Because someone didn’t learn the lesson of the payroll fiasco. Because someone rolled out a program districtwide without testing it out on a small scale first. Because someone cut a corner.

LACCD Scandals: LACCD ANNOUNCES NEW ACTION TO CONSIDER TERMINATION OF THIRD MAJOR BUILDING PROGRAM CONTRACTOR

LACCD PRESS RELEASE


LACCDBuildsGreen

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

LACCD Announces New Action to Consider Termination of Third Major Building Program Contractor
Notice to Turner Construction Company is the latest in LACCD’s drive to reform the Building Program

Media Contact:
Coby King
MWW Group
213.405.3791 (office)
310.489.3280 (cell)
cking@mww.com

Los Angeles, November 9, 2011 – Continuing the Los Angeles Community College District’s drive to reform its $6 billion Building Program, District Chancellor Daniel LaVista today announced that the District has sent a letter to a major LACCD Building Program contractor instituting a procedure that, after a hearing to be held next month, could potentially terminate its contract with the District’s Building Program.  The letter was sent to Turner Construction Company, which is serving as the College Program Manager and overseeing all Building Program construction activity at West Los Angeles College in Culver City, one of the nine LACCD colleges.

This is the third such letter sent in the past month.  On October 17, 2011, the District sent similar letters to FTR International, Inc. and Gateway Science and Engineering, Inc.  The letter to Turner has stated that Turner had permitted contractors to perform work at West Los Angeles College without (1) submitting written bids, (2) written contracts, (3) payment or performance bonds, (4) enrolling in the District’s OCIP insurance program and/or (5) providing certified payroll records or other proof of compliance with prevailing wage laws.

“By informing Turner of our intent to terminate its college program management contract, we are making it clear that no waste or mismanagement in our Building Program will be tolerated,” said LaVista.  “If anyone thought that the letters to FTR and Gateway were our only dramatic actions to improve accountability, they were mistaken.”

“This Board is aggressively rooting out waste and mismanagement in our Building Program,” noted Miguel Santiago, president the LACCD Board of Trustees.  “We will not tolerate shoddy work or underperforming firms at LACCD.  Today’s actions are another step in our efforts to reform the building program.  We are committed to taking whatever steps are necessary to protect the taxpayers of Los Angeles, including terminating multi-million dollar contracts.”

“As due process requires, each contractor should and will have an opportunity to explain its actions prior to a decision by the Board of Trustees,” said LaVista.  “At the same time, at the direction of the Board, we will continue to reform the Building Program and take whatever steps are necessary to protect taxpayer dollars and deliver results.”

About the Los Angeles Community College District
The Los Angeles Community College District, the nation's largest community college district, serves one-quarter million students a year in more than 36 cities in Los Angeles County.  The District covers nearly 900 square miles and has educated and trained the region's diverse workforce since 1969.
About the LACCD Building Program
LACCD’s Building Program is a 14-year, $6 billion program funded mostly by taxpayer-approved bonds, supplemented by additional funding from the state of California.  With approximately $3 billion spent so far, the LACCD’s nine colleges are benefiting from brand new and renovated academic buildings, sports facilities, arts complexes, administrative buildings, child development centers, and parking structures.  The Building Program has completed hundreds of separate projects, with hundreds more in the planning or construction stages.

#   #   #

BUDGET ANALYSTS & CHILD ADVOCATES: A DANGEROUS DIVIDE?

    BUDGET AND CHILD ADVOCACY
    • Budget experts see a need for an overhaul of institutions and entitlements before we can focus specifically on kids, or any other specific issue.
    • Advocates, on the other hand, want to see more immediate changes that will help the people who are suffering right now.

    Sound familiar? That's a big canyon to cross in thought and approach.

 

by Alison Beth Waldman | SparkAction | http://bit.ly/sQeu5D

November 8, 2011 - Last month, the Urban Institute held a spirited discussion on “National Priorities and Children: How do They Come Together?"  Six distinguished professionals and a moderator—experts in federal budget policy and child and youth issues, respectively—came together to talk about what's really going on in Congress, what the public sees as priorities, and what it means for America’s 74 million children.

The panel was held in conjunction with the release of Today's Children, Tomorrow's America: Six Experts Face the Facts, an anthology of analysis from the panelists on how we might tackle the budget crisis while protecting children. It's a challenge that so far, our nation seems far from resolving.

Here are my take-aways. I'd love to hear yours.

Starting the Conversation

The paper and the accompanying panel are an attempt to bring child advocates and researchers together with budget experts to talk about the state of children and the state of the budget—and what we can do to create better out comes in both areas.

The event was spearheaded by Olivia Golden, Urban Institute Fellow and former staff member of the Department of Health and Human Services, who has long felt a disconnect between these classes of experts.

Getting them together in the same room is rare, Golden has observed—and for good reason, it appears: despite the fact that both ultimately want the same thing for America, getting these groups on same page about how we do that proved difficult.

What We Know

The short story: as statistics show, more kids now are starting out below the poverty line than in previous genearations. Therefore, more kids right from the start are disadvantaged in education, career opportunities, and life.

Margaret Simms of the Low-Income Working Families project shared that 10 percent of all children in the states are persistently poor.  It's become a cyclical problem and a dangerous course of events for both today's youth and tomorrow's workforce and citizenry.

There's plenty of research showing that experiences in the early years of a child's life are critical to how that child learns, interacts and succeeds later in life—in short, whether he or she will be ready for college, work and a successful adulthood. As Simms shares in her segment of the report, recent census data shows that more than one-fifth of all children under age 18 lived in poverty in 2010, 25 percent of those under age six were poor. By race and ethnicity, it looks worse.

And yet, as Olivia Golden pointed out, public spending today on education (and other things) is the reverse of what would make sense based on this research. The public invests less time and money and fewer resources in the early years than we do in the later years.

What's In Our Way?

Read the report:

As you'd expect, the panelists all agreed that it is complicated.

It may be in part that we as a nation struggle with the very idea of making investments in the future.  "There is a cultural and political mess of mindsets" that disallow us from looking ahead and investing as we should, said Charles Kolb, president of the Committee for Economic Development.

Kolb argued that unlike other countries, the U.S. has a harder time valuing human capital and investing in it. Our attention span as a country is short and we seem to have a hard time looking further ahead than the next fiscal year. With that mindset, it's difficult to really believe (especially in tight times) the connection between investing in children’s early years and education and a strong workforce.

Solution: Going corporate? To me the phrase "human capital"  sounds so corporate—it immediately got me thinking about business models and value propositions. And in fact the role of corporations and the private sector sparked some very interesting discussions during the panel.

Robert Reischauer, president of the Urban Institute and former director of the Congressional Budget Office, noted that business leaders are trained in forward-thinking strategies and making investments.  There is an opprtunity here,  he said, to bring that frame into our legislation by helping to train Congress to "think forward."

Failing that, he said, advocates may want to try bringing in powerful corporate players to advocate for causes like education.  I'm leery of inviting the private sector into education more than it is already, but Reischauer made a compelling case that it's something to consider if we can’t get Congress to pass federal laws.

Bigger, broader messaging: Raymond Scheppach, former executive director of the National Governors Association,  made the point that advocates will be more effective in rallying public support if we think (and talk) about a bigger picture. A strong approach in advocating and raising awareness of the budget process, he said,  is to make it universal—to remember that even though kids are our focus, the public and Congress have broad concerns. We can do better to make the case for how our issues fit in with others, from the environment and transportation to housing and on and on...

The state challenge: Jim Kolbe, senior transatlantic fellow of German Marshall Fund of the United States and former Member of the U.S. House of Representatives pointed out that education and some other child-focused programs are controled by the states, which means that we can't stop at the federal budget. While much of the money for the states came from the feds, the allocations are set by states and local boards. Therefore, bringing child-focused programs to the federal platform takes a shift in paradigm for federal policymakers, and an extra challenge for advocates. Perhaps this is the reason that the value of these programs is not clear to those putting them on the chopping block.    

"Canyons of Thought"

As I listened to this diverse group of experts, it was clear to me that there is a big difference in the mindset and approaches each, based largely on whether their background is in budget policy or child and youth issues.

Budget experts see a need for an overhaul of institutions, and large-scale structural changes that must happen before we can truly and productively focus on kids, or any specific issue, and allocate the money they need.  Advocates, on the other hand, want to see more immediate changes that will help the people who are suffering today, right now—they want to see those who are hungry today have food to eat today.

Observing these big canyons in thought and approach on this panel, I found myself wondering where that common ground lies where diverse thoughts can come together and solve this issue.  Yes, it is necessary to take many ideas and approaches into consideration when facing a problem of this scale. If we had the time, resources, and desires to continue to sit down and have the type of conversation that I observed on the pane;, that perhaps a mutual understanding, goal, and process could be determined.  However, in the desperation--and upcoming deadline--to make budget decisions for the year, a huge disconnect still remains.  It's a disconnect that lies at the core of our democracy and at the core of these diverse schools of thought, and it's a compromise that will take more than a bipartisan "Super Committee" to solve.

What do you think? Is this a problem? And how can we move forward? (And should we "go corporate?") Please share your thoughts in the Comment section below.

Get more on these experts' ideas in Today's Children, Tomorrow's America, and check out the panel for yourself in this video recording:


Alison Beth Waldman is Editorial Assistant at SparkAction. Email her at alison@sparkaction.org.

YESTERDAY’S ELECTION MAY SIGNAL A SWING TO THE CENTER

ELECTION highlights from an article by LA Times’ Paul West | http://lat.ms/tE4sMb

November 8, 2011, 10:50 p.m. - Reporting from Washington

  • Ohio voters overturned a controversial law that would have weakened public employee unions
  • Mississippians rejected an antiabortion "personhood" initiative in elections Tuesday that suggested at least a pause in the strong conservative Republican trend that swept Democrats from office in 2010.
  • One year after getting shellacked by Republicans, President Obama, whose poll ratings continue to languish, maintained a low profile.
  • In the Phoenix suburbs, state Senate President Russell Pearce, the architect of Arizona's contentious immigration law, was defeated by fellow Republican Jerry Lewis in the state's first recall election of a sitting lawmaker.
  • In Kentucky, Gov. Steve Beshear, a Democrat, won reelection over Republican David Williams, the state Senate president, and third-party candidate Gatewood Galbraith.
  • In Mississippi, voters chose another Republican, Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant, to succeed term-limited GOP Gov. Haley Barbour. Democratic nominee Johnny DuPree had sought to become the state's first African American governor of the modern era.
  • At the same time, Mississippi voters firmly rejected Initiative 26, which would have effectively defined birth control methods like IUDs and the morning-after pill as murder.
  • In another setback for newly emboldened Republican lawmakers, Maine voters repealed a law passed this year by the Republican Legislature that would have ended the tradition of same-day registration.
  • And in Iowa, Democrats won a special election for a vacant state Senate seat to keep Republicans from gaining control of the entire government in Des Moines.

Even as strategists warned against reading too much into the results of an off-year election, the 2011 contests were enough of a mixed bag to provide talking points for partisans on both sides.

Read the whole article: Elections nationwide suggest pause in Republican trend - latimes.com http://lat.ms/tE4sMb

A LIBRARIANS WORDS ARE BINDING

A son’s work speaks volumes about libraries

By Steve Lopez, LA Times columnist | http://lat.ms/uYWCpo

4LAKids notes: The California School Libraries Association will award Times columnists Steve Lopez and Hector Tobar their Advocacy Award – along with another for LAUSD Library Aide Franny Parrish  – this weekend at their annual convention in Pasadena | http://t.co/bWMhoKXE

Passion Project

“The notion that libraries could be replaced by Google is tantamount to suggesting that Americans are better off with vending machines instead of farmer's markets.”- L.A. Times columnist Steve Lopez's son, Andrew, in New Orleans. (Jeff Lopez / November 8, 2011)

November 9, 2011 - Several years ago a young man who was majoring in philosophy and French got a part-time job in his university library to help pay his bills. Over time, it occurred to him that he loved that hallowed sanctuary, surrounded each day by bound volumes of ideas and by records of our history. He knew then what he wanted to do with his life and went on to graduate school to study library science.

Today, he's a librarian at a college in New Orleans, helping rebuild a collection wiped out by Hurricane Katrina.

    His name is Andrew, by the way, and he's my son.

    So yes, I have a bias when it comes to librarians and libraries. I even got married in a library. And it's no fun watching the profession and the institution take hits these days, with libraries shut or scaled back and in some cases privatized. Meanwhile, I'm struck by the number of people who see no tragedy in this and think society no longer has much use for libraries.

    "We have the Internet; we don't need a library at all," Bill Maher said recently on his TV show. Then he added: "I don't know anyone who's been to a library since 1998."

    The comment was a little out of touch, to say the least. In this economy, I know a lot of people who rely on the library for books or videos or to research job prospects. Many libraries have seen greater traffic as more people need them. More than 1 million Californians visited a library on a single day in October 2010, according to a survey by the California Library Assn.

    Yet despite the interest and the need, the American Library Assn. says 60% of all libraries report that funding is either flat or decreasing, and 16% of all libraries have reduced their hours. I recently wrote about the Los Angeles Unified School District laying off more than 200 library aides and reducing the hours of nearly another 200. About 100 library aides were later reinstated, but even when they return to work, the number of district schools with no trained library staffer could still be in the hundreds.

    Last week, I was on a related topic, writing about a West Hollywood library page who lost her job.

    "It is obvious you have overlooked the constant drum beat of i pad and smart phones that have nailed the coffin on libraries," a reader wrote. "What is the sense in trying to prop up such relics…I am surprised that you do not see what is truly going on."

    What's going on, with all due respect, is the devaluation of great institutions that define a civil society and offer hope, security and opportunity even as economic disparity grows. The combination of a bad economy and overheated contempt for government threatens Social Security, Medicare, public and higher education, libraries and more.

    Fortunately, there are still some people out there who understand the value of a library. On Monday night, in a citywide Library Foundation program called Literary Feasts, 50 Angelenos hosted a dinner attended by an author, with hundreds of thousands of dollars raised for programs catering to children and teens in L.A.'s city libraries.

    I was the author at the Pacific Palisades home of Victoria Foote, a philanthropist and child education advocate who later sent me a passionate, 14-point bulletin on why libraries matter as much, if not more, than ever. Among other things, she said libraries serve as havens for many children, provide computer and Internet access for those who have neither, and unite community members of all ages for various events. And all of this is free.

    For me, there's a critical symbolic value to libraries as well. Their very existence tells us that books are so vital to our intellectual well-being that we keep them on display in special buildings and pass them between each other, as if they were community treasures.

    Last month, I had the privilege of watching my son teach a class in New Orleans, helping English students understand what's in their library and how — given the blur of information available today — to judge the credibility of the information they dug up.

    Libraries, my son says, "Organize, preserve, and provide access to the human record. I'm talking clay tablets, medieval manuscripts in unknown languages, and Nietzsche's laundry list, not to mention 'Meet the Fockers' and tons of other popular and not-so-popular materials of all sorts. They are increasingly one of the last free spaces for people to meet and do homework, hang out and read, attend a free lecture or a reading, or look for a job, and to get assistance along the way."

    Andrew said he shudders at the thought of a post-library world led by people self-educated on the Internet.

    "Do you really want these people planning policy, looking after your dying parents, brewing your coffee?  With a plethora of library catalogs, databases, and consortial borrowing mechanisms in place, rendering essentially every human document in existence accessible in about two weeks…there is no question that research and learning of a high quality is impossible without libraries. Exposure to new, foreign, and challenging ideas is absolutely vital for humankind.

    "Libraries are a public good and a civic responsibility.

    "They are about our future as much as they are our past....The notion that they could be replaced by Google is tantamount to suggesting that Americans are better off with vending machines instead of farmer's markets....Cut the libraries and you cut everything that goes with them, just as Thomas Jefferson knew well."

    That's my boy.

    LACCD Scandals: MILLIONS IN COLLEGE DISTRICT CLAIMS ‘UNALLOWABLE’, AUDIT SAYS

    by Larry Gordon – LA Times/LA Now | http://lat.ms/usxzbx

    November 7, 2011 |  4:46 pm - The state controller's office says the Los Angeles Community College District should be denied $23.7 million in state funding that the nine-campus system contends it is owed for collecting student fees and awarding financial aid for more than a decade. In a new audit report, the controller's office said the college district did not submit proper documentation of its cost claims and understated some savings and reimbursements.

    As a result, the office recommends that the college district receive only $2.5 million on top of the $2.27 million it already has received for the managerial costs of collecting student fees and waiving them for low-income students from July 1, 1998, through June 20, 2009. The additional $23.7 million the district is seeking “is unallowable,” the audit found.

    The district, which enrolls about 141,000 students, issued a statement Monday by its chief financial officer, Jeanette Gordon, saying that her office is reviewing the controller’s report and that she believes the matter is "primarily a dispute over documentation.”  Gordon said the district will be providing the proper paperwork and expects a favorable outcome.

    The Ideal Team: CALIFORNIA SCHOOL LIBRARIANS TO HONOR STEVE LOPEZ & HECTOR TOBAR, LAUSD LIBRARY AIDE FRANNY PARRISH AND SCHOOL LIBRARIAN CONNIE WILLIAMS FOR THEIR ADVOCACY

    by smf for 4LAKids

    Forget the Rose Bowl Game and the Big Parade – which will be on Jan 2 this year – and forget all the Little Old Ladies of Beach Boys' fame – from Friday to Sunday the librarians will be Occupying Pasadena – and the Queen City will Rock!

    This weekend is the 2011 California Library Association and California School Library Association Annual Conference & Exposition at the civic auditorium.

    The Friday Legislative Luncheon keynote, State Senator Alan Lowenthal, Chair of the Senate Education Committee, will share his unique perspective as part of the "Ideal Team".

    "The Ideal Team", according to California School Libraraians president Diane Alexander, "includes all the people and organizations which support our goals …which are to ensure that all California students and educators are effective users of ideas and information."

    At the luncheon, and later at the Sunday morning membership breakfast, California School Librarian Association Advocate Awards will be presented to:

    image HECTOR TOBAR - of the LA Times for shedding light on the importance of school libraries and the instruction that takes place in them.
    image STEVE LOPEZ - of the LA Times for his articles in support of teacher librarians and paraprofessionals.
    image FRANNY PARRISH - paraprofessional and equal access advocate extraordinaire. Parrish is the elementary librarian /'Library Aide' at Lohman Special Education Center in LAUSD.
    image And CONNIE WILLIAMS, teacher librarian chair of the Strong School Libraries campaign, advocating on both the state and national level for equal access to instruction for all 21st century students.

    CSLA president Diane Alexander continues: "Our free Cyber Sunday event at the Conference will bring together even more stakeholders in support of digital literacy. There will be workshops and a panel with representatives from Common Sense Media, PTA, CLRN, CUE, Facebook, Google, Yahoo, CDE, Creative Commons, and many others to discuss our common concerns. I have been inspired by these contacts with other organizations that have the same goals that we do. By working together we can make a difference for our students. We hope to see all of you in Pasadena to be part of the team.

    The “team” meeting will be our Membership Breakfast Sunday morning. You will hear what CSLA is doing for you, share your suggestions and hear how you can support our efforts to ensure that schools understand and value our expertise. Go team!"

    Tobar and Lopez are obvious honorees; their articles in the Times have been powerful messages in support of school libraries and librarians under attack in the face of budget cuts.

    Franny Parrish, a frequent correspondent with 4LAKids (or perhaps a co-conspirator) was surprised by the award: "I was convinced it had been a mistake. An award for me from the California School Library Association? For what? I am not still not sure …maybe for being disrespectful to self important people with titles that are too big for their pants?"

    Connie Williams, nationally certified Teacher Librarian in Petaluma City Schools in the Bay Area, Past President 2008/09 at California School Library Association and current Legislation Chair of the American Association of School Librarians – and blogger @ CIRCULATE THIS!: Stories From The School Library http://circulatethis.posterous.com/ is a powerful national voice for school libraries.

    Register for the FREE CYBER SUNDAY Event here.

    Tuesday, November 08, 2011

    LAUSD HAS ITS FIRST ROSE PRINCESS: Sarah Zuno, Franklin HS, Class of ‘12

     

    By: Monica Carazo |LAUSD Journal | http://bit.ly/s9Bpxx

    October 17, 2011 - On a cold, crisp recent morning in Pasadena, seven young ladies stood poised on a stage decorated with urns of red roses, their lives about to change forever.

    In front of the historic Tournament House, these Tournament of Rose Princesses sported salon-perfect hair, identical sheath dresses and sparkling smiles, waiting for THE announcement of the 94th Rose Queen.

    For Sarah Zuno, a senior at Benjamin Franklin High School in the LAUSD, she was already a winner. She is the first ever LAUSD coed to serve on the Tournament of Roses’ coveted Royal Court.

    Although Drew Washington was named the 2012 Rose Queen, Sarah is already reigning supreme throughout the District with this historic appointment. The newly selected Royal Court will reign for an entire year. As ambassadors of the Tournament of Roses she and the other members of the Court will attend more than 150 community and media functions leading up to the 123rd Rose Parade and 98th Rose Bowl Game on Monday, January 2, 2012.

    “This whole experience has been amazing,” beamed Bertha Zuno, Sarah’s mother.

    In support of this momentous occasion, Sarah’s classmates recently hosted a royal rally in her honor. Her regal send off was complete with Franklin High School’s Mighty Panthers band, the school’s cheerleaders, and screaming cheers of good luck and well wishes.

    Sarah, who lives in Los Angeles, possesses a resume worthy of any royal court. She plays on her school’s varsity basketball team and the softball team. She is a fluent Spanish speaker, a student mentor and the school’s Glee Club co-president. In her free time, she enjoys dancing, singing, playing the piano and reading. She plans to study communications, journalism or English literature in college, and possibly pursue a career in corporate law.

     (left) Sarah Zuno, 17, with Rose Queen, Drew Washington, 16, from Flintridge Sacred Heart Academy (center) and the rest of the 2012 Tournament of Roses Royal Court. 

    “This organization has been wonderful and so well organized,” added Alex Zuno, Sarah’s father.

    The announcement on October 18 follows a month-long process in which approximately 1,000 Pasadena-area young women participated. The lucky seven were whittled down from 34 finalists. Selections were based on a range of qualities including public speaking, ability, poise, academic achievement, community involvement and personality.

    Historically, the boundaries for the selection of Rose Queen and her court have been limited to the exclusive communities of San Marino and Pasadena. However, a representative in the Tournament of Roses Association executive committee wrote a proposal to include Highland Park. This year, for the first time, the committee voted in favor of extending the application process to include schools in Highland Park. Benjamin Franklin High School sits in the heart of the Highland Park community.

    On her way to the Royal Court, Sarah learned about the noble process for Rose Queen during a school visit from the 2011 Rose Queen Evanne Friedmann and a Rose Princess in mid September with a presentation about the Tournament of Roses Royal Court try outs.

    Mrs. Zuno shared that Sarah was always” very confident.” “I can do this,” Sarah told her mom.

    “We could not be more proud of the seven young ladies that will be representing the Tournament of Roses as the 2012 Royal Court, “ said Amy Wainscott, Chair of the Queen and Court Committee. “They are outstanding role models and will be wonderful ambassadors for the Tournament of Roses.

    As part of their ceremonial ensemble, the seven young ladies of the Royal Court each received a pearl necklace from Mikimoto, provider of the stately crowns and tiaras. The six princesses will also be fitted for their formal gowns, which will be unveiled at the coronation ceremony scheduled October 27 at the Pasadena Convention Center.

    “Her father and I are so proud of her.” She is the first to represent the District and we couldn’t be more thrilled. The school staff, her principal, teachers and her friends have been so supportive and accommodating,” said Mrs. Zuno.

    After THE announcement was made, the Rose Queen was surrounded by her court of princesses, smiling and waving before their families and friends. The sun peeked through the clouds, and yes, the roses were blooming.

    Sarah’s princess duties had begun.

    LET’S COME TOGETHER IN NOVEMBER 2012 TO RESTORE EDUCATION FUNDING:

    By Carol Kocivar  in Thoughts on Public Education/ToPED | http://bit.ly/uclE7s

    Posted on 11/06/11 • It’s time now to unite for next November.

    Yes, November 2012. It may seem like a long way off, but it’s not. In just a year, our state will have a potential opportunity our children can’t afford for us to miss.

    Carol Kocivar | KQED >

    That’s when millions of Californians will go to the polls, where they could have a chance to do what our legislators have so far been unable to do: reverse the chronic underfunding of our public schools.

    So far, several well-regarded organizations have been exploring potential ballot measures. Some deal exclusively with education funding, some with broader tax increases or school reforms, and some with larger state budget reforms.

    California State PTA is calling for a united effort to qualify and pass a state ballot measure that focuses – first and foremost – on restoring funding for educational programs that have been cut or eliminated.

    Along with other groups, we’re raising awareness about the importance of this effort, and urging state leaders, organizations, businesses, and individuals to come together around a plan that meets the needs of students.

    In our most recent annual survey, PTA members and leaders from throughout the state singled out adequate state funding for education as a resounding priority: 89.2 percent said it is extremely important; 98.6 percent said it was important or extremely important.

    No other issue came close to this level of support.

    In addition, our survey showed that parents are most interested in making sure students have access to a full range of programs and services. In response to a list of nine specific education topics, the five top-rated responses were:

    • Access to a full curriculum that includes the arts for every student;
    • Smaller class sizes;
    • More science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM);
    • Strengthening teacher and administrator effectiveness; and
    • Reducing the dropout rate.

    In another section of the survey, access to physical education also rated extremely high with parents.

    Parents and family members know that what matters most is what happens on the ground in our schools and in our children’s classrooms each day. While talk in Sacramento and Washington, D.C., often centers on the reform of the week, our members have spoken loudly and clearly: Schools need adequate funding so that every child has access to a complete educational program that includes physical education, arts, and STEM (science technology, engineering, and math), as well as counselors, libraries, and smaller class sizes. We think other systemic reforms to the education system that frequently are discussed in Sacramento are important as well, but they may be better addressed through legislation, instead of a ballot measure.

    In PTA we’re passionate, but we’re also realistic. We understand it typically takes a lot of money to qualify a statewide ballot initiative, especially in this polarized political climate. But that doesn’t mean we won’t put all of our energy toward working with others to try. While we are not an organization that can write a big check to get a measure on the ballot, we have something even more valuable: our members.

    Together we are nearly 1 million parents, educators, grandparents, aunts, uncles, students, and others who care deeply about the damage inflicted by year after year of budget cuts. We will fight for every child, and we can help to create the broad public support and true grassroots engagement that will be needed to work with others and help qualify and pass a ballot measure.

    Of course, any successful ballot measure must include new revenues. But we know that public education is our collective responsibility and that we must all step up to restore its promise.

    Passing a measure won’t be easy, but we think the majority of Californians are up for the challenge.

    Now, more than ever, we must act to secure the financing for public schools that will allow us to fulfill our promise of providing a quality education for all students. We look forward to forging a united effort focused on this goal. Please visit our website to find out how you can help and keep up to date on our progress.

    Carol Kocivar of San Francisco is president of the California State PTA. She has served as president-elect, vice president for communications, an education commission member, and on numerous committees with the California State PTA. A past president of the San Francisco Second District PTA, Kocivar has worked as a journalist, attorney, and ombudsperson for special education. The California State PTA has nearly 1 million members throughout the state volunteering on behalf of public schools, children, and families, with the motto “Every child, one voice.” The PTA also advocates at national, state, and local levels for education and family issues.

    Monday, November 07, 2011

    TEEN DEATHS SPUR SUICIDE OUTREACH AT AGOURA HIGH SCHOOL

    By Susan Abram, Daily News Staff Writer | http://bit.ly/uY4JHT

    "DAN" is spelled out on a hillside above Agoura High School, as seen on Nov. 3, 2011, in remembrance of senior Dan Behar, who took his own life Oct. 31. (Andy Holzman/Daily News Staff Photographer)

    11/07/2011 01:00:00 AM PST - AGOURA HILLS -- A mother's chilling wail pierced the night, until even the most expressionless among the teenagers began to sob.

    Her cries came during an impromptu candlelight vigil last week for a 17-year-old Agoura High School student, Dan Behar, who sent his classmates a text message that said goodbye and where to find his body. Then he drove his car down an embankment in Malibu State Park.

    "Turn to your left and turn to your right and talk to somebody," a teenage girl implored the crowd of young, illuminated faces during the candlelight vigil for Behar, and for two other young men with ties to the school who had died recently.

    "We don't want this to happen again."

    Behar was among several youths who have died in the last few weeks, most by taking their own lives.

    A few days earlier, Joshua Feinberg, 21, also a former Agoura High student, was found at the bottom of Rindge Dam in Malibu.

    An official cause of death is still pending for Griffen Kramer, 18, a quarterback at Thousand Oaks High, who was found dead Oct. 30 after falling asleep at a friend's house in Thousand Oaks. Kramer was a former Agoura High student. School officials said his death might have been related to alcohol poisoning.

    In mid-October, David Barseghian, a 17-year-old senior from Northridge Academy High, died when he jumped from an 18-story building at the Trillium Towers Center in Woodland Hills. The teen was clutching a rosary when he jumped, police said.

    And in August, Calabasas High School student Amelia Schiff, 17, also took her life the evening of the first day of school.

    The deaths have caused pain and confusion for students and staff at local high schools.

    And there is one question raised again and again, not only within the Las Virgenes Unified School District, but countywide as well: What is happening among the youth?

    "There are lots and lots of questions we will never have answers to," said Richard Lieberman, a psychologist for the Los Angeles Unified School District. "It's complex."

    Lieberman was among the founders of the suicide prevention services within the LAUSD nearly 25 years ago. The services began when the number of suicides tripled in the 1980s and became the third leading cause of death for high school kids in the United States.

    For youths between the ages of 10 and 24, suicide continues to be the third leading cause of death, according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Nearly 4,400 youths take their lives each year.

    Between 1994 and 2003, there was an average of 26 youths each year who died in Los Angeles County as a result of suicide, Lieberman said. The average declined to 13 per year between 2004 to 2009, he said.

    "It is such a hard topic to talk about and very often parents don't wish to discuss it as a suicide," Lieberman said. "There are no predictors of youth suicide."

    But he said there are factors that can be considered, such as mental illness or chronic depression, a history of trauma and loss, breakups, alcohol and substance abuse, grief that transforms into anger, and a feeling of believing someone else is at fault. A loss of dignity that comes from being bullied also can be a factor, as well as arguments with parents.

    In recent years, social networking has played a role in death by suicide too.

    "In some cases, the students went home and went on their MySpace.com account and told everyone what they were going to do," Lieberman said.

    The number of suicide attempts remains high as well, and Lieberman said at LAUSD it is highest among 14-year-old Latina girls. CDC statistics confirm the rate is highest among Latina teens at the national level as well.

    "We see it within all socioeconomic groups and all cultures. That's the alarming part," Lieberman said.

    Though they are still in school, teens are also affected by the Great Recession and the accompanying unemployment and loss of income and job opportunity. How their parents manage those stresses can have a great impact on the child's sense of security, Lieberman said.

    Donald Zimring, superintendent for the Las Virgenes Unified School District, said it is difficult to pinpoint why so many deaths have occurred in the area, and why so many youths choose to end their lives.

    "I think you've got a generation of kids that are under pressures that we haven't seen in the past," Zimring said. "I think it's a combination of things.

    "There were clearly issues outside of the school."

    Yet, the issues surface at school and both students and school leaders have begun to be more open and engaged in helping young people struggling with issues that can lead to suicide.

    Last month Agoura High held its first-ever Friendship Week, with the goal of making the campus a friendly, welcoming place, and to remind students they have a support system within the school.

    Zimring said despite last week's tragedy, he credits the students for doing what they were supposed to do. When classmates received Behar's text message, many contacted 911 or went to an adult immediately.

    "When this incident occurred on Monday, everyone called to get this boy help," Zimring said.

    He said he hoped students who attended last week's vigil do not come away glorifying the experience, but see the consequences, the permanence, of taking one's own life.

    "At this age, understanding what life is about and the permanency of hurting yourself, they don't get it," Zimring said. Behar's death "was a terrifying moment."

    If you go

    Agoura High School, (28545 West Driver Avenue, Agoura Hills) is hosting an informational meeting for parents on the subject of teen suicide, on Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2011 at 7 p.m. 818-889-1262.

    Here are some additional resources:

    Suicide Prevention Center: 877-7CRISIS (877-727-4747)

    Teen Line: 800-TLC-TEEN (800-852-8336)

    Trevor Lifeline -- For gay and questioning youths: 866-4UTREVOR (866-488-7386)

    Tips for parents and suicide prevention: From the LAUSD's School of Mental Health Suicide Prevention Services and the National Alliance on Mental Illness).

    • Talk to your child about suicide. Don't be afraid; you will not be “putting ideas into their heads.” Asking for help is the single skill that will protect your child.
    • Help them to identify and connect to caring adults to talk to when they need guidance.
    • Know the risk factors and warning signs of suicide. Because mental disorders or substance abuse often times accompanies suicidal behavior, parents can watch for certain signs, including extreme personality change, loss of interest in activities, withdrawal from friends and family and neglect of personal appearance.
    • Listen without judging. Allow for the discussion of experiences, thoughts, and feelings. Be prepared for expression of intense feelings. Try to understand the reasons for considering suicide without taking a position about whether or not such behavior is justified. Ask open-ended questions.
    • Supervise constantly. Do not leave your child alone.
    • Ask if your child has a plan to kill themselves, and if so, remove means. As long as it does not put the caregiver in danger, attempt to remove the suicide means such as a firearm, knife or pills.
    • Take action. It is crucial to get professional help for your child and the entire family.

    Sunday, November 06, 2011

    REFORM/REVENUE PLAN FOR ‘12 BALLOT: Higher taxes coupled with finance, personnel reforms

    By John Fensterwald - Educated Guess | http://bit.ly/rSMjg2 

    11/04/11 • A  partnership of education, parent, and business groups is aiming to put on the November 2012 ballot an initiative combining sweeping education reforms with a tax increase dedicated to preschool to twelfth grade, called The 2012 Kids Education Plan.

    In a short statement (see below), the dozen groups used the code words for fundamental changes in school funding and personnel laws like teacher tenure without yet citing specifics: “a student centered finance system, true transparency, significant workforce reforms, and new investments in education through a statewide broad based revenue source and lowering the voter threshold on local revenue” (a reference to the current two-thirds majority needed to pass a parcel tax).

    Joint statement by the groups and individuals in The 2012 Kids Education Plan.

    Joint statement by the groups and individuals in The 2012 Kids Education Plan.

    Ted Lempert, president of Oakland-based Children Now, said the groups were considering a tax that would raise $6 billion to $8 billion annually for education – the equivalent of roughly an additional $1,000 to $1,330 per student – an amount that would recover much of the state funding that has been cut over the past three years. While a big ask in a recession, it would still fall shy of raising California’s per-student funding to the national average.

    Those who have signed on to the effort so far include one member of the Education Coalition, the Association of California School Administrators; Children Now; Bay Area Council, a San Francisco-based business group; United Way of Greater Los Angeles; Education Trust-West; Public Advocates; San Francisco-based Silver Giving Foundation; the new parent groups   Educate Our State, Educacy and Parent Revolution; and three prominent superintendents: Mike Hanson of Fresno Unified, Chris Steinhauser of Long Beach Unified, and Tony Smith of Oakland Unified.

    At this point, Lempert said, it’s still in the discussion phase. Over the past month, Lempert said, he and others have reached out to other groups that have signaled interest but have not committed, like the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, California PTA, and the California Teachers Association (no official comment yet from the CTA). Also, “key folks in the Brown administration are interested in what we are pushing,” Lempert said. “I hope they get behind this.”

    The presidential election ballot is expected to be jammed with initiatives, including pension and state governance reforms. Lots of ideas for tax increases –  reconfiguring Proposition 13, hitting up millionaires, taxing oil production to support higher education – are floating around, though still in flux. Lempert said that a broad-based tax that business groups could support, focused on pre-K to grade 12 education, would most appeal to voters and have the best chance of passing. With big backers behind it, a Kids Education Plan would dominate, if not chase off, other initiatives.

    If $6 billion, tied to reforms, sounds familiar, that’s because Gov. Schwarzenegger’s bipartisan Committee on Education Excellence, led by Ted Mitchell, a Democrat, recommended the same amount and strategy four years ago. Schwarzenegger blew off the committee’s report, but the ideas – many stemming from the voluminous studies Getting Down to Facts in 2007 – and the approach have been simmering on back burners. “The concept is to do it all together, to put it in one package and get it done,” Lempert said. “You can get more money for education if it includes reform.”

    The need to settle on the initiative’s wording and to start collecting signatures by January at the latest leaves only about two months to reach agreement on which reforms and which tax. Consensus will demand few hard-and-fast positions.

    A student-centered finance system with transparency is shorthand for replacing the complex system of legacy-based funding, with dozens of categorical grants, with a system based on student needs, with more money for poor students and English learners.

    The principle behind workplace reforms, Lempert said, is removing obstacles in state law preventing districts from exerting more control over hiring, including tenure, and promoting and dismissing staff. Three groups in the coalition – United Way of Greater Los Angeles, Public Advocates, and Education Trust-West – have pushed for more rigorous evaluation systems. Public Advocates also represents plaintiffs in the suit Campaign for Quality Education, charging that the state inadequately funds its schools.

    Several key bills now before the Legislature would address some of the initiative’s key reforms: Assemblywoman Julia Brownley’s AB 18 on school financing and Assemblyman Felipe Fuentes’ AB 5 on teacher evaluations. But, reflecting both the compressed timing and uncertainty over whether the Legislature will pass strong bills, the coalition intends to write the reforms into the initiatives, leaving perhaps companion bills to the Legislature.

    In an email, California State PTA Executive Director Paul Richman said that the PTA disagrees with this approach, while expecting to support one ballot measure funding education next year. “We believe new funding to restore programs that have been cut for students is foremost and that other potential reforms, many of which we’d get behind, can be accomplished legislatively,” he said.

    Dennis Cima, vice president of the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, another likely ally of the effort, said that the organization agrees with many of the priorities  in the initiative and could support a broad-based tax, but will be watching to see what else is being proposed for next November. Noting that an initiative can be a blunt instrument, he said, “Is the ballot the best way?”

    It may be if the intent is to ensure that reforms are passed, not watered down or frittered away by the Legislature.

     

    ●●smf's 2¢: Children Now does good work, its well thought out Children’s Agenda for California is a paradigm for excellent thinking in progressive Ed Reform. However the totality of  The 2012 Kids Education Plan is included in the pink box above.

    Saturday, November 05, 2011

    LAUSD COPS TRY TO KEEP UP WITH ILLEGAL STREET VENDORS

    Esther Kang | Contributor | Neon Tommy/the online publication of the Annenberg School for Communication & Journalism   | http://bit.ly/w1OA36

    At least one district employee expressed concern' with Diana's Ice Cream truck, which is seen in this photo vending closer to a school than the law allows. (Esther Kang)
    At least one district employee expressed concern' with Diana's Ice Cream truck, which is seen in this photo vending closer to a school than the law allows. (Esther Kang)

    November 2, 2011 - A shrill bell punctures the enveloping silence across the John Muir Middle School campus at three o’clock, ushering out hoards of loud and uniformed sixth, seventh and eighth graders.

    Just a few steps outside the front gate, the sound of another familiar bell jingles more subtly.

    It is the ice cream man. A stout Hispanic man pushes his cart and inches closer to the gate, where the kids are spilling out like grains of sand.

    The surrounding sidewalks resemble something of a buffet line. One lady is selling Doritos out of a large garbage bag and sodas out of a blue icebox. Another is carrying prepackaged pink and blue cotton candy and a collection of inflatable toys. Another is preparing made-to-order Mexican creamed corn from a metal cart.

    All of these vendors are well within 500 feet of the school. City of Los Angeles municipal code prohibits all forms of vending within 500 feet of schools between the hours of 7:30 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. on school days.

    “It’s a serious problem,” concedes Los Angeles School Police Department Sgt. Ken Kimbrough. “Particularly in certain parts of the city, vending is a red target.”

    This area – on Vermont and Slauson – is definitely one of them.

    As the second largest public school system in the country, the Los Angeles Unified School District holds nearly 1,000 regular schools; the number of police and patrol officers overseeing the campuses is about 250, according to Kimbrough.

    “Each officer gives a warning or two if the vendor is too close to the school,” he explains. “They’ll tell them to move across the street, especially if it’s a new person. After the first strike, the officer will probably ticket the vendor.”

    The effectiveness of issuing warnings is questionable, says Alma Richardson, a Los Angeles Department of Transportation employee.

    Richardson has been working as the crossing guard for eight years next to Budlong Avenue Elementary School, which is just behind John Muir Middle School. During this time, she says she has observed a repetitive game of cat-and-mouse between school police and street vendors.

    “When these guys see the blue and white car, they’ll move,” she recounts. “And when it leaves, they’ll come right back.”

    Richardson is unable to hide her distaste for one particular vendor, who is just across the street from her crosswalk.

    “This is the main one, and this is their corner,” she says, pointing to a yellow metallic van with an enormous decal of a skipping SpongeBob plastered next to the window. Its menu is something of a Hansel-and-Gretel paradise: it sells anything and everything, including Skittles, Twix bars, ring pops, hot dogs, Doritos and banana splits.

    Diana’s Ice Cream, as it’s called, claims that spot every day from 1:30 p.m. to 4 p.m., from the time elementary kids get out of school until the “big kids” are dismissed, Richardson says.

    For many of the van’s regular customers, buying junk food is not so taboo. Rather, most of its younger customers are accompanied by their parents.

    A lady approaches the van with her two little girls. The older of the two, about 6 six years old, takes out her own wallet and shows the vendor a crumpled dollar.

    “Mira, mira!”

    She directs the man’s attention to the ring pop behind the glass. Next, she points to a spicy mango lollipop. The exchange is made, and the mother takes her under her arm.

    Yesenia Cordova, whose son Juan is a fifth grader at Budlong Avenue Elementary School, says she gives her son $2 every day for after-school snacks.

    “I don’t have any problem with it; at least it’s sealed,” she acknowledges as Juan munches on flaming hot cheetos. “But I won’t let him buy food from those people selling corn and stuff from their carts. They touch money and then touch the food with those same hands. I don’t see a sink there.”

    For Korayma Arevalo, a senior at Manual Arts High School, it’s not a matter of packaging; it’s about authenticity.

    “I’m not gonna buy something that’s been packaged for months,” Areyalo says.

    About once a week, she buys homemade ice cream from a street vendor who passes by her school afterschool. She likes it because it’s fresh, familiar and not offered in stores, she says.

    “They made it that morning,” Areyalo says. “I know so because most of my family are street vendors. I know how they prepare things, so I assume other people do it the same way.”

    As young students continue to flock to these illegal sidewalk vendors every day after school, Richardson worries that law enforcement officers are not keeping up with the pervasive issue.

    “It’s not getting any better; it’s worse on some days,” she said. “But it’s definitely not getting any better.”

    BACKSLIDING ON SCHOOL REFORM: The latest effort in Congress to overhaul No Child Left Behind would only make things worse.

    LA Times Editorial | http://lat.ms/vmRPh2

    U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, flanked by Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, left, and superintendent John Deasy, right, speaks at a news conference following a board meeting of the Los Angeles Unified School District, in downtown Los Angeles on Oct. 11. (Reed Saxon / AP Photo)

    U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, flanked by Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, left, and superintendent John Deasy, right, speaks at a news conference following a board meeting of the Los Angeles Unified School District, in downtown Los Angeles on Oct. 11. (Reed Saxon / AP Photo)

    5 Nov 2011 (Guy Fawkes Day) - When it comes to federal school reform, the overriding lesson is to be careful what you wish for. The No Child Left Behind Act, signed into law in 2002, ushered in an era of badly needed educational accountability, requiring schools to improve the lot of disadvantaged, black and Latino students who up to that point had been shorted academically in almost every way. But the law was so poorly written, so laden with rigid, arbitrary standards, that it had the effect of narrowing school curriculums, branding good schools as failures and, in fact, leaving many of the most troubled students behind. Schools and states have justifiably been crying for relief.

    Guy Fawkes mask>

    (having nothing to to do with this story) 

    The congressional overhaul of No Child Left Behind is four years overdue, but now  that a bipartisan bill has passed the Senate Health, Labor, Education and Pensions Committee, we wish it would go away. The legislation sponsored by Sens. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa) and Michael B. Enzi (R-Wyo.) might best be called an anti-accountability act. Instead of replacing rigid goals with more sensible ones, it would do away with almost all goals for the vast majority of schools.

    States would still have to test most students, but they wouldn't be required to do anything about the results except in the lowest-performing 5% of schools, and in an additional 5% with the biggest achievement gaps between white and minority students. That would be fine if 90% of the nation's schools were doing solid work. But thousands of schools across the country that do not fit into either category are still badly in need of improvement.

    Under the Harkin-Enzi bill, there would be no academic standards for schools to meet. To be sheltered from consequences, and thus from any incentive to improve, they would just have to stay out of those two 5% zones, no matter how many students were dropping out or failing to grasp the basics. The bill calls on states to develop goals for schools' "continuous improvement" but leaves it to states to decide what that improvement looks like.

    The overreaction is in ways understandable. No Child Left Behind pressured schools to teach to standardized tests in math and reading. While those tests measure basic skills, they are limited indicators of educational quality. High-performing schools should be given a break from the relentless emphasis on test scores, perhaps by not having to administer them every year. For that matter, all schools should be judged on multiple, relevant factors, not just test scores. School visits by educational experts might be useful, as Gov. Jerry Brown has suggested, along with assessments of graduation rates and portfolios of student work. All students should have instruction in arts, science, languages, research and writing, academic areas that have been given short shrift under the federal accountability mandate.

    That's not what the Harkin-Enzi bill would do, though. Instead, it reauthorizes the same old testing-only regimen while setting no standards for what students should learn or how much they should improve. If only 10% of schools at most might have to change their practices as a result of the tests, why bother testing at all?

    The No Child Left Behind Act was the result of collaboration between Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.) and President George W. Bush, who shared a commitment to bettering the lot of poor and minority students. The reform movement gained momentum under the prodding of business leaders who found that too many graduates of the public school system were lacking the skills for even relatively mundane jobs.

    Today's bipartisan support for virtually dismantling the law comes from a different sort of collaboration. Deeply conservative Republicans are looking to rein in the role of the federal government; and education, which traditionally has fallen under the purview of states, is a prime target. Some Democrats are heeding the call of the national teachers unions, which have been complaining about the law since its inception. Harkin appears willing to do whatever it takes to pass the bill, even if it means weakening it to the point of irrelevance.

    The bill's passage has been given impetus by U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan's plan to grant waivers from the existing law's more cumbersome provisions if states agree to certain conditions. Critics say, with justification, that the administration is substantially rewriting the law rather than interpreting it, but in the absence of congressional action, something had to be done. With the vast majority of the nation's schools on target to be declared failures, even though many were falling short in very minor ways, the accountability movement was on the verge of collapsing. And if the Harkin-Enzi bill becomes law without the addition of some meaningful standards, that's more or less what will happen.

    Friday, November 04, 2011

    NATION'S REPORT CARD: CA Schools' Struggle 'Against a Riptide'

    Themes in the News for the week of Oct. 31-Nov. 4, 2011 by UCLA IDEA | http://bit.ly/uX5gWc

    4 Nov 2011 - The Nation’s Report Card was released this week and the scores don’t look good for California. But first, how did the rest of the nation do?

    The National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP, http://nationsreportcard.gov/ tested a sample of 4th and 8th graders from each state in reading and mathematics. This year, 40 percent of 4th graders and 35 percent of 8th graders scored proficient or above in math, and 34 percent of students in both grades scored proficient in reading. These scores reflect a 1- or 2-percentage point increase from 2009, the last year the tests were administered (New York Times, Christian Science Monitor).

    The slight increases continue a 20-year trend during which 4th graders have posted a 5-percent increase in proficiency. Mathematics scores in the past two decades have shown greater improvement with a 27-percent increase in 4th graders demonstrating proficiency.

    The relatively modest progress and low proficiency rates on the NAEP contrast with performance on many state tests. Because NAEP’s definitions for basic, proficient and advanced are different from various states’ tests, students can be classified as “proficient” on state exams but fall to “basic” on NAEP (Washington Post). It is also the case that state tests have high-stakes consequences. These high-stakes consequences lead schools to target a limited set of skills and focus attention on test preparation, so state test scores might inch up at the expense of an overall high-quality education for students. Recent news of testing irregularities in Washington D.C., Atlanta and California also suggest that high stakes testing promotes an environment where scores are vulnerable to manipulation. Some believe that NAEP is a more reliable measure for judging state and federal policy because there are not consequences for individual students, teachers, or schools and only states are reported on and ranked.

    Here in California, 34 percent of 4th graders and 25 percent of 8th graders were proficient in math. In reading, 25 percent of 4th graders and 24 percent of 8th graders were proficient (between 9 percent and 10 percent behind the nation). These figures reflect marginal improvement from 2009 (San Francisco Chronicle, Thoughts on Public Education).

    California has been near the bottom of NAEP rankings for a while now, in both reading and math. This time around it’s worse with the state tied with Louisiana at 49th in 8th-grade reading, just one point above Mississippi.

    Regardless of one’s opinion of NAEP as a high-profile (if not high-stakes) test, it’s clear that California public schools lag far behind the rest of the nation in promoting core skills in reading and mathematics. Of course, some progress is better than no progress, but the current rate of improvement means that more decades will pass by with large proportions of California students unable to demonstrate critical academic skills.

    Perhaps mindful that some California schools are considering cutting another week from the school year to meet their budgets (Los Angeles Times, San Jose Mercury News), State Superintendant of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson said of the NAEP results:

    Our students are still making progress, even as they swim against a riptide of crowded classrooms and deep budget cuts to our schools. Asked to do more with less, students, teachers, school employees, and administrators have delivered. Imagine how much more they could accomplish—and how many more students would share in this progress—with the resources they deserve (CDE).

    FORMER SCHOOL BOARD PRESIDENT CANTER HEADS GREEN DOT CHARTERS + smf’s 2¢

    Howard Blume | LA Times/LA Now | http://lat.ms/taPzzQ

    Photo: Marlene Canter in 2007. Credit: Ricardo DeAratanha / Los Angeles TimesPhoto: Marlene Canter in 2007. Credit: Ricardo DeAratanha / Los Angeles Times

    November 3, 2011 |  8:01 pm - Former Los Angeles school board President Marlene Canter will head the governing board for Green Dot Public Schools, one of the nation’s largest charter school groups, the organization announced Thursday.

    The locally based nonprofit operates schools mostly in the low-income, heavily minority areas of south and southwest Los Angeles. Its best-known effort is the takeover of Locke High School, near Watts, where academic achievement and enrollment have improved substantially although the school’s test scores remain low overall.

    This fall, Green Dot took control of Clay Middle School and half of Jordan High School.

    Canter succeeds Shane Martin, dean of the Loyola Marymount University School of Education.

    Green Dot’s new vice-chair is UCLA Vice Chancellor Kevin Reed. Reed was the head attorney for the Los Angeles Unified School District when Canter served as board president. Some advocates for charter schools, which are publicly financed, managed independently of the school system, viewed them then as not sufficiently supportive of charters.

    Separately, a recently troubled local school-management group also announced a new leader this week.

    L.A.’s Promise, which manages three Los Angeles schools, announced its new executive will be Veronica Melvin. She had been working as chief operating officer of Communities for Teaching Excellence, a new local nonprofit advocacy organization funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

    Founding L.A.’s Promise Director Mike McGalliard had recently resigned for undisclosed reasons.

    L.A.’s Promise recently came under scrutiny for a disorganized opening this fall of Manual Arts High School. The group converted the school from year-round operation to a traditional calendar a year earlier than previously planned. The benefit was a longer school year for each student. The drawback was a campus more crowded than at any time in its history, which teachers said created numerous problems.

    School district officials recently reasserted some control over Manual Arts, but L.A.’s Promise is still managing the campus on a day-to-day basis.

     

    2cents CUE THE IRONY POLICE:  Marlene Canter is currently a City of Los Angeles Ethics Commissioner – a job I would think would fill all one’s waking hours and challenge the sleeping ones.

    In 2006-07 LAUSD Board of Education Board President Canter and LAUSD General Counsel  Kevin Reed successfully led the effort in court to defeat Mayor Villaraigosa’s takeover of LAUSD under AB 1381.

    At that time Green Dot Public Schools Founder/Chairman/CEO Steve Barr (along with UTLA President A.J. Duffy) led the effort in support of Mayor Tony (laughing over Marlene’s left shoulder in the picture above) …initially though Barr’s “Small Schools Alliance” and its Ging-grinchian “Contract to Transform LA. Schools” (which morphed into Mayor Tony’s Partnership for LA Schools and his “Schoolhouse” reform® plan) …and also produced the LA Parents Union which begat Parent Revolution.  Barr was the sole appellant in support of AB1381 when the challenge reached the California Supreme Court.

    Barr has since left Green Dot to form Green Dot America which became The Future is Now (FIN) Schools - which has  as their logo not a green dot – but green type and a red-white-and-blue dot.

    Duffy is starting his own charter school.

    If the bedfellows were strange then, they are estranged now. And it all becomes stranger still.

    JOIN PTA. If not now, when?

    by smf in the AALA Weekly Update  - week of Nov 7, 2011 | http://bit.ly/tUcz8I

    image

    ●●smf adds: If you are not at a school, or try as you can - your school doesn’t have a PTA - I invite you to join your voice with our one voice for all children and students and join Golden State PTA.

    Thank you and Onward!